AVS Forum banner

1 - 19 of 19 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
48 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Can anyone help me figure out why my Blu-ray Rips using Make MKV look so crappy? Do I need to convert it after I rip it? Thanks
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
3,025 Posts

Quote:
Can anyone help me figure out why my Blu-ray Rips using Make MKV look so crappy?

I'm sure plenty of people could help you, if you provided any relevant information, which you haven't.

Quote:
Do I need to convert it after I rip it?

No, not if you have a powerful enough Mac.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
48 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
Sorry, Ripping with a Mac Mini 2010, the rip looks very grainy, (even my wife noticed).

I did the rip with the default settings in Make MKV. (not sure if it matters). Thanks
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
3,025 Posts
OK, I'll try again. When I say relevant information, here are just a few things you might want to mention:


A 2010 Mini, which model, which OS version, how much RAM, how are you connected to the HDTV, which HDTV, what resolution are you connecting to that HDTV at, which software are you using to try to play the rip back with, how does it look when you use a different software player, which blu-ray did you rip, do all blu-ray rips show grain or just this one, how does other video content look, etc. I could go on, but a good general rule around here is to really describe your setup because there can be a lot of variables.


Most of us use the default MakeMKV, some also include the HD audio track, but all MakeMKV does is put the video in a different container, it doesn't alter it otherwise.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,840 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tlamb /forum/post/20308729


Sorry, Ripping with a Mac Mini 2010, the rip looks very grainy, (even my wife noticed).

I did the rip with the default settings in Make MKV. (not sure if it matters). Thanks

using default Make MKV produces spectacular result for me- both without conversion played via Plex and with conversion (Handbrake) played with iTunes.


Also, as chef says. There isn't anything being done by Make MKV that can cause 'grainy'- that descriptor is for the source film and BD implementation of it.


What movie are you ripping?


ken
 

·
Immaculate Grand Phoobah
Joined
·
3,783 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by kenliles /forum/post/20310275


using default Make MKV produces spectacular result for me- both without conversion played via Plex and with conversion (Handbrake) played with iTunes.


--snip--


ken

+1. I'm wondering if we're talking about a movie like 300? I remember thinking how "crappy" it looked...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,380 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by grubavs /forum/post/20311329


+1. I'm wondering if we're talking about a movie like 300? I remember thinking how "crappy" it looked...

Not all transfers are created equal -- that's for sure.


Another tip: there is way, way, way less difference between a top flight DVD transfer (5th Element superbit; most HBO series seasons; top flight Criterion/WB transfers, etc.) and Blu-ray than there is between a bad DVD transfer (Rancho Deluxe -- an MGM atrocity that looks like it was telecined with two screen doors in the way; any number of early Fox-Lorbers that resemble bad 4th generation VHS copies) and the above mentioned good DVD transfers.


Indeed my main hope for Blu-ray has always been that those producing them will be too embarrassed to recycle old VHS transfers to BD the way they did to DVD time and again -- not that Blu-ray will look all that amazing compared to a good DVD.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1 Posts
Makemkv does not transcode the original blu-ray, it copies blu-ray to mkv. So it might be a problem of this disc. You can try copying the bluray again with some similar app- like AnyDVD HD (bd to iso) or pavtube bytecopy (bd to mkv), if you get the same grainy picture, it's the blu-ray disc to blame, otherwise it might be a decryption problem or mac.


To judge if it is a issue of your mac mini: try playing the ripped blu-ray mkv on a mac desktop or windows pc. If the mkv plays well on windows- you gotta consider replace your mac mini with something more powerful, or down convert the blu-ray - transcode the blu-ray to something more friendly to mac with bytecopy or something else.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,427 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tomrobot /forum/post/20339462

Makemkv does not transcode the original blu-ray, it copies blu-ray to mkv. So it might be a problem of this disc. You can try copying the bluray again with some similar app- like AnyDVD HD (bd to iso) or pavtube bytecopy (bd to mkv), if you get the same grainy picture, it’s the blu-ray disc to blame, otherwise it might be a decryption problem or mac.


To judge if it is a issue of your mac mini: try playing the ripped blu-ray mkv on a mac desktop or windows pc. If the mkv plays well on windows- you gotta consider replace your mac mini with something more powerful, or down convert the blu-ray - transcode the blu-ray to something more friendly to mac with bytecopy or something else.

Yay!! Somebody actually posts the only piece of pertinent info on this thread.



It ain't the makemkv app. It's one of 3 possibilities:


1) the original BR transfer itself (ie, the one done by the movie company) was terrible -- this is not unheard of -- or


2) you're using an underpowered (or under-RAM'ed, if you're using other apps during playback) Mac Mini or media playback app that isn't up to the task, or


3) THE ORIGINAL MOVIE WAS MEANT TO BE GRAINY. A number of directors find 'grainy' to be a sexy presentation of a movie (for a prototypical example, see 'Miami Vice' or the aforementioned '300').
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,427 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by kenliles /forum/post/20310275


using default Make MKV produces spectacular result for me



Well, in all fairness -- if you say a rip is 'aweful,' it should mean that it's of such quality that one is full of awe.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
47 Posts
Just yesterday I installed MakeMKV and Handbrake to begin ripping my BD to a digital library for use in my MCPC.. I started with The Wolverine on MakeMKV and the video came out badly pixelated and running it through handbrake didn't make a difference. Then I downloaded a trial of DVDfab, ripped the BD, ran it through handbrake which took almost three times longer, but the end video is crystal clear, no pixelation. So its obviously an issue with MKV then.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
527 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by M3Roc  /t/1328934/blu-ray-rips-with-make-mkv-look-aweful#post_24194086


Just yesterday I installed MakeMKV and Handbrake to begin ripping my BD to a digital library for use in my MCPC.. I started with The Wolverine on MakeMKV and the video came out badly pixelated and running it through handbrake didn't make a difference. Then I downloaded a trial of DVDfab, ripped the BD, ran it through handbrake which took almost three times longer, but the end video is crystal clear, no pixelation. So its obviously an issue with MKV then.

MakeMKV merely wraps the video stream in an mkv container. It does no encoding, as opposed to something like HandBrake. More likely the issue is with your video player not being able to handle the bitrate of the original video. When you "ran it through HandBrake" you re-encoded the video, most likely lowered the bitrate so your player could play it. So you really are not watching the same quality video now.


But if you like it, that is all that matters!
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
3,025 Posts

Quote:
I started with The Wolverine on MakeMKV and the video came out badly pixelated

There's either some new form of protection on that disc that MakeMKV can't handle, or you're trying this on a weak-ass Mac that can't handle playing back a full-size MakeMKV blu-ray rip like djb61230 suggests, in that case it would stutter more than pixelate or you are doing something wrong either in ripping or playback. So which Mac are you using, which OS and which version of MakeMKV? What player are you using for playback of the full-size .mkv file?
Quote:
So its obviously an issue with MKV then.

Unlikely, MakeMKV has been rock solid for quite a while now on multiple versions of OS X. Until you can play a MakeMKV rip back perfectly just as it is, leave Handbrake out of the equation, you're just muddying the water.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,380 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by chefklc  /t/1328934/blu-ray-rips-with-make-mkv-look-aweful#post_24195310


Until you can play a MakeMKV rip back perfectly just as it is, leave Handbrake out of the equation, you're just muddying the water.
This. MakeMKV just changes the container to .mkv without in any way transcoding the video itself -- the video should be bit for bit the way it was on on the Blu-ray disk.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
406 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by M3Roc  /t/1328934/blu-ray-rips-with-make-mkv-look-aweful#post_24194086


Just yesterday I installed MakeMKV and Handbrake to begin ripping my BD to a digital library for use in my MCPC.. I started with The Wolverine on MakeMKV and the video came out badly pixelated and running it through handbrake didn't make a difference. Then I downloaded a trial of DVDfab, ripped the BD, ran it through handbrake which took almost three times longer, but the end video is crystal clear, no pixelation. So its obviously an issue with MKV then.

It's obvious that you don't understand video codecs, containers and MakeMKV. MakeMKV does not modify the video at all, it just stores it in an MKV container along with the audio and chapters. So if you are seeing pixelation, it's because your player/playback/hardware can't handle the full bandwidth of the video, it has nothing to do with MakeMKV. After "running it through handbrake", you've essentially reduced the bandwidth (and quality) and so now your hardware/player can handle it, that's why it works, again, it has nothing to do with MakeMKV.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,540 Posts
FYI - I am using MakeMKV to rip some blurays using my 2007 iMac 24" 2.8GHz Core2Extreme and 6GB RAM. I am using VLC Player to play it back and both work great without any stutter. I am using a cheap USB Bluray drive that I got from Amazon for $33.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
3,025 Posts

Quote:
I am using a cheap USB Bluray drive that I got from Amazon for $33.

that's commodity pricing for you, the friend of every HTPC owner, I can remember a few years ago when the inexpensive bluray ROM drives were $75 or so, and burners well over $100.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,333 Posts
It could be that your computer screen resolution is 16x10 vs. 16x9 so it appears pixelated. Have you tried playing it back on your TV yet?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,133 Posts
Was hoping someone could comment on this picture. I recently used MakeMKV to rip Red Bull's the Art of Flight and I get vertical banding from the MKV file.

Through the process of elimination I have confirmed that the banding exists on the .MKV file itself and nothing to do with my playback equipment. It appears in VLC, jriver, kodi, WMP... in Windows 7 or Windows 10.. at all resolutions .. and on 3 different displays.

I was looking at ByteCopy -- but I get pretty small filesizes when I choose to create an MKV with 'original' resolution and bitrate. Is there a better solution?
IMG_20170105_174321.jpg
 
1 - 19 of 19 Posts
Top