AVS Forum banner

1 - 20 of 83 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
10 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Hi all, I'm looking to put together a simple 2 channel system for listening to music in my apartment living room, which is 12x20 feet.


I think i've already settled on the Emotiva mini-X a-100 as the amplifier. I will be playing mostly 2 channel audio from a digital source like computer and mp3 player, but have plans for adding a turntable/vinyl in the future as well. Now I just need to pick out some speakers.


I have a budget of about $400 max for the pair. My plan is to get a pair of bookshelf speakers that i can place on stands that will sound good by themselves right now, and then maybe 6 months to 1 year down the road add a subwoofer to to round out the bottom end. I've looked at the Arx A1b, as well as the Axiom M2v3 and M3v3, as these all seem to keep popping up in budget conscious threads, but am definitely open to any suggestions. The axiom m3 seemed more appropriate to me because of the larger driver, but i never seem to see that one recommended, only the smaller m2?


My main concern is finding a pair that will sound great on its own, specifically the bass response, as it could be a while before I add a sub, or possibly forego the sub all together (though that's not likely).


In addition, a faux wood grain finish would be a definite plus (real wood is not possible at this price point is it?), as aesthetics is a concern... as reference point i think the Arx A1b's are not very attractive at all.


Also I think it is worth noting that I currently tend to listen to a lot of electronic based music, but I do appreciate balanced sound. I would hope for speakers that could excel at this type of music but be equally at home playing something like Jack White's new album.


One last bit of info. This system will be an upgrade over one of those $80 5.1 in a box systems from logitech they sell to connect to your computer. The satellite speakers are all plastic enclosures, lack tweeters, and the 6 inch sub is loud enough, but way too boomy and draws attention to itself. I've had that for the last 5 years and want a more mature looking and sounding system.


So, am i on the right track with the axioms or Arx, or can you recommend some that I'm missing completely?


Thanks in advance!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,814 Posts
Well you are going to be hard pressed to find a bookshelf with good bass response for that price. But if you are adding a sub later, they will do a decent job until then, especially since this is only for music.


Wharfedale Diamond 10.2 ($450 but worth it over the 10.1)

Focal Chorus 705V

Polk LSi7 ( http://www.ebay.com/itm/PAIR-LSi7-EBONY-Bookshelf-Loudspeakers-Polk-Audio-/390426100204?pt=Speakers_Subwoofers&hash=item5ae73581ec ) These are being replaced by the newer LSiM line, but when given good power they sound wonderful. This would take advantage of your Emotiva's 4ohm support.


These are a few off the top of my head, I would lean towards the Polks myself, but YMMV.


Edit: If you can hunt down a pair of Energy RC-10, they are fantastic speakers with good bass performance, and were offered in a very nice cherry finish.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by Transmaniacon  /t/1477695/bookshelf-speaker-recomm...-in-a-2-channel-setup-for-music#post_23437305


Well you are going to be hard pressed to find a bookshelf with good bass response for that price. But if you are adding a sub later, they will do a decent job until then, especially since this is only for music.

[...]

These are a few off the top of my head, I would lean towards the Polks myself, but YMMV.

I kind of figured 'good bass response' would be impossible with a bookshelf and at this price range, but as you picked up on I'm really looking for something that will still be nice to listen to until i do add a sub.


Also, what are the reasons you would lean towards the polks yourself? Is it simply a matter of value since the refurb price on ebay is significantly discounted?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,069 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by jps1107  /t/1477695/bookshelf-speaker-recomm...-in-a-2-channel-setup-for-music#post_23437264


HiI've looked at the Arx A1b, as well as the Axiom M2v3 and M3v3, as these all seem to keep popping up in budget conscious threads, but am definitely open to any suggestions. The axiom m3 seemed more appropriate to me because of the larger driver, but i never seem to see that one recommended, only the smaller m2?


My main concern is finding a pair that will sound great on its own, specifically the bass response, as it could be a while before I add a sub, or possibly forego the sub all together (though that's not likely).


In addition, a faux wood grain finish would be a definite plus (real wood is not possible at this price point is it?), as aesthetics is a concern... as reference point i think the Arx A1b's are not very attractive at all.


So, am i on the right track with the axioms or Arx, or can you recommend some that I'm missing completely?

Well out of the Arx A1b, Axiom M2, Axiom M3 and Axiom M22 the Arx A1b has them all beat on deep bass extension. The Axiom M3 has a huge midbass hump at 100hrz to give the impression of bass but its not actually deep bass it rolls off at around 80hrz. The Arx A1b is flat and doesn't begin to roll off till 50hrz and has useful bass into the 40hrz. The A1b actually has deeper bass than the Ascend Acoustics 170SE and the HSU HB1 Mk 2 bookshelfs and those are also 6.5" woofers.


Finish is very similar on the Arx and the Axioms but the Arx is a much larger cabinet than the M2 or M3.









Thats the Axiom M2 and the older smaller Arx A1 the current A1b is about 4" deeper than the one pictured and a few inches taller.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,814 Posts
The LSi line is known for the tweeter, which produces a very dynamic and detailed sound, with great imaging. I have heard the LSi9 (the bigger brother) and they really do sound fantastic. Surprisingly good bass, and they are well built at 21lbs each... The only drawback to them is they are 4ohm speakers, with an 88dB sensitivity, so they really command a good deal of power to sound good. That Emotiva amp though is rated for 4ohms, and should provide ample power to drive them, and considering you are in an apartment, I can't imagine you will require any more power.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,827 Posts
+1 on the LSi. Great performers, excellent build quality and beautiful finish.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
756 Posts
I have usable output down to around 40Hz with my Wharfedale Diamond 10.2's. I can actually hear down to around 35Hz, but anything below 38Hz is just too distorted for my tastes.


Great bass, mids, and highs with the Diamond 10.2's. They are quite large though. Beautiful finish as well.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
83 Posts
The Wharfedale 10.1s have a fair amount of bass to get you by if you're considering a subwoofer. The 10.2s have a little more bass. Can't go wrong with either for the money.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
419 Posts
Another vote for the LSi. Really great sounding speaker line (I have the LSi25s) and are an excellent value at the current closeout prices.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,063 Posts
I will second that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Webomatic  /t/1477695/bookshelf-speaker-recomm...-in-a-2-channel-setup-for-music#post_23437925


The Wharfedale 10.1s have a fair amount of bass to get you by if you're considering a subwoofer. The 10.2s have a little more bass. Can't go wrong with either for the money.

Almost as good, and for a ridiculously low price, are the Pioneer BS-22 speakers (only $103 per pair at Amazon).


See the review in this month's issue of Stereophile.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,849 Posts
The sm450s are very good! However, I got them for right around 200 dollars/pr last year.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
8,185 Posts
Gotta mention. The PBS image b6. These still blow me away Have since I got them in December. Not a day goes by I am not in awe
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
156 Posts
You can get very good bass output from bookshelves. Both the Polks and PSB B6s would be great choices. When I had the B6s I was never impressed with the low end until I put a good amp on them... after that they were a fantastic performer.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
16,705 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by jps1107  /t/1477695/bookshelf-speaker-recomm...-in-a-2-channel-setup-for-music#post_23437264


I think i've already settled on the Emotiva mini-X a-100 as the amplifier. I will be playing mostly 2 channel audio from a digital source like computer and mp3 player, but have plans for adding a turntable/vinyl in the future as well. Now I just need to pick out some speakers.

Have you considered that the mini-X will need a preamp to be used with multiple sources as input? Unless you are restricted on size, a budget AVR could be a better option for adding onto in the future. Or, if you are determined to get a 2 channel device, check into the HK 3390 which has phono inputs as well.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10 Posts
Discussion Starter · #18 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by cel4145  /t/1477695/bookshelf-speaker-recomm...-in-a-2-channel-setup-for-music#post_23439364


Have you considered that the mini-X will need a preamp to be used with multiple sources as input? Unless you are restricted on size, a budget AVR could be a better option for adding onto in the future. Or, if you are determined to get a 2 channel device, check into the HK 3390 which has phono inputs as well.

I have considered this, and correct me if my thinking on this is wrong, but I liked the simplicity of one quality two channel amp, that I will only have one source connected to 90% of the time. As far as the phone inputs, for my future turntable, I was looking at the Audio-Technica AT-LP120-USB which has a built in pre-amp. Simplicity and quality was my aim with the emotiva.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,814 Posts
Another option for a compact 2-channel amp is the Parasound Zamp v.3, they offer a whole matching line so you could add a pre-amp/DAC/CD player, just food for thought.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10 Posts
Discussion Starter · #20 ·
Everyone, thank you very much for all the recommendations!


After taking everyone's advice, I've narrowed it down. I'm now trying to decide between the Polk Lsi7 and the Wharfedale Diamond 10.x. Haven't decided which of either the 10.1 or the 10.2 if i were to go that route. I must admit I like the looks of the wharfedale diamonds better than the polk, but i'm not going to let looks be the deciding factor on something i'm looking at with my ears. I know the lsi7 is probably the best bang for the buck because of the closeout prices, having a much higher msrp than the others.


diamond 10.1 is $350

lsi7 is $400 for the black enclosure refurb on ebay

diamond 10.2 is $450

and the lsi7 cherry cabinet (which i prefer) brand new for $500 on ebay.


I am willing to push the budget to 450, but not 500, that kind of eliminates the better looking of the two lsi7.


That was mostly just me thinking out loud, but I do have a few remaining questions. Would the choice be different if i was never going to add a subwoofer to my system? To me the lsi7 seems like the winner, it's a higher end product, and saves me some money to use towards a sub in the future. But if I decided to never add a sub, would i be better off spending an extra 50 and getting the diamond 10.2 with the larger driver? Does the diamond 10.2 necessarily even have more bass than the lsi7 just because it has a larger driver?


Thanks.


Edit: I guess i forgot about the axiom m2's as well, they are still the cheapest of any of these. Should i forget about them? are the Diamond 10.1's better speakers?
 
1 - 20 of 83 Posts
Top