AVS Forum banner
  • Our native mobile app has a new name: Fora Communities. Learn more.

Barricade vs. Dricore

54927 Views 29 Replies 19 Participants Last post by  Eyleron
My local HD has Barricade and Dricore on for virtually the same price (20 cents different per panel).


-Both are about the same thickness - (Dricore is 7/8th inch and the Barricade is 1 1/8" thick)

-Both have claims about water. Dricore has a lot more channels. My basement is very dry, and has a "diaper" around it - I'm not too worried about water

-Barricade has a 1/2" foam insulation under the OSB, and so claims to be 15 deg. warmer than the concrete. I am interested in that (I'm in Canada).


For a HT, is one product better than the other? I plan to put carpet pad and carpet on top in the room. From a sound treatment perspective which wins?
1 - 20 of 30 Posts
Hi Damon,

I have the Ovrx Barricade in my basement. I absolutely love it. I covered approx 1500 sq ft of my 2200 sq ft basement, and the temp is much improved. You can walk on this stuff barefoot in the winter and not get cold feet, and I don't even have carpet down yet. I went with it over the Dricore for two reasons. One being the insulation. The other was noise. I had read in other reviews of the Dricore that anything other than a level floor required you to shim it. Otherwise, the plastic would click against the concrete when you walk on it. Also that it had a type of 'hollow' sound. I think others here have posted that the Dricore has the problem of retaining water in the little plastic cups on the bottom in the event that you take on water in the basement. The Barricade uses XPS foam:

"A critical factor affecting long-term performance is the ability of an insulating material to resist the intrusion of moisture. Moisture can come in contact with insulation not only during construction, but throughout the life of the building. If absorbed, its effect is to drastically reduce thermal efficiency (R-value). The closed-cell structure and lack of voids in XPS helps the foam to resist moisture penetration better than other types of insulating materials. The excellent moisture resistance of XPS foam insulation has been confirmed repeatedly and consistently in laboratory tests and under field use conditions. "

"Because XPS foam is essentially a plastic material, it will not corrode or rot or support the growth of mold or mildew. It is resistant to microorganisms found in soil and provides no nutrient value to vermin. These properties make it an outstanding insulating material for below grade applications."



The channels in the bottom of the panels allow air to move underneath the floor which will also keep moisture from building up.

See my build thread for some pics. You cant go wrong with the Ovrx.

Craig
See less See more
Yep I couldn't agree more with the warmer floor. I just laid it in my basement and can already notice a difference walking around. I am in Canada as well and that was one of the reasons I went with the barricade.

The installation is very similar with tongue and groove ends. It also has a small area built in for moisture at each end. It seems like a solid product.


+ 1 for barricade
Do you need to work with tiles or could you work with 4x8 sheets of foam and OSB.

Quote:
Originally Posted by BIGmouthinDC /forum/post/0


Do you need to work with tiles or could you work with 4x8 sheets of foam and OSB.

That would work. So 1/2 inch foam and 1/2 inch osb tongue and groove and the glue the osb to the foam? I do like the idea of fewer seams...
On an episode of Holmes on Homes there was one where he did a similar floor. I remember he taped the foam seams. It might have even been thicker foam.
Have you considered Platon with OSB on top?


I'm in Canada as well - I have the Platon with 3/4 TG OSB and I find it incredibly warm. Not to mention much more cost effective.

Quote:
Originally Posted by BIGmouthinDC /forum/post/19443871


On an episode of Holmes on Homes there was one where he did a similar floor. I remember he taped the foam seams. It might have even been thicker foam.

I saw that episode, IIRC he used 1.5" on the floor and 2" on the walls (or vice versa!!) Either way it was thicker than 1/2".


I think they also tapconed the plywood to the concrete.

Quote:
Originally Posted by mels /forum/post/19443923


Have you considered Platon with OSB on top?


I'm in Canada as well - I have the Platon with 3/4 TG OSB and I find it incredibly warm. Not to mention much more cost effective.


This is what I did. But man, was it a pain in the rump to install. The Platon was always trying to curl up at the ends. Can't argue with the final product, though. Very warm and comfortable on the feet.

Quote:
Originally Posted by damonbrodie /forum/post/19443460


My local HD has Barricade and Dricore on for virtually the same price (20 cents different per panel).


-Both are about the same thickness - (Dricore is 7/8th inch and the Barricade is 1 1/8" thick)

-Both have claims about water. Dricore has a lot more channels. My basement is very dry, and has a "diaper" around it - I'm not too worried about water

-Barricade has a 1/2" foam insulation under the OSB, and so claims to be 15 deg. warmer than the concrete. I am interested in that (I'm in Canada).


For a HT, is one product better than the other? I plan to put carpet pad and carpet on top in the room. From a sound treatment perspective which wins?

I thank you very much for introducing me to Ovrx. I will be doing a home theater in my basement. I found the product that I will use. I hope to start within a couple months.
Yep I think I'm going to use it as well.
I used 3/4" 4*8 sheets of t&g foam with 3/4" 4*8 sheets of OSB on top. I just glued to the floor and between sheets. I also taped all the seams with tyvek tape. It feels like a main level floor now.
One tip if you use the 4x8 sheet method mentioned; lay the OSB at right angles to the foam. When you glue the OSB, it will help tie the two sheets of foam together. I think you could skip the adhesive to the floor and just use it between the foam and OSB.

Also, if you plan on covering with carpet, you will probably need to put a few Tapcons in the middle of the floor/room to keep it from bowing up in the middle when they stretch the carpet. This was a suggestion from the Ovrx site, but I think it would apply to this situation as well.

Good luck!
Interesting. I used DriCore for the office previously built and extended that out a bit to the area at the base of the stairs, but stopped there. So here's a new question: can you tie the Ovrx into the DriCore?


Also does anyone have a comparison of DriCore to Ovrx that's not anecdotal? I noticed a pretty good temperature increase (increase in insulative ability) in the one room after we put in the DriCore, so I guess I'm asking how much better is the Ovrx?

Quote:
Originally Posted by morgbug /forum/post/0


Interesting. I used DriCore for the office previously built and extended that out a bit to the area at the base of the stairs, but stopped there. So here's a new question: can you tie the Ovrx into the DriCore?


Also does anyone have a comparison of DriCore to Ovrx that's not anecdotal? I noticed a pretty good temperature increase (increase in insulative ability) in the one room after we put in the DriCore, so I guess I'm asking how much better is the Ovrx?

The orvx is 1/4" thicker than dricore, so mating the two will need some creativity I think. The orvx claims a 15 deg F increase in temp of the floor. I haven't found a temp claim for dricore. The orvx has to be warmer though - it has foam insulation instead of the hard plastic water channel on the dricore...
Thanks for that. The 1/4" difference could prove problematic though. I wasn't ever planning on doing the carpet myself anyway, so I'll probably drop by my carpet guy's shop and ask him what he thinks and if can do anything to smooth it. Maybe putting extra underlay on the dricore area? Thankfully it's only an area of about 8x8'.

Quote:
Originally Posted by morgbug /forum/post/0


Thanks for that. The 1/4" difference could prove problematic though. I wasn't ever planning on doing the carpet myself anyway, so I'll probably drop by my carpet guy's shop and ask him what he thinks and if can do anything to smooth it. Maybe putting extra underlay on the dricore area? Thankfully it's only an area of about 8x8'.

I you want to even them out the just put down a layer of 1/4" plywood over the drycore. I know HD sells it in 2x2 panels so it is easy to work with
I used the 6' rolls of platon in my last house with 3/4 OSB on top...the final product was fine, but like another poster already mentioned, it was more difficult to work with as the roll kept trying to roll back up.


I just ordered 200 Barricade tiles a few weeks back from Rona and they should be here in the next day or so.


Working with the 2X2 sheets of OSB around corners and jack posts would seem to be a lot easier than working with 4X8 sheets. I went with the platon/OSB combo in my old place to save some cash, but decided this time around that I'm more concerned with ease of install over the few hundred extra dollars. I was able to get the Barricade tiles for $5.97 each and saved another 10% during a "scratch and save" promotion so I'm happy with the cost. Based on the threads I've read, I think I will be happy with the purchase.
For those of you who are thinking of using Platon, just one word of caution. I used it to finish my basement as an underlayment, with tongue and groove plywood on top, attached with tapcons to the cement, and was very pleased with the result. Unfortunately, we had some water infiltration a few weeks ago, not too much, we thought we could just change the laminate floor, but it turns out that the concave side of the bubbles on the Platon retained all the water and mold and rot set in, on the undeside of the plywood. We have to redo the whole floor - thank goodness the insurance is paying, but it's a pain in the neck. We are going with Barricade this time.
1 - 20 of 30 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top