AVS Forum banner

1 - 20 of 65 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
394 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
So I pulled out my Speed disc the other day and it was not recognized in my PC drive. It tried seeking for about a minute before it finally gave up. I then tried it in 2 different PS3 units and the disc does not show up in either one. The disc looks fine on visual inspection and I tried cleaning and dustbusting as much as I could. Still no go.


I decided to then go through the rest of my collection and I found that my American Psycho and Superman: The Movie discs are not working either. All of these discs were working in the same players at the time of purchase.


So has anyone else had problems with these or any other discs? Speed was known to have some playback issues with certain players but that would have been a software problem. My copy worked fine in my PS3 until now. I've e-mailed Fox about their exchange program and am waiting for a reply.


Earlier there was a bad batch of The Prestige that had some issues with disc rot. So am I seeing Blu-ray Rot here?


That's 3 discs out of a collection of only about 130 titles. I sold about 90 titles earlier this year, including The Prestige, and now I'm wondering if any of those went bad too.


I guess I will have to put these in the same pile as my rotted DVDs of Apollo 13, The Devil's Advocate, and Vertigo.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,729 Posts
I had something of the sort happen to my US copies of American Psycho and Basic Instinct, both Lionsgate releases. I saw many spots on the discs and they did not play at all. I just shredded them for disposal.


I have the superior Australian version of American Psycho and was never really happy with the quality of Basic Instinct, so an exchange wasn't worth the hassle.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
761 Posts
That sux, sorry to hear that...I'll try my sealed copy of Speed tomorrow on my fat ps3 and slim ps3 to check if it's ok.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
581 Posts
American Psycho is one of my oldest blu-rays.

Got it with the PS3 when they had the 5 free discs thing going on.


I'll have to take a look at it.


EDIT: Just popped it in. Still works perfectly. It's the Lionsgate disc.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,093 Posts
my American Psycho stop working about 6 months ago. No scratches on the disc one day my ps3 was not able to read it...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,101 Posts
And the studios wonder at the consumer's desire to backup their titles on other media.


How many titles would they sell if they included the caveat: "may not play after 2 years"?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,729 Posts
For what it's worth, this morning I tried my copies of Speed and The Prestige that were both bought on the day of release, and they played and looked perfectly fine.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,022 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by benes /forum/post/19188257


So I pulled out my Speed disc the other day and it was not recognized in my PC drive. It tried seeking for about a minute before it finally gave up. I then tried it in 2 different PS3 units and the disc does not show up in either one. The disc looks fine on visual inspection and I tried cleaning and dustbusting as much as I could. Still no go.


I decided to then go through the rest of my collection and I found that my American Psycho and Superman: The Movie discs are not working either. All of these discs were working in the same players at the time of purchase.


So has anyone else had problems with these or any other discs? Speed was known to have some playback issues with certain players but that would have been a software problem. My copy worked fine in my PS3 until now. I've e-mailed Fox about their exchange program and am waiting for a reply.


Earlier there was a bad batch of The Prestige that had some issues with disc rot. So am I seeing Blu-ray Rot here?


That's 3 discs out of a collection of only about 130 titles. I sold about 90 titles earlier this year, including The Prestige, and now I'm wondering if any of those went bad too.


I guess I will have to put these in the same pile as my rotted DVDs of Apollo 13, The Devil's Advocate, and Vertigo.

How are your discs stored and the temperature(static or varying) of the room/location in which they are stored?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,830 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by benes /forum/post/19188257


So I pulled out my Speed disc the other day and it was not recognized in my PC drive. It tried seeking for about a minute before it finally gave up. I then tried it in 2 different PS3 units and the disc does not show up in either one. The disc looks fine on visual inspection and I tried cleaning and dustbusting as much as I could. Still no go.


I decided to then go through the rest of my collection and I found that my American Psycho and Superman: The Movie discs are not working either. All of these discs were working in the same players at the time of purchase.


So has anyone else had problems with these or any other discs? Speed was known to have some playback issues with certain players but that would have been a software problem. My copy worked fine in my PS3 until now. I've e-mailed Fox about their exchange program and am waiting for a reply.


Earlier there was a bad batch of The Prestige that had some issues with disc rot. So am I seeing Blu-ray Rot here?


That's 3 discs out of a collection of only about 130 titles. I sold about 90 titles earlier this year, including The Prestige, and now I'm wondering if any of those went bad too.


I guess I will have to put these in the same pile as my rotted DVDs of Apollo 13, The Devil's Advocate, and Vertigo.


yikes
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,071 Posts
I don't think Blu-rays are even suspectible to "rot" in the same way as all layers are internal, there is no external joining of separate plates as in DVD (and most of the "rot"-afflicted titles, to the best of my knowledge, went a step beyond that and were DVD-18s with two dual-layered DVD plates joined as a flipper disc). If any BDs were to experience the same form of "rot," I'd expect it to be Universal's BD/DVD combos.


There was a problematic batch of The Prestige (and also apparently the original release of Stranger Than Fiction) where a contaminant was found in the material used for the clear-coat protective layer. This manifested as a series of discolored spots on the bottom of the disc, and resulted in the disc not being readable. This information comes via paidgeek, a Sony employee who apparently tracked down this particular issue. Assuming this is all true, that would just fall into "bad batch" territory, and not be indicative of an inherent flaw in the Blu-ray disc manufacturing process.


For the past year or so, I have seen isolated posts on various forums discussing Blu-ray discs that at one time worked, but now no longer do. The overwhelming majority of them have been early Lionsgate releases (American Psycho, Basic Instinct, and Lord of War spring to mind). I don't mean to jump to conclusions as certainly nothing is verified and other possibilities exist, but the simplest explanation here is just that early batches of Lionsgate discs also had a manufacturing error of some kind, although it would seem to be a different one as errors are occurring over a more drawn-out timescale. I feel if it was a general Blu-ray manufacturing problem, it would occur not just over a wider range of discs, but in larger numbers of discs as well. But I suppose time will tell.


I'm at a tech conference at the moment, but when I return home I will try to find and test my various early Lionsgate BD releases. I purchased mine in late 2007 so they may not be from the earliest manufacturing batches, but I'll still see what I can find out from them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,071 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by benes /forum/post/19191613


Call it whatever you want but the fact is these discs don't work anymore. Speed is from Fox and Superman is Warner so its not just limited to Lionsgate.

I fully acknowledged the fact that they don't work anymore. My point with the rest of the context I provided was that we shouldn't just "call it whatever we want." Making assumptions, especially worse-case ones, doesn't get us any closer to a real explanation, and just fuels paranoia which can lead to dramatics.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,455 Posts
I had a bad copy of The Prestige. Whatever the problem was the disc looked similar to disc rot that I've seen with several DVDs I've owned that went bad over a period of years; the disc should look spotted, if it's the same problem. You can call the support number on The Prestige disc and Disney will exchange the defective disc for a new copy, just like they did for POTC for free. In fact, Disney will exchange any bad dvd or BD, for about the cost of shipping, I believe. If it's a defective product, exchange is free, and unlike Paramount, Disney is professional about it - they provide a return shipping label and RMA number to insure the disc doesn't get lost.


I've got what is likely a copy of Speed from its first batch, as I received it early for review. The disc looks OK, but I'll check it tonight to verify whether or not it still works.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,455 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by benes /forum/post/19192537


Exactly. It's not like this is a technical term anyway. "Rot" simply means when something has deteriorated to the point where it no longer works. Obviously that's the case here. As to what exact chemical reactions are going on here who knows.

I've read a more specific definition than that, possibly in DVD Demystified, referring to rot as oxidation of the recorded membrane due to breakdown or inconsistent application of the bonding agents (not verbatim). So, the breakdown of the membrane due to air getting in has always been my understanding of rot - not that the definition couldn't have been broadened since then. Seems like rot, the traditional definition of it anyway, was supposed to be a more serious problem with CDs than DVD due to improvements in replication and/or the sealant/glues. As I understand it, BD has supposedly improved on it even further.


I forgot to check Speed last night btw. Maybe I can remember today.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
566 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by benes /forum/post/19188257


I guess I will have to put these in the same pile as my rotted DVDs of Apollo 13, The Devil's Advocate, and Vertigo.

I know this doesn't help but I find it interesting that you added that. My Apollo 13 went bad too.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,455 Posts
I didn't know about Devil's Advocate having a problem. I sold my original unaltered dvd, just a few months ago. The disc looked flawless, but I didn't actually check to make sure it played properly. The buyer didn't complain so I guess it did, considering the price I got for it, that, or he hasn't watched it yet.


I remember there were a lot of problems with early dvds of Contact going bad. There was also a bad batch of Desperado Superbit, but it wasn't rot. I exchanged my copy twice and gave up; I decided to just keep it and use the disc to judge dvd player error correction. A few players could handle it, but most would freeze up.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,455 Posts
I checked my copies of Speed, Lord of War, and Stranger than Fiction; all should be first run; all looked and played fine.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
69 Posts
I'm glad I found this thread. The Prestige I have has spots on the disc. I looked at it under a microscope and the spots are between the layers. Disc played fine when I first got it about 2 years ago. Then went to play it the other day and it will not play in 3 different bluray players. I contacted Disney at BVHEBluray.com and they are to be sending me a replacement disc.
 
1 - 20 of 65 Posts
Top