Quote:
Originally Posted by
lodit /forum/post/15559307
Your disagreement of their business practices does not provide legitimate insight into the performance of their products.
Just because McD's doesn't tell you how much more flavor is in your first or last bite doesn't mean you won't eat their Big Macs and like it anyways.
And if you think Big Macs are garbage, then you gotta wonder why McD's is still selling them after all these years, right? Is it really the marketing hype? Or maybe they actually taste great to those billions served?
Since there is no mandatory requirement or legislated standard for speaker companies to list the +/- X db rolloff measurements of their products, they tend to market specs according to whatever they think the public will buy. That's just business.
Ultimately, their success will not depend solely on the marketing materials but rather the testimonials of those who try, buy, like, and recommend them to friends and family.
You're definitely entitled to your opinion, if there's a factual basis for it. If you've owned a DefTech Supercube I and set it up correctly in your HT room and it doesn't live up to what was advertised, then by all means you're justified to denounce the product.
But claiming a product should be put in the garbage because the marketing materials don't read like a best seller perhaps isn't the best testing method. If the specs pronounce the product to be trash-worthy, then fine I can agree with your suggestion (a la white van speakers). But I believe the SC I has sufficient capability and does sound good for smaller to perhaps medium-sized applications.
And I'm not just referring to DefTech alone, but to any brand. Even the much-hated Bose is still in business even after all the bashing. Must be something about them that appeals to people to keep them chugging along, right? And it's not just marketing hype, since they offer a 30 day trial period for returns if you're not satisfied. I tried it, didn't like them, so I returned them.
No big deal. Others liked the sound and look of Bose speakers and kept theirs after the trial period. They're satisfied, so good for them.
As for the OP's question regarding placement of the SC I in a closed cabinet, I would have to say no in agreement because of the side passive radiators.
No harm in trying, though to see if you'll like the sound. I would think there would be more localized rattling and cabinet vibration by hiding it in the enclosure.
Can you not just put it behind the couch or unassumingly in a corner?
Good luck on finding the best placement to "hide" that sub.
And thirdeye, I'm not looking to start a feud with you by any means. Just want to set the record straight that we all don't necessarily find happiness with the same things. That's why there's more than one speaker company in business. And we can't discount the tastes of others just because the packaging is not pleasing to our eyes. It's the product we're paying for, right? Is the spec sheet for your speakers on display in your HT? I would think not, but the quality of sound is there for all to hear when you turn it on and our ears become the best judge of the product.
Cheers to you in finding your audio nirvana, regardless of what anyone else says about it.