AVS Forum banner

Can Nielsen track HD viewing yet?

1623 Views 35 Replies 16 Participants Last post by  fredfa
We are supposed to get the books in the next few days. In our case, I TIVO just about everything that is in primetime and if it isn't in HD we don't watch it. About the only non HD I watch is news (FOX News Channel) sports and Monk (All TIVO'd). We watch very little local news. My wife does watch one afternoon soap and a couple of daytime craft shows on her own SD TIVO.


I want to emphasize to NEILSEN just how important HD is to our family.


If anybody has suggestions on how to impress upon those who count just how important HD is please feel free to post.
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 20 of 36 Posts
I don't think we're supossed to know any of this, now you're gonna have to kill us ;) Pretty cool though...
Quote:
Originally posted by bgall
I don't think we're supossed to know any of this, now you're gonna have to kill us ;) Pretty cool though...
Deep dodo is nothing new.
God I pray if nothing else you get to describe yourself as an HD user.


Surely listing yourself watching broadcasts on the HD channels helps.


You could consider inventing a second HD setup in your home. While you're watching Deadwood and Sopranos HD, the kids are watching Desperate Housewives and Boston Legal in HD. Of course that's breaking the rules.


If you liked my advice, please watch Justice League Unlimited and Venture Brothers during your ratings diary period. :p
Quote:
We are a NEILSEN Family - What should I do?
SHUT UP! When you agree to be a Nielsen family, you agree to not tell anyone and especially to broadcasters. It is considered conflict of interest. Your books can be disqualified and all of your viewing will not count. Nielsen plays this one seriously.
foxeng is not blowing smoke.


Have the MODs delete A.S.A.P.


Good luck!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Dave
Just say the word and I'll remove it.


We could start a new thread with hypotheticals if you'd rather.
We were a Neilsen family last year and my wife and I don't recall any threats, suggestions, urgings, or anything else, zilch, zero, el zippo, about confidentiality in any of the booklets with anyone. We even received two separate phone calls prior to the survey and the Neilsen persons calling said nothing about mum's the word. I think our usually serious foxeng for once is putting us all on.


My wife complained to the second Neilsen caller that we were atypical, didn't watch much network other than sports, and didn't want to participate. The caller said that's OK, please participate anyway to get your input and we need people like you.


In the booklets there are areas where participants can enter comments and I made it a point to heavily emphasize our almost sole interest in HD. So go for it Mike!
foxeng isn't putting you on. The typical Nielsen contract requires non-disclosure.
Quote:
originally posted by CPanther95

The typical Nielsen contract requires non-disclosure.
This is news to me and I've spent a career looking at fine-print. I wonder if Neilsen has subpoena power and I wonder if this means Mike, myself, and my INNOCENT SPOUSE may go to jail!
Having done the ratings diary in the past I recall a great deal of fine print on the non-disclosure aspects of the event. I'd be surprised to discover that a post here could eventually lead to pinpointing you but I do believe foxeng is one of those folks "in the know" and I would follow his advice.
They're not as strict with the ratings diaries (large samples, primarily used for local ratings) as they are with the metered viewers (small samples, primarily used for national ratings, overnights, etc.), but yes, violating NDA can cause your information to be discarded. For the metered families, they can take legal action (much more serious NDA).
I hear what you are all saying. Let's do this.


I haven't agreed to anything as yet. I do have the two one dollar bills they sent me; unsolicited I might add


Nielsen and the boadcast industry has an agenda. I, too, have an agenda and that is more HD as well as the right to time shift.


If we participate in the survey it will be done honestlly as to what my family actually watchs. They cannot expect more than my being honest.


At the same time, I will "push" my agenda if I can. If Nielsen wants to disqualify me, that is fine. But then I would think they want to know my viewing "habits" whatever they are.


However, I think this is a great topic for the FORUM so let's continue it to a later day after I've received the material, read the fine print, and, probably filled out the Nielsen books.


So please DO NOT DELETE. I'm in this for the fun. It will be interesting to see how NIELSEN addresses the TIVO issue. But I promise to be fair with NIELSEN meaning I will write down what programming I actually watch (or record) as they request.


But I sure as Hell reserve the right to talk about the experience as a later date on the FORUM.


See you then.
See less See more
Actually, Nielsen has a 10,000+ TiVo home survey ongoing.

It has been working for 4-5 months now.

Some of the network numbers usually get published about once a month in USA Today's Wednesday ratings section.
I did the booklet thing last year, found all confidentiality statements were focused on mine, and was very pleased to find VOOM as one pre-printed service selection.


I Voomed and Voomed and put it all in the book. Good luck!
I don't know what the metered panel families sign to; but, as a former Govt. contracting officer for many years, I know that the sweeps diaries my wife and I filled out and returned almost against our will nearly a year ago will not be used to prosecute us for coming out of the closet today Feb. 19, 2005 on the AVS Forum. I don't philosophically believe in suing or counter-suing, but if they try I'll get a good lawyer.


Neilsen has gotten some serious criticism not too long ago, as I vaguely recall, for its methodology and it didn't involve or relate to disclosure by participants. I believe it was much more substantive than that, so Neilsen has greater problems than to have a confidentiality compliance police force in operation. Below web posting is kind of enlightening, so at least my wife and I are gonna relax. And Mike in his first contact was clearly not impressed upon about confidentiality; and I'm still doubtful that we ever had to affirm we'd hencefoth forevermore remain silent about filling out the diaries. But Mike can let me know.
Quote:
Quote from Neilsen website

In the few cases where homes have revealed their NielsenTV status, we removed them from the metered panels or disregarded their diaries.
See less See more
Quote:
Originally posted by mikey mo
But I sure as Hell reserve the right to talk about the experience as a later date on the FORUM.


See you then.
After it is over, you can talk all you want about it and no, no one goes to jail over something like this. They just don't count your diary.


Nielsen takes this so seriously that stations promotions during ratings are looked at and if Nielsen determines that the promotions are too much, they will disqualify a station from that ratings. If the tallies of diaries are shown to be too far leaning, they can and do remove whole markets. It averages out to about one market a book.


Nielsen has a reputation to protect and contracts that have to have legal protection with the stations and they will not hesitate to disqualify a family if it means it keeps their reputation. We in the broadcast business have to sign agreements with Nielsen, through our employers, that state if we receive a diary or hear of someone talking about it receiving a dairy, we are to report it. Nielsen doesn't even want the perception of hanky-panky going on.
See less See more
Foxeng now at last makes a lot of sense I can't argue with. I just know some previous postings here from others as well sounded awfully ominous -- "legal action", "follow his advice", "Neilsen contract requires non-disclosure" -- that could shake up some of us from a legal standpoint. Then I remembered this is America, plus in further digging, it's not really that ominous.
Nielsen has no problem with people saying what they watched AFTER their participation in a survey ends.

But even disclosing a Nielsen affiliation in such an anonymous place as this could easily lead to potential problems:

People could PM you to "alert" you to various programs. (You might never know that those people work for a programmer.)

The Nielsen non-disclose is for no other reason than to keep its data as pure as it can. There is no motive, sinister or not, beyond that.
Quote:
Originally posted by Bill Johnson
Foxeng now at last makes a lot of sense I can't argue with. I just know some previous postings here from others as well sounded awfully ominous -- "legal action", "follow his advice", "Neilsen contract requires non-disclosure" -- that could shake up some of us from a legal standpoint. Then I remembered this is America, plus in further digging, it's not really that ominous.
You sound like you've been sued before ;)


I didn't see anyone mention legal action, and I wouldn't worry about them suing you for their $2 back for breach of contract. But Nielsen and those affiliated with the broadcast industry do take it very seriously because there is a tremendous amount of money (rightfully or wrongfully) that is spent based on the Nielsen system.


There are many, many "Nielsen families" that get the diaries to fill out (and many show up at AVS) - but the metered Nielsen families are either so few, or so serious about their "duty", that you never hear from them. I suspect it's more likely that they don't want to put at risk the cash they receive from the producers of shows like Jerry Springer and any other similar show that inexplicably remains on the air. :)


[EDIT] I revised the title just so it doesn't scream out to those who might take offense. To the original question, I would think any show that is only available in HD (HDNet exclusives, etc.) would send a pretty clear message.
See less See more
1 - 20 of 36 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top