AVS Forum banner

ECO Advanced Liquid Cooling (A.L.C.)

1606 Views 19 Replies 13 Participants Last post by  Mr.D
3
I've been looking for a solution to my crappy Intel fan, and from doing a little research the company claims to be hitting up to 4 gigs full load @ 50c.
Quote:
Hi Guys, this is Barry here w/ CoolIT. Just based on those stock clock, temperatures something is clearly wrong and I suggest you return your ECO on RMA Yozz.


We've got a 920 here so I will set it up w/ an ECO on it and report the temps back here later.


We designed the ECO to beat the H50 and that is exactly what it does. Not sure what is going on atm but we will get to the bottom of it and report back.


To all that were helping assist in this thread. Greatly appreciated.
Quote:
Quick heads up guys, a random ECO pulled out of the last shipment we got is keep an i7 920 is in the low 50's at full load, stock speeds.


They are doing runs at 3.8, 4.0 and possibly higher now.. will keep you posted.

The second link I posted sounds like the guy either didn't hook it up right or QC issue but until more reviews come out I'll seriously be considering this over Corsairs H50 unit but until then....

http://forums.anandtech.com/showthread.php?t=2041274

http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/sho...8108493&page=2






I was also going to team it up with this.

See less See more
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
The idea with HPTC's is to REDUCE power consumption, not squeeze every ounce of performance out a processor.
No, the goal of a HTPC is to provide media to your traditional audio and video systems rather than relying on numerous standalones.


Nothing wrong with getting more performance as long as noise levels are kept in check.
Power consumption is significant when PC's are on 24/7.
if you care about power consumption, yes

but that is another issue that affects any appliance
I just used the OC as a reference to the cooling performance of this unit. It to me it is a perfect silent solution with no extra added heat build up in the case. Sure you can OC the chip but I was looking at it as a silent solution, and I don't keep my HTPC on 24/7 anyways. I don't see any negatives toward this unit it keeps your chip way cooler than any stock solution, less heat means longer life cycle for your hardware. A lot of people go to liquid cooling for silent PC solutions and I think I'll join that crowd if this thing turns out to be a winner. For 80.00 it's worth giving it a chance at least.
It's not going to make it "much" cooler. These exotic cooling systems really only become usefull if you've got a component (processor) throwing off lots of heat, so much heat that more standard solutions can't effectively remove it.


I've never understood going to water for silent cooling, they've still got pumps and fans that make noise (not to mention more stuff to fail). The way you get silent cooling is with heatpipes and massive heatsincs.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nimo /forum/post/18112731


less heat means longer life cycle for your hardware.

Not really. Unless you are really cooking the thing beyond its design temps, less heat doesn't really mean much. It's just one more number that gearheads can compare to show off their E-dork machismo.


Honestly it is heat cycling that puts strain on the traces of circuits. Once it is up to steady state, there is little to no wear on it, unless you are cooking it to the point that the individual materials are breaking down.


Has anyone had a CPU, kept at a relatively sane but by no means cool temp, die on them before it was completely outdated and useless?


Regardless, if you like the cooler and it suits your needs, have at it. Personally, I don't think I would ever bother with water cooling in this day. CPUs are just too robust and efficient now to have a need for the complexity.


-Suntan
See less See more

Quote:
Originally Posted by Suntan /forum/post/18114391


Not really. Unless you are really cooking the thing beyond its design temps, less heat doesn't really mean much. It's just one more number that gearheads can compare to show off their E-dork machismo.


Honestly it is heat cycling that puts strain on the traces of circuits. Once it is up to steady state, there is little to no wear on it, unless you are cooking it to the point that the individual materials are breaking down.


Has anyone had a CPU, kept at a relatively sane but by no means cool temp, die on them before it was completely outdated and useless?


Regardless, if you like the cooler and it suits your needs, have at it. Personally, I don't think I would ever bother with water cooling in this day. CPUs are just too robust and efficient now to have a need for the complexity.


-Suntan

Since I built this system I've got the hardware bug in me. I think I'll take your advice and save my money.
See less See more

Quote:
Originally Posted by stanger89 /forum/post/18113879


It's not going to make it "much" cooler. These exotic cooling systems really only become usefull if you've got a component (processor) throwing off lots of heat, so much heat that more standard solutions can't effectively remove it.


I've never understood going to water for silent cooling, they've still got pumps and fans that make noise (not to mention more stuff to fail). The way you get silent cooling is with heatpipes and massive heatsincs.

It would have been my first H20 system but you guys are right I'll just keep what I have and be happy. Thanks for the input guys/gals.
Longevity is not really an issue anymore. Provided the pump is silent and the fan used on the radiator is silent, the water cooling system will greatly aid in heat removal from the case.


Rather than blowing the hot air from the CPU directly into the case, it is moved to the radiator which also has the case exhaust fan on it. The heat never makes it into the case, so the entire case stays cooler.


On a related note, you then have to make sure the components which normally would be cooled by the CPU fan (those surrounding the CPU) are still kept cool. They may need additional cooling, but might not, since the CPU heat is not blown directly onto them.


I think water cooling a HTPC is overkill though. Intel's CPU cooler is silent already.
I just picked up a Corsair H50 when BB had it on sale online a couple of weeks ago and installed it in my main PC yesterday. I haven't checked the CPU temp but it does appear to run a bit quieter than the combination of the 120mm case fan and the Zalman CNPS-9500 CPU cooler I had been using.


I believe there's a link on the Corsair website for using this cooler with dual identical 120mm fans in a push/pull configuration that blows away most anything else with regards to cooling your CPU. Since I don't overclock I don't see the need. Frankly, I can't see why anyone would need that much performance out of their HTPC unless they're also using it as a hardcore gaming rig.


I had thought about water cooling my HTPC a while back and even invested in a Koolance setup with all the bells and whistles. I never got around to installing it because it simply takes up too much space.
If having a stable HTPC is your end goal which I assume is the goal of almost anyone here considering that the lack of stability is the htpc's largest fault basically then overclocking an HTPC is probably the most counter productive thing you could do. I have done overclocking and I have spent many years reading on overclocking forums. The only way to get a stable overclock is to barely overclock. Anything more and you spend countless hours tinkering. Considering the countless hours already spent tinkering just to maintain stability of everything else on an HTPC this seems like a huge bunch of nonsense when you could simply just buy a slightly faster processor. And since you dont need the fastest processor for an HTPC the end goal of overclocking is basically pointless. The tiny bit of performance achieved by a slight overclock is basically pointless as well and could probably be achieved with a few bios tweaks and the stock cooler or as I stated earlier probably about $20 by getting a faster processor.
See less See more
I spent a lot of time and money on quiet cooling solutions.


Went with watercooling haven't looked back.


I've got a reserator 1 on my serious PC and a Reserator XT on my HTPC ( I'm a sucker for analogue needles).


The XT gave me some problems with the Zalman coolant it came with ( advice: use 100% distilled water and some anti-algae additive instead).


And the flow indicator is notorious for breaking down because of a design fault ( quite easy to fix yourself or you can buy fixed new ones).


Apart from that both have given good service for years. The Reserator 1 is pretty much completely silent ( have to put your ear to it to hear the pump). The XT has a fan which makes a little noise but is still quieter than the hard drives or the fans in my plasma and projector so isn't an issue.


Hottest either machine gets under load is about 42C , usually idles at about 32 and thats with the XT and HTPC in a cabinet and its cooling the cpu and gpu on the same loop.


I have one silent undervolted zalman fan pressurising the case at the front. One sucking a little bit of air out a blowhole on the top and the PSU is one of those active ones that only spins up the fan when it detects heat ( I've never seen it activate in all the years I've had the PSU). You still need a bit of airflow through the case even when you watercool.


Plan to put my 360 into the reserator loop to try and quieten that sucker.
See less See more
I have done watercooling as well and what a headache. Not at home and it springs a leak? Say goodbye to all your components. You might have a real hard time getting them to honor the warranty as well. I realize watercooling can be great if its a simple system and you arent going too crazy but since the fans on an htpc are almost silent to begin with the sound of a watercooling pump is probably louder.
Thanks to the OP for making me aware of this. I had only heard about the Corsair H50 as a very good alternative to the gigantic cpu heatsinks we all hate, and this looks to be even better.
we, should no better than to talk about Liquid cooling at the avsforum.
See less See more

Quote:
Originally Posted by shayking /forum/post/18118232


we, should no better than to talk about Liquid cooling at the avsforum.

Grasshopper, That's your myopic view/opinion.
First of all. You MUST do a 48 hour leak test before you put your components in there


Second of all, there is another 48 hour test with everything but your motherboard plugged in and hard drives powered up.


Third, the distilled water won't immediately destroy your components, believe me, I know about this. I had my NB waterblock leak all over my video card. It's a mess, but it won't destroy it immediately.


This leak was only because I didn't leak test it first.


Most of the water components for sale today wouldn't have ANY reason to blow.


I am Tony and I have been watercooling for 3 years.
See less See more

Quote:
Originally Posted by AnthonyB /forum/post/18119375


First of all. You MUST do a 48 hour leak test before you put your components in there


Second of all, there is another 48 hour test with everything but your motherboard plugged in and hard drives powered up.


)

I give the loop an hour on its own outside the case.


Then I check the interior of the PC for leaks over the next few hours.


Then I'll give it a routine inspection with a torch every week or so.


Never had a leak (avoid some of the kit that is knocked up in someone's backyard though).


Don't use any toxic additives beyond a few drops of anti-algae solution. That way if you do get a leak the water shouldn't be too conductive and it won't stain anything.
See less See more
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top