Quote:
Originally Posted by HardBat /forum/post/18144077
So because you have a Panasonic, that means that it is the only "good" plasma, correct? From what I have read, the X1 series is one of Panasonic's worst efforts in years. I personally have no reason to bash it, since I've never seen one, just going by what I've read.
no, its not the only good plasma.
The X1 is an excellent entry level plasma. professional reviews are good and user reviews are extremely good.
Panasonic is better than samsung and LG's current offerings, pioneers that you can still find today in stores are better than all of them.
my feeling on Samsung really are more brought up in the LCD side of things. i'm really more of an LCD person experience wise and use LCD TV's as primary computer monitors.
it takes a high quality display in more ways than just one to make an LCD TV suitable for monitor/gaming use and Samsungs 2009 models fail completely when it comes to this use for more reason than just one.
their quality is extremely lacking. when it comes to their LCD models you could buy say a B650 model samsung in a store assuming that it will look the same as the one you saw on the floor but in reality the one they give you depending on a lot of factors but mostly luck will 2/3 times actually have a completely different LCD panel in the TV than the one you saw on display!!
they use 3 different panels in their LCD TV's in the same exact model number from 3 different manufactures. none of them perform as good as their own S-LCD made panel that was found in virtually all B series models when they first came out but now AUO and CMO made panels are more commonly found when you buy a samsung LCD in stores and neither perform as good.
on top of this the S-LCD made panels as good as they perform have a major problem with black uniformity, polls on these forums show 50-60% of the good S-LCD panels have either flashlights, clouding or both at the same time and it can get pretty severe in many cases
combine this with samsungs plasma buzz and their aging LCD models only 2-3 years old having their power supplies fail commonly really shows how poorly they produce their TV's
Then you also have people on these forums like Servicetech571 who repair TV's for a living and have sated that he repairs far more Samsung TV's than any other brand and he rarely ever has to repair a broken Panasonic, this to me really speaks allot for the build quality of the 2 brands
I honestly believe they build them to impress when new but once out of warranty all bets are off, no other major brand name save for sony has these kind of wide spread issues and sony's issue is directly related to Samsung because S-LCD is a jointly owned plant between the companies and both of them use the panels in their TV's yet sony never does a panel lottery nor have they had the same wide spread issues as samsung other than the flashlight and clouding issues that are directly related to S-LCD made S-PVA LCD's
This is likely why sony has partnered with Sharp to procure their new panels for 2010 top end models and probably going into the future more and more of their mainstream TV's will also use them just to get away from the terrible issues S-LCD's design/manufacture process currently has unless it can be fixed and that is really in samsungs control because S-LCD is 51/49 Samsung/Sony