Feel free to state exactly WHERE in tier (?) you would place it. It will not only help place it more accurately but save repetitive posts in the Tier thread once it is decided which tier to place it in.
Kind of hard to decide... because of the inconsistency (which isn't necessarily terrible, but you can definitely tell where the different cameras where used, even within the same general scene) I can't decide if it's a tier zero or tier 1 -- if it was tier 1, it'd definitely be at the top of it, no doubt... or low Tier 0.
None of the scenes look bad at all though (the issue is that it's noticeable and not that any shots look bad at all), it's just the distinct changes that don't seem to have any reason (like using the 35mm for only certain types of shots) -- it seemed somewhat random as to what was used when at times and because of that became a mild distraction (once you know it's hard to stop noticing!).
I watched it with 4 friends on Wednesday and I don't think any of them could tell... they all thought it looked great, so it's likely a case of being too picky. I'll go with Tier 0, because there is little that looks as good overall on either format that I've seen -- definitely some of the best stuff all around though.
A forum community dedicated to home theater owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about home audio/video, TVs, projectors, screens, receivers, speakers, projects, DIY’s, product reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!