AVS Forum banner
1 - 20 of 3347 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Welcome to EV's Indoor Antenna Round-Up!


The Ultimate Internet Guide to Indoor Antennas!





Some introductory thoughts.

THIS GUIDE IS A WORK IN PROGRESS


These antennas are listed in no particular order. This list of antennas are all recommended and better than average.


There is no one best indoor antenna. Environmental factors present a plethora of situations that no one antenna can be best for all of them. In fact, most times the best indoor antenna is an antenna placed outdoors or an outdoor antenna placed indoors. Some may need VHF Hi and UHF, others only UHF, after the Feb2009 shutdown of analog broadcasts. Antennas are a strange brew, sometimes it's more of an art than a science, and while these are generally well regarded antennas for indoor use, Your Mileage May Vary.


Remember, outdoor placement is much preferred if you can swing it. Even if you get some of these outdoor antennas that are small, flat, and aesthetic and unobtrusive enough to go inside, they will do better outside on a patio or outside a window especially if facing the broadcast tower cluster. Some even put large antennas in attics.


These are some of my personal favorites and I have personal experience with many of these antennas. Most are highly recommended antennas by others on the net and other AVSforum members in this thread; and in reviews and tests that I researched on the net


The other end of the equation is tuner ability, sensitivity and selectivity. ATSC tuners have dramatically improved over the last couple of years. If you are on the fringe of reception even using the best antenna setups, you may want to consider improving your tuner with a set top box tuner. Both SD Coupon Elligible Converter Boxes and HDTV Tuner Boxes exist. LG and Samsung make great HDTV tuner boxes. LG makes some of the best tuners, and their CECB the Zenith DTT901 currently has one of the most sensitive tuners for those looking to keep using their old CRT NTSC analog sets. You can research tuners and converter boxes in the same subforum that you are now located in AVSforum.


Please feel free to add your comments, suggestions, observations, corrections, experiences, questions, etc. They are most welcome.


I am not an expert or highly trained and experienced technician, just an amateur enthusiast. I do not portend to be anything else. There are many other people on this site that are much more knowledgable and experienced than I.


Special thanks to Seatacboy, golinux, fajitamosaic, Rick313, Rammitinski, and deltaguy, for their encoragement, enthusiasm, guidance and contributions.....and to KenH for making this thread a sticky.


I hope this will be useful to others.


Please let me know if you like it.


Best regards


EV



Newbies start here! Read this first!

Quote:
Antennas and Digital Television


FCC Consumer Facts


Federal law requires that all full-power television broadcast stations stop broadcasting in analog format and broadcast only in digital format after February 17, 2009. Broadcast stations in all U.S. markets are currently broadcasting in both analog and digital. If you have one or more analog televisions that receive free over-the-air television programming with an outdoor antenna or "rabbit ears" on the TV, you will either need a digital television (a TV with a built in digital tuner) or an analog television connected to a "digital-to-analog converter box" (which converts digital signals to analog signals for viewing on your analog set) in order to continue to watch programming from full-power broadcast stations. This Fact Sheet provides information on antennas and on what is needed for good quality reception of digital broadcasts.

Try Using Your Existing Antenna First


First, it is important to know that if your television currently receives good quality reception on analog channels 2-51 with a broadcast antenna, it should be able to receive digital television (DTV) signals, including high definition television (HDTV) signals, with the same broadcast antenna. You do not need to purchase a "DTV antenna" or an "HDTV antenna" to receive DTV or HDTV signals. However, consumers should be aware that if they use a digital-to-analog converter box, they will still need to use an antenna to receive DTV signals.


Prior to making any changes to your current antenna or antenna system, you should check to see if it will receive the digital signals being broadcast in your area. Connect your existing antenna to either a digital television or a digital-to-analog converter box connected to an analog TV. Make sure your TV is set up to receive over-the-air broadcasts (as opposed to being connected to a paid provider such as a cable or satellite TV company). It may also be helpful to perform a "channel scan," in which your TV will automatically check to see which stations it can receive. In many cases, this is all you will need to do to watch digital television broadcasts.

For Help With Reception Problems


If you experience reception problems, the following information and tips may help to improve your reception for digital broadcasts.


During the transition to digital TV, many stations are temporarily operating at reduced power levels. If you are not receiving certain digital TV stations, this does not necessarily mean there is a problem with your antenna or receiver. Check with the TV station to find out whether they are planning changes that will improve reception.


When an analog TV signal is weak or receives interference, static, snow, and distortion will often appear on the screen, but you can watch the picture through the noise. Digital broadcasting will provide a clear picture even with a weak signal and in the presence of interference. However, if the digital signal falls below a certain minimum strength, the picture can suddenly disappear. This “cliff effect” means that if you typically watch analog TV stations that have a lot of static and distortion, you may have to adjust or upgrade your antenna system to get a reliably good signal for digital broadcasts.


TV reception can be affected by factors such as terrain, trees, buildings, the weather (rain, wind, humidity), and damaged/deteriorated equipment. Often digital reception can be improved just by changing the location of your current antenna. Moving it away from other objects and structures, or placing it higher can often improve reception.


Many antennas need to be oriented or aimed to get the best signal from the desired station. For indoor antennas, you may need to do this manually by trial and error. For outdoor antennas, a rotor that re-orients the antenna can improve performance, particularly when trying to receive stations that transmit from different locations.


Television stations broadcasting in digital use both the VHF band (channels 2-13) and UHF band (channels 14-51). Many indoor antennas use “rabbit ears” for the VHF band and a “loop” or “bow-tie” antenna for the UHF band. Make sure you are using an antenna that covers both the VHF and UHF bands and have connected it properly.


Simple indoor antennas, such as rabbit ears, provide minimal performance that may or may not be suitable for your location. If you are unable to obtain satisfactory reception with your current indoor antenna, you may wish to obtain an indoor antenna that includes features for better reception of UHF signals and/or an amplifier to boost the received signal (often referred to as an active indoor antenna).


Generally, an outdoor antenna will get better reception than an indoor antenna. If you already have an outdoor antenna and are getting good quality reception from VHF and UHF channels, your antenna should work fine for digital television.


The performance of outdoor antennas can degrade over time due to exposure to the weather. If you are having problems, check for loose or corroded wiring, broken antenna elements and that the antenna is pointed in the right direction.


Try to keep the length of wire between your antenna and digital receiver as short as possible for best reception.


You can use a single antenna to provide digital broadcasts to multiple TVs in your home. Remember, however, that each analog TV connected to your antenna will need its own digital-to-analog converter box to view digital broadcast programming.


"Splitters" that are used to connect a single antenna to multiple receivers reduce the amount of signal available to each receiver. If you are having problems, check to see whether reception is improved without the splitter. In some cases an "active" splitter that includes an amplifier can solve the problem.


If you are near a station's broadcast tower, reception of that station, as well as other stations, can be impeded by signal "overload". Consider using an "attenuator" or removing amplifiers to improve your reception.

If you decide to replace or upgrade your outdoor antenna, websites such as www.antennaweb.org and http://tvfool.com/ provide information on the locations of broadcast towers and the types of outdoor antennas appropriate for the stations you wish to receive. If you need assistance with upgrading your antenna system, check with a local antenna retailer or antenna installer.

http://forum.ecoustics.com/bbs/messa...79/468153.html

Sage advice from KenH.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ken H /forum/post/14136288


In general:

Outdoors is better than indoors.

Bigger is better than smaller.

Directional is better than omnidirectional.

Mounting higher is better than mounting lower.


Performance rankings.....based on EV's observations....Rough Guide....YMMV


These are rough guestimations, based on my personal observations. They have not been instrument tested yet. Just because something is at the top of the list, does not necessarily mean that it is the best antenna for you and your particular situation. You may be best served by an unamplified model or an omnidirectional model, and directional and amplified units tend to do better on net gain and distance measures. This list is also most certainly distorted by varying atmospheric conditions. I will address that by instrument testing these all on one day, so as to minimize human and atmospheric error.


Performance rankings so far.....based on EV's observations....Rough Guide....YMMV

THIS IS A WORK IN PROGRESS and is changed and updated regularly as new and better testing data becomes available

Channel Master 4220 with CM 7777 amp on roof

DB2 with CM 7777 amp on roof

RS 1880

RS 1892 UFO

Antennas Direct ClearStream2

Channel Master 4220 unamped indoors

DB2 unamped indoors

Winegard SS-3000

Petra SuperPower 32db (Cornet 645A)

Terk HDTVa

RS Double Bow Tie

Philips MANT940

RS DA-5200

GE Futura Outdoor

Philips MANT950

RCA ANT806

Classic Single Bow Tie

Philips Silver Sensor

Godar Model 1

Terk TV-3

Philips MANT510

RS 1634

My First Attempt at the Coat Hanger Antenna, Youtube Video Specifications unamped

GE Futura Indoor

Terk TV-55

RS 1874 Budget

Picture Frame Antenna

RCA ANT1500

Channel Master 4030

Samsung Axession TV DA1000/GE Contempo

RCA ANT108 (very similar to the RCA ANT110 and others)

RS 1868 Delta

Terk TV-2

RCA ANT1020

Terk TV-5

RS 1870

Jensen TV 931

Terk TV-1 without Loop

RS FM Dipole





EV's Favorites....so far


RS 1880

RS 1892 UFO

RS DA-5200

RS Double Bow Tie

RS Single Classic BowTie

RS 1874 Budget

Petra SuperPower 32db(Cornet 645A)

Godar Model 1

Antennas Direc DB2

Antennas Direct ClearStream2

Channel Master 4149

Winegard SS-3000

Terk HDTVa

Terk TV-3

Terk TV-2

Philips Silver Sensor

Philips MANT510

Philips MANT940

Philips MANT950

RCA ANT806

RCA ANT108 (ANT110)




Here is a chart designed by wwong incorporating the data that I collected in regards to antenna performance using a Zenith 901 Converter Box. Note the first 2 entries were tested on a seperate day, I was testing the Clearstream2 and used the DB2 as a control to help integrate the information into the above lists.





.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #2 ·
Table of Contents


1. Introduction

. a. Tips for Reception

. b. Sage Advice

. c. Performance Rankings

. d. EV's Favorites


2. Table of Contents


3. Rabbit Ears and Loop Style Antennas

. a. Basic Rabbit Ears & Loop

. b. Radio Shack 15-1868

. c. Terk TV-1

. d. Channel Master 4000

. e. Philips MANT510

. f. Terk TV-3

. g. Petra SuperPower 32db

. h. Cornet 645A

. i. Radio Shack 15-1874

. j. Quantum FX ANT-102

. k. Lava A-463

. l. Philips SVD2750


4. Bow Tie Antennas

. a. Classic Single Bow Tie

. b. Channel Master 4149

. c. Terrestrial Digital DB2

. d. AntennasDirect Lacrosse

. e. Channel Master 4220

. f. Channel Master 4221

. g. Homemade Quad Bow Tie


5. Silver Sensor Style Antennas

. a. Antiference Silver Sensor

. b. Terk HDTVi and HDTVa

. c. Philips PHDTV3 Amplified Silver Sensor

. d. Channel Master 4040

. e. Godar Model 1

. f. Terk HDTVo

. g. Cornet ET-8DA


6. Miscellaneous Design Antennas

. a. Winegard SharpShooter SS-3000

. b. Terk HDTVlp

. c. Radio Shack 15-1892 "The UFO"

. d. Godar HD-3

. e. ClearStream C1C

. f. ClearStream2

. g. RCA ANT751

. h. Digitenna City

. i. Digitenna Metro

. j. Digitenna Suburban


7. Rectangular UHF Array Antennas

. a. Meritline "Artec" "Kingbox" Antenna

. b. AntennasDirect PF7 Picture Frame Antenna

. c. RCA ANT1500

. d. Radio Shack DA-5200

. e. Philips MANT940

. f. GE Futura Outdoor

. g. Monoprice Antenna

. h. HD 650 Antenna

. i. Winegard SquareShooter's

. j. Terk HDTVs


8. Stick Style Antennas

. a. Philips MANT950

. b. RCA ANT806

. c. Winegard Sensar III's


9. RV Style Antennas

. a. Radio Shack 15-1634

. b. Winegard MetroStar MS-2000


10. Miscellaneous Antennas under consideration for the list


11. The Dog House - Not Recommended


12. Indoor antenna Tests, Shootouts, and Review Websites

. a. HDTV Primer antenna gain chart and link

. b. HDTV Primer - Antenna Basics

. c. Digital Dude Video: Antenna Myths Dispelled!

. d. Consumer Reports TV FAQ

. e. HDTVexpert shootouts

. f. Indoor Antenna Test Results Reported at the NAB Broadcast Engineering Conference

. g. Kyes Antenna Site

. h. RabbitEars.info

. i. Other good sites for antenna reviews

. j. AVSForum links

. k. DIY Quickie Antenna Reflector


13. Oldies but Goldies...Discontinued but not Forgotten

. a. Radio Shack Double Bow Tie

. b. Radio Shack 15-1862

. c. Radio Shack 15-1880

. d. Samsung TV5.4 SAX

. e. Recoton Color Antenna


14. Working Ideas and My Antenna List

a. Ideas

b. My Antenna List


.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
Rabbit Ear and Loop Style Antennas



Basic Non-Amplified Rabbit Ears & Loop




Believe it or not, these are pretty darn good antennas. The Rabbit Ears give you good VHF performance, and the basic loop gives you good UHF. These outperform many fancy looking and more expensive Amplified RE & Loops. If you have a pair of these around, you should pull them out and give them a try. They may be all that you need. Indeed they may be the best solution.


Note that those close to the towers can overload their tuners with already strong signals that are then amplified. This wont hurt your tuner/TV(but you shouldnt keep abusing it), but they just wont work.


Some of the best currently available basic RE & Loops from mine and others experience and testing are the RCA ANT110 and the RCA ANT108. These are virtual clones and Ive seen these same units with other brand names on them as well. These are easy to find at major B&M retailers nationwide. The RCA ANT108 is pictured.


They have strong thick 5" loops and 39" telescoping rabbit ear dipoles that are sturdy and simple to adjust. On the downside, they have thinly shielded coax that is not detachable. However, they do perform and are dirt cheap.



Radio Shack 15-1868 Delta




The RS Delta has pleasing aesthetics and good user reviews. Plus fine tuning adjustment knob. Good performer for non amplified RE & Loops. This unit has detachable coax and telescoping rabbit ear dipoles that are adjustable in altitude and azimuth. If you dont like the utilitarian looks of the basic models above, this one works well also. Nice little antenna. VHF and UHF.

Quote:
Delta design for a high-tech look.

Use the UHF/VHF/FM indoor antenna with 12-position fine-tuning control to dial in the clearest picture for each station. The unique delta design of this set-top antenna makes it an attractive addition to your viewing room. It has gold plating and 75-ohm VHF/UHF output. The internal loop UHF loop is 39" with black chrome and VHF dipoles. This antenna comes with a 6-ft 75-ohm coaxial cable with gold-plated connectors.


12-position fine-tuning control--no need to move base for best picture

Gold-plated "F" connector output for better signal and picture

Unique delta design makes it an attractive addition to your TV room
Terk TV-1 Rabbit Ears




Here is Terk's version of the non-amplified basic Rabbit Ears. It has good build quality and nice modern aesthetics, plus 44" VHF dipoles. It comes with a sepereate UHF loop which is not attachable as an integrated UHF/VHF antenna solution. Its made to attach to the back of an old TV and thusly isnt very useful. But it can be used in conjunction with a superior UHF only antenna as many are in this list. If you need to add a VHF Hi antenna after the Feb09 cutoff of analog signals, this is a good choice. In order to join 2 seperate UHF and VHF antennas, you need a VHF/UHF Combiner. Its worth the effort to use a Combiner and not just a basic Splitter for less signal loss and better signal filtering and handling. Channel Master and Winegard offer combiners but you can get the cheapies and they are still better than the basic splitter.

Quote:
VHF: channels 2-13; UHF: channels 14-69

heavy-gauge 40" retractable VHF dipoles with safety tips

UHF loop antenna

300-ohm to 75-ohm matching transformer

height of base: 3-3/8"; height with dipoles: 12-1/2" - 42-1/2"D

An AVSforum member explains this setup.

Quote:
Originally Posted by golinux /forum/post/0


...... I am in a heavily wooded area (and in a hollow to boot) about 26 miles from the towers. My location has been described as a "worst case scenario".


I have been using a DB2 with a 22db amp in an indoor window for several years. Since there is a VHF station, I have rabbit ears and the DB2 hooked to a signal combiner before going to the amp. This setup picks up all the local stations in analog and also with the Zenith DTT900 converter box. On two of the weaker stations there is some minor dropout if the winds are heavy but nothing I can't live with.

Channel Master 4000 Rabbit Ears



Quote:
Set top antenna

• 300 Ohm twin lead output

• Dual 40 in., 5-section retractable chrome dipoles with 90° tilt for fine tune adjustments

Philips MANT510




One of the best of the ubiquitous Amplified Rabbit Ears and Loop style set top antennas, which arent the best performers in general as distance antennas, but may suit your needs best. It doesnt have a loop per se, but a "UHF flat panel array." It is also amplified, 50db overkill(I'm skeptical of that figure), but adjustable and has nice 44" dipoles for VHF reception. Strangely it includes a 75ohm to 300ohm transformer/balun along with a nice guide booklet. Has a detachable coax interface, plus an Aux input with a switch so that you can choose between the antenna or another source. Doesnt have an FM trap, so can be used as an FM antenna as well. One thing to note, is that this is a directional antenna, loops are omni-directional or more precisely bi-directional....and is adjustable in altitude and azimuth. The build quality is good on these, the base is weighty and stable and it sits off of the surface. VHF and UHF.


If you are close to the towers, this highly amplified version may not be for you, although the amp is adjustable like most other amped RE & Loop combo antennas, you may want to try an unamplified version first. Overamplifying strong signals can overload the tuner and you might recieve no stations at all. Overloading will not damage the tuner though, it just wont work. When reading user reviews, often the ultra low scores are by people that get no signals because of this amplifier gain overloading business, unbeknownst to them.


In depth comparative reviews of this and other antennas can be found on the Big River MANT510 page.


Quote:
50 dB amplification boosts weak signals, expanding your reception range and allowing you to receive more signals over a greater distance.


The highly efficient UHF flat panel array offers improved reception over conventional loop antennas. Due to the flat design, the antenna concentrates the signal for better reception.


44" dipoles adjust 360° with a 180° tilt to deliver the best possible reception.


Together with the adjustable amplification, low noise amplification ensures you of a great reception range and improves and maintains the quality of your signal.


Easy touch control with LED signal increases or decreases amplification strength. Also confirms amplification strength at a glance.


The weighted base stabilizes the antenna's position so you enjoy more positioning choices.

A/B switch - Built-in selector switch makes it easy to change between viewing sources.


Simple sleek, elegant design lines compliment today's new TVs.

http://www.consumer.philips.com/cons...nna+SDV2510-27



Terk TV-3 Amplified Rabbit Ears and Loop[/b]






Petra SuperPower 32db (Cornet 645A, others)




I really like these antennas. They are excellent performers and are the best of the amplified Rabbit Ears & Loop style antennas. They can be found at major online retailers for dirt cheap as well. The large 9" loop (which is also particularly thick) is the key. It shifts the meat of the gain curve down into the newly re-allocated UHF TV spectrum of Ch. 14 to 51....for superior performance over all others with smaller loops. The amplifier helps as well, if you need the extra umph. Also has Rabbit Ear VHF dipoles for adequate VHF reception. Amplified....UHF and VHF.




Radio Shack 15-1874 Budget RE&Loop




This is my new favorite unamplified RE&Loop. Its main claim to fame is that it has a larger 7.5" diameter loop which pushes the gain curve down into the heart of the newly squashed UHF Digital TV spectrum (really it could be even larger like the 9" loop on the Petra SuperPower above that is a very good performer). The RCA ANT108 and others like it have a 6.5" diameter loop. UHF and VHF. Highly Recommended.



Quantum FX ANT-102 Indoor




The Quantum FX ANT-102 performs on par with the legendary RS-1880. As you can see they are similarly sized and designed with amplified double loops plus telescoping articulating Rabbit Ear VHF dipoles. The Q FX ANT-102 includes a remotely controlled light duty rotor that works well....can be useful for people with multiple direction transmissions....however even if you dont need this feature, this antenna is one of the elite indoor antennas in current distributino (along with the Silver Sensor, and Terk HDTVa, RS 1892 UFO). Snap one of these up, youll be glad you did. Recommended. UHF and VHF.



Lava A-463




The Lava A-463 is also a good antenna similar to the lengendary RS 1880, with amplified double loops and telescoping articulating Rabbit Ear VHF dipoles. However it is smaller, as can be seen in the pic. The Lava A-463 is nearly as good as the RS 1880, beating everthing else in this category except the Q FX ANT-102. I think the Lava gives up something on the lower channels of the UHF band due to its diminuative size to both the ANT-102 and the RS 1880. However, this is not a bad antenna, and is better than any Amplified RE&Single Loop style antenna which is so common. Its just the Q FX ANT-102 is slightly more desirable. UHF and VHF.



Philips SDV2750

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
Bow Tie Antennas


Radio Shack Classic Single Bow Tie Antenna




Believe it or not, this is a pretty darn good UHF antenna! It will beat most RE & Loops on UHF. And best of all, its dirt cheap. Can be found at Radio Shack and there version has plastic clips for securing the antenna to a Rabbit Ear dipole or wire. 13" long x 3 1/4" wide, bi-directional(omni). Give this one a try, for sure. You will need a 300ohm to 75ohm balun. UHF only.


Digitenna Indoor



Channel Master 4149 Double Bow Tie




This is a clone of the famous RS Double Bow Tie. It is an excellent performer. It is approximately 12" square x 3" deep. Its screen gives it nice directional forward gain on UHF. No VHF performance to speak of. The bows are fairly easy to bend so be careful. It has a twin lead to 300ohm spade cable...so you will need a matching transformer balun. However, you may be able to improve the performance of this one by removing the twinlead and adding the matching transformer balun directly to the feedlines. Another home improvement technique is extending the bowties with aluminum foil. UHF only.



Terrestrial Digital DB2 - Double Bow Tie (AntennasDirect, Eagle Aspen, and others)




Superior antenna for use indoors. Technically not an indoor antenna. This one is small enough and not too aesthetically unpleasing to do indoor duties in tough situations. Can also be mounted on small patios or outside windows for apartment dwellers. Not amplified, but an external can be added if necessary. Excellent performance among indoor antennas(better outside of course). Ive currently got this one on the roof with a Channel Master Titan 7777 amplifier and its holding its own against an xg91 that it temporarily replaced(yes I have serious tree and placement problems) 45 miles South of the towers. UHF only.

Quote:
New for 2008! New Low-loss Design.


Although the DB2 was originally designed for outdoor use, it has quickly become one of our most popular indoor antennas due to its small size and extraordinary gain. The bowtie design provides strong gain across the entire UHF spectrum and it functions incredibly well in areas where a low profile antenna is required. In fact the DB2 was recently named "The highest performing indoor antenna" from HDTV Primer.


The Eagle Aspen version is virtually identical to the DB2 and can be found for a significantly lower price at major retailers online.


Some mounting ideas for the DB2...


Microphone Stand

Torchiere Lamp

Freestanding Coat & Hat Rack

Bath Towel Rack Mounted Sideways on the Wall

Hooks from the Ceiling Joist

Suction Cup Hooks on the Window

Hooks from the Top Window Frame

Extendable Shower Curtain Rod Mounted Vertically

LCD Computer Monitor Swing Arm Wall Mount

Paper Towel Holder - the kind with the wood dowel that stand vertical from a wood base.


Range: 1-30 Miles

Multi-directional (pulls in signals from many directions)

Achieves a high gain of up to 11.4 dB

Ideal for UHF channels 14-69

Great for indoor, outdoor, and attic use

Dimensions 12" H x 19" W x 4" Deep

Weight: 2.8 pounds

Lifetime Warranty

http://www.antennasdirect.com/DB2_Indoor_antenna.html




Antennas Direct Lacrosse





This is basically a DB2 with an "attractive" plastic housing which can be useful in Homeowners Association situations. Expect similar if slightly diminished from the plain DB2 performance. It comes in 2 flavors, amplified or unamplified. UHF Only.

Quote:
Includes all you need: Lacrosse Antenna, 17dBamplifier, J Mount Bracket, Mounting Hardware, Quad-Shield Coax Cables.

Receive uncompressed, over-the-air HDTV signals from local affiliates.

Better HDTV picture than cable or satellite.

Range: Up to 40 Miles

Build to blend intot he design of your home.



Channel Master CM 4220 - Double Bow Tie





Similar to the DB2, expect similar excellent performance. The 4220 is probably a bit better than the DB2 because of its larger bows. Note however that the CM 4220 is quite a bit larger than the DB2, including depth, plus its a bit heavier than the DB2......making the DB2 perhaps more suited as an indoor antenna, since performance is similar. I replaced the DB2 on the roof(which replaced the xg91) and it performed admirably, perhaps a tad better than the DB2 on signal strength. The build quality of this unit is commendable. Galvanized steel whiskers, feedlines, and sub-mast, galvanized steel heavy duty powder coated reflector, and yellow chromated steel mounting hardware, plus a bit of plastic. UHF only.


Update: These USA made antennas have been discontinued and replaced with Chinese made HD series antennas (4220HD, 4221HD, etc). I recommend the Antennas Direct (Terrestrial Digital) DB series antennas (DB2, DB4, etc) over these new Chinese made Channel Master double bowties. Although they are made in China as well, the build quality is better on the DB series. The DB2 has nice thick aluminum whiskers and a superior quality reflector.

Quote:
• Antenna measures 20 W x 17 H x 5 D

• Turning radius of 10 in.

• Free Balun Kit included with antenna

• Versatile mounting methods - Easily mounts to a univerasl antenna mast or to a standard satellite mount

• Powder coated components insures the antenna holds up under even the most extreme conditions

• Constructed of high quality galvanized steel

• Almost transparent design that wont obstruct your view

• Almost transparent design that wont obstruct your view

• Mount NOT included

• Powerful, but small - no bigger than most home satellite dishes




Channel Master CM 4221 - Quad Bow Tie




If you are really desperate, then you may consider the Channel Master 4221, quad bow tie as an indoor antenna. Prime candidate for an attic or closet install. Its the smallest, most compact with the least number of sharp protrusions of the commercially available quads. UHF only, but does give you some VHF Hi gain.


Tip: You can leave this one(or the CM 4220) in the box and use it like that. The cardboard seems to have little effect. This may be a better way to "mount" the antenna in a closet or elsewhere inside as you wont have protrusions that may snag items and provides protection for the antenna so that it wont be damaged accidentally. (Hat tip to unknown AVSforum poster)


Update: These USA made antennas have been discontinued and replaced with Chinese made HD series antennas (4220HD, 4221HD, etc). I recommend the Antennas Direct (Terrestrial Digital) DB series antennas (DB2, DB4, etc) over these new Chinese made Channel Master double bowties. Although they are made in China as well, the build quality is better on the DB series. The DB2 has nice thick aluminum whiskers and a superior quality reflector.

Quote:
receives digital & analog UHF TV signals

range is 45 miles

reception "beam width" is 45 degrees

4-bay bowtie dipole design

20"W x 5-1/4"D x 36-1/4"H
Coat Hanger Quad Bow Tie




Or you can try to build your own. These are inexpensive to make from common materials, but are good to excellent performers depending on the skill of the maker. You can build one without a reflector to save space and mount them in out of the way places. Even add an amplifier to boost performance so you can shove it in the closet or mount it in an attic. UHF only.


The pic is of My First Attempt at a Homemade Coat Hanger Quad Bow Tie, Youtube Video Specifications. I knocked one of the whiskers out of position. It can be adjusted simply.

Youtube Video: Coat Hanger HDTV Antenna!


There is also an active topic discussing improvements and techniques here on the AVSforum.

How to build a UHF antenna...


Here is a video produced by AVSforum member jwwm_2, of the improved design of the 4 bay advanced and tested by AVSforum mclapp on the How to build a UHF antenna thread. This desian uses wider spacing and longer elements to increase gain in the heart of the newly shrunken TV UHF band spectrum, and also has gain on UHF High. Much improved version of the 4 bay bowtie. There is a great comparison between this design and the famous Youtube Coathanger Antenna right at the beginning.

A Better HDTV Antenna





.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Silver Sensor Log Periodic Style Antennas


These style antennas are especially good at multipath or interfence rejection, because of there tight beamwidths aka very directional nature. Airport/airplane noise, multipath in big cities from buildings, etc.


Antiference Silver Sensor - Philips, Zenith, others




The famous original Silver Sensor. Lots of different brandings on this one. Looks more like a sculpture, but it works well, very directional though, not best if you are in the middle of several towers in different directions. May have to fuss with it too much for your liking. Also, it's a bit tippy. Still offers excellent performance for a small indoor antenna. Non Amped.....but you can add an amplifier and make this one even better. UHF only.


Addendum: The build quality of these is often criticized. Probably partially due to its propensity to tip over(instability), but also fit and finish.



Terk HDTVi and HDTVa




Terk here offers 2 good antennas which are Silver Sensor style log periodic antennas, but not exact clones. They are very good performers and highly directional. These offer the advantage of Rabbit Ears which are attached at the base of the unit, thus offering VHF reception. The rabbit ears have a limited range of motion because of the way they are attached to the base. The HDTVi version is un-amped, the HDTVa version contains an internal amplifier. The amped version give you more gain, and I think an unamped Rabbit Ears and Loop, would be more desireable in cases where the unamped version would more likely best fit. However the directionality of its UHF design can be useful where multi-path is a problem and amplification would overload the tuner, like big cities with lots of high rises. These units are a little tippy like the Silver Sensor but a little more stable as they have more mass in the base, but the base is not as wide and the rabbit ears complicates matters further. Like the original Silver Sensor, you may have to fuss with it too much for your liking, or it could be the perfect antenna to deal with multipath. VHF and UHF.



Philips PHDTV3 Amplified Silver Sensor





Channel Master 4040




Here is a Brand New version of the log periodic indoor antenna from Channel Master. It looks very promising. Highlights include long 110" cable and wall mounting option. UHF only.


Ill try to find out more ASAP.

Quote:
The CM-4040 indoor UHF/HDTV antenna offers excellent indoor UHF/HDTV reception.

The antenna design allows for increased forward gain while minimizing interference

from the side and rear. The antenna can be wall mounted or placed on top of the TV set

or entertainment center.

Godar Model 1




The Made in USA, Godar Model 1 is a nice log periodic UHF antenna with VHF dipoles. Its not amplified. It performed well and also is good for FM reception. The log periodic elements are encased in a low profile black plastic housing which is very sturdy and stable. The VHF telescoping Rabbit Ears can be extended if you need VHF reception or tucked away behind the low profile body for UHF only. Really nice setup. UHF and VHF and FM.


Godar offers several antennas for VHF, UHF, and FM. They are especially known for their FM antennas. Check out their website here at godarusa.com.


Terk HDTVo



Quote:
Dimensions:

width 39"

length (front to back housing bracket) 22"

depth (top to bottom of f-connector) 3.25"

Length of mast with bracket: 12”


Frequency range: VHF 40 MHz – 230 Mhz (channels 2-13)

UHF 470 MHz-862 Mhz (channels 14-69)

Gain: UHF 11 dB typical

VHF 12 dB typical

Insertion loss: -1 +/1 1dB max.


Weight: 7 lbs


Included in packaging:

- HDTVo antenna

- Power injector

- Mini-mast mounting bracket

- All associated mounting screws

Cornet ET-8DA





.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
Miscellaneous Design Antennas


Winegard Sharp Shooter SS-3000 and Terk HDTVlp(SS-3000 clone)





The Winegard Sharp Shooter 3000 is an excellent performing antenna. I really like this one with its pleasing wing style. Its fairly wide and is great with multipath thanks to it reflector screen which also helps with directionality and gain. This "scatter plane" reflector is removable for those who are better served by an omni directional antenna. This antenna seems to be pretty forgiving with placement as well. It has an integrated amplifier and and incorporates and FM Trap. VHF Hi performance is OK, VHF Lo is not so good. UHF is where it shines. One thing to note, it has a thin unshielded cable that is detachable which connects to the base of the unit. However, a thicker shielded cable does not fit in the notch in the plastic base which this cable exits...this probably however can be modified pretty easily. It works well at my location 45 miles out from the towers. VHF and UHF.



Quote:
Winegard SS 3000 3000 Indoor UHF/VHF Antenna (SS-3000)



Winegards newest and best all-band indoor directional / bidirectional DTV/HDTV Antenna platform. Perfect for close range off-air reception in urban areas.



Winegard "Scatter-Plane" to reject digital multi-path

90 Day Warranty

Response throughout VHF/UHF bandpass

Receives and resonates indoor analog and outstanding DTV/HDTV signals up to 20 miles from the transmit source

Reception for apartment/condominium dweller to receive digital broadcasts where line-of-sight to the transmit source is blocked

Only 26.75 inches wide

Weighs only 1.5 pounds

Specifically designed to capture reflected off-air HDTV and DTV broadcasts signals

Integrates an ultra-low noise amplifier design with an ultra-low noise figure for a DTV/HDTV picture

Great antenna in urban areas where HDTV and DTV signals bounce off buildings


SS-3000


Mechanical


Width ............................................................ ........ 26.75"

Height ............................................................ ............. 5"

Depth ............................................................ ......... 4.25"

Antenna weight .................................................. 1.5 lbs.

Will ship UPS


Electrical


Bandpass .................................................. 54-806 MHz

Power requirements ......................... [email protected] VDC

Amplifier gain ........................... 7-10 dB ave. VHF/UHF

Amplifier noise figure ........... 1.0 dB or lower VHF/UHF


VHF Low Band (54-88 Mhz, CH 2-6)

Nonamplified element gain ................................ -15 dB

Ave. half power beam width ..................................... 87°

Ave. front to back ratio ......................................... 1.2 dB

VSWR........................................................ ......... 2.0- 2.1


VHF High Band (174-216 Mhz, CH 7-13)

Nonamplified element gain .................................. -5 dB

Ave. half power beam width ..................................... 70°

Ave. front to back ratio ....................................... 11.3 dB

VSWR........................................................ ......... 2.2- 2.3


UHF (470-806 Mhz, CH 14-69)

Nonamplified element gain ................................... 0 dB

Ave. half power beam width ..................................... 36°

Ave. front to back ratio ......................................... 7.5 dB

VSWR........................................................ ......... 2.2- 3.3

http://www.winegarddirect.com/ss-300...00_pattern.gif




Radio Shack 15-1892 with Remote - "The UFO"

aka "The Magic Mushroom," "The Starship Enterprise," and "The Frisbee"




This one, affectionately known as "The UFO," is a very interesting antenna. It gets great user reviews, and its performance is excellent. I really like this antenna. It is like a Smart Antenna but without the tuner interface, instead you operate it by remote control. Its automated, you can set it to move within its UFO disc, to adjust the antenna for individual stations that may be located in differing directions and also adjust the gain for each channel. Can be really handy for those whose broadcast towers are not all in one direction. Comes with a remote to tune the antenna from the chair, to preset channel positions. This one can be extremely useful for those who are in reach of more than one broadcast market. Has Rabbit Ears for VHF which are limited in range of motion by the UHF disc. This one has an FM Trap. Amplified. VHF and UHF.


Here is a link to my in depth review of the RS 1892 UFO's Features and Use on page 10 of this thread.

Quote:
Tune in to a better picture.

This indoor antenna allows you to enjoy the best possible HDTV programming. Experience sharper HDTV picture quality with three amplifier gains (19dB, 15dB and 10dB), 330° rotation and 12 reception directions. The LCD displays the memory numbers, gain settings and direction for easy reference. The remote control works indoors or outdoors, up to 50 feet away.


3 amplifier gain levels

330° rotation and 12 reception directions

Remote control range of 50 feet, indoors and outdoors


What's in the box

Amplified antenna

Power adapter 12V 350mA

6 feet 75ohm coaxial cable with Gold-plated connector

CR2032 Li-ion battery x 1 (for RF remote control unit)

Remote

User's Guide


Godar HD-3




The Godar HD-3 is designed for Attic Install. An unsual design, it performed well, but was a bit finicky about placement. Check out the details at the Godar website here .



Antennas Direct ClearStream 1




Quote:
The first in a series of compact, highly efficient antennas designed and optimized for 2009 frequencies associated with the DTV transition.


High gain, and compact design offer excellent gain and impedance matching across the whole post 2009 DTV spectrum. The Clearstream is vastly superior to the existing compact antennas for receiving DTV signals. Good directivity at all frequencies with a peak gain of 8 dB. Provides substantial performance gains over commonly available compact antennas.

Range: Up to 30 Miles

Gain of 8 dBi

Consistent gain through the entire DTV channel spectrum

Totally new engineering for post-2009 DTV frequencies

Great for indoor, outdoor and attic use

Dimensions 10”h x 10” w x 4.5” deep

Antennas Direct ClearStream2 (Terrestrial Digital)




RCA ANT751 (aka EZ HD)






Digitenna City



Digitenna Metro





Digitenna Suburban





.




.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
UHF Flat Panel Array Style Antennas



Meritline "Artec" "Kingbox" Antenna




This is a fantastic little UHF flat panel antenna. Expect similar performance to the Classic Single Bowtie above, pretty darn good on UHF. The panel is 8" long by 4" high. It comes with an adjustable mount which you can angle at 90 degrees and use the suction cup on the bottom to mount to a window. The antenna is sandwiched between 2 strong pieces of plastic film which is somewhat flexible but bounces back into shape. This antenna along with the Classic Double Bowtie and RCA ANT108 are great backpackable portable antenna solutions. UHF only. (might pick up some strong VHF in a pinch)


Antennas Direct PF7 - The Picture Frame Antenna




Ive seen this one ranked high for performance among set top indoor antennas in a UK test and elsewhere. This one performs better than most Rabbit Ear and Loops on UHF. Wife friendly. UHF only.


Here is one netizen's review of The Picture Frame Antenna.

Quote:
I bought this with very low expectations for our 19" kitchen LCD television. We had been using a Terk HDTVa but that was too large and just did not work that well anywhere in our kitchen. (It works great now that we moved it in our home theater room) Enter the lowly HDtv Picture Frame Antenna. I put it on the wall facing the direction of my towers and presto, all the local stations tuned right in! It really works amazingly well.


One other important thing to note is that the included wooden frame is only average in quality. However, the antenna part of the frame (the back part) is completely removable and fits nicely into most 8x10 frames. So basically, you can customize it very easily to fit any room if the plain brown frame included does not match your style. I have mine in a wide silver and blue frame and it looks great.
Quote:
Range: Up to 15 Miles

Gain of approximately 6.5 dB

Ideal for UHF channels 14-69

Cherry wood frame with glass photo cover

Landscape orientation with wall hanger or table mount

Includes 6ft 75 ohm RG6 coaxial cable fitted with F-Type connector

Dimensions: 9" high x 11" wide x 1" deep to hold an 8" x 10" photo.

RCA ANT1500 Digital Flat Panel Antenna





The RCA ANT1500 is better than most unamplified Rabbit Ear and Loops. It is a 10" square uhf panel that is 1/2" thick and is bi-directional in its gain pattern. Very sleek aesthetics. It has a permanently attached 6ft coax cable and a stainless steel bar that slides into the back to form a stand. There are also screw head mounts moulded and cut into the backside plastic as well as molded bumps to keep the unit off of the wall a bit when wall mounting. UHF and VHF.



Quote:
New, patent pending technology

Omni directional design allows for multiple placement options

Optimized for HDTV reception with improved reception in both UHF and VHF bands.

Low Profile Design

Mounts on wall, lays flat or sits up right with included stand

Product in Inches (L x W x H): 11.0 x 0.5 x 10.0
Radio Shack DA-5200




People seem love this popular little amplified antenna from user reviews, and they should. Expect excellent performance from this surprising little gem. And it is small. It comes with a thoughtful array of accessories, including 12ft or so of coax, screws and wall anchors, and u bolts. It has a pretty good internal amplifier. The mounting system is dynamite. It's an single piece articulating arm made from quality materials, steel and ABS plastic, hefty for its size. The performance is what matters though, and this one performs. UHF only.


Quote:
This low-profile outdoor HDTV antenna is small enough in size that it's perfect for apartments or other areas where space is limited. With its anti-UV coating and waterproof design this antenna will last for years.


The neat stuff

Amplifier gain of 17-23dB helps reception of weaker stations

Wall-mountable (installation kit included)

Can mount indoors in an attic, closet or other out of the way location



What's in the box

Low profile outdoor/indoor HDTV antenna

3m RG59U cable (F male to F male)

15cm RG59U cable (F male to F male)

Power adapter

Installation kit


Product Length 4.45 inches

Product Height 8.22 inches

Product Width 2.83 inches

http://www.radioshack.com/product/in...ab=custRatings
Philips MANT940




The Philips MANT940 antenna gets good user reviews and comes with a nice versatile solid mount, but a bit more complicated than the RS DA-5200 above, and a good assortment of accessories, like 20ft of coax cable, power injector. It is an amplified unit and offers very good performance. It offer some VHF Hi gain as well. UHF only.

Quote:
Product Details:


Easiest and best solution for urban/surburban UHF DTV (Digital TV) reception. Perfect alternative to conventional outdoor antennas. Can be used indoors but designed for outdoor use(weather resistant).


Features:


•Built-in optimum gain amplifier, 18dB UHF, with low noise circuitry, under 3.5dB, for best possible DTV performance

•Efficient flat panel UHF array, up to 40 miles range

•Compact yet effective size, 5” X 10”

•Easily mounts on wall, mast or railing

•Can be used with rotor (optional – mast only)

•Ideal for RV or boat

• Includes 20’ cable, power injector, power supply, and flexible mounting kit.
GE Futura Outdoor




Quote:
20dB Gain Amplification

Noise Eliminator Circuitry Filter

Noise Eliminator Circuitry Filter

Designed to Mount Horizontally or Vertically


Monoprice Antenna




Expect similar performace as the Philips MANT950 and Radio Shack DA-5200 above. This one has a similar gooseneck mount as the GE Futura Outdoor above.



HD 650 Antenna




Expect similar performace as the Philips MANT950 and Radio Shack DA-5200 above. Nice looking mount.



Winegard Square Shooter SS-1000(non amplified) and SS-2000(amplified) and Terk HDTVs(SS-2000 clone)





Quote:
Winegard SS-1000 SquareShooter UHF Only Digital/Analog/HDTV Antenna System (SS-1000)


Winegard’s newest digital antenna. A true technological break-through and Innovations award winner. It’s the Best designed, Best-built, Best performing, Best looking, Easiest to install, Urban/metropolitan HDTV antenna available.



Comes with J-Type Mast and Mount.

Includes hardware to mount to standard DIRECTV / DishNetwork dish masts (U-bolts and nuts are included to attach to dish antenna mast)

Average beamwidth: 61°

Average VSWR across band: 1.3:1

Average Front to back: 13 db

Average antenna gain across band 470-806: 4.5 db

Maximum Width: 16 x 16 x 4

Box size: 24½ x 24 x 6½

Range for channels 14-69 0-20 mile average

Choose amplified model SS-2000 with built-in pre-amp when 25 miles from tower or further. Integrated 12dB gain amplifier across both UHF/VHF bands for better reception of digital HDTV channels.



Winegard’s newest digital antenna. A true technological break-through and Innovations award winner. It’s the Best designed, Best-built, Best performing, Best looking, Easiest to install, Urban/metropolitan HDTV antenna available. An absolutely unique antenna with unlimited installation options. Fast and easy installation, Requiring no assembly. Because of its revolutionary design, it offers multiple mounting solutions for the best digital TV reception up to 50 miles out. Can be easily mounted using familiar DBS satellite antenna hardware, on Walls, Fascias, Roofs, Railings, Over a Satellite Dish, In the attic, On patios, Almost any place an installer needs to place it.


The latest DTV set-top boxes show significant improvements in receiving DTV signals, particularly with respect to multipath echoes that can in some cases prevent successful reception. However, antenna characteristics are still an important part of the whole system. While difficult DTV reception can often be overcome using high gain and directional Yagi, logperiodic, or multi-element bow tie antennas, these tend to be expensive, large and suitable only for outdoors or attic mounting. There continues to be a need for small antennas optimized for DTV reception in urban environments, where signal strengths may be good but multipath is frequently a problem.


At the Consumer Electronics Show this year the Winegard Company introduced a compact antenna specifically for DTV reception in urban locations but with the ability to receive signals over longer distances. The SS-2000 is built on the same platform as the SS-1000 “SquareShooter™” which the design won a CES Innovations Award in the Design and Engineering Showcase. With the integrated 12 dB amplifier, the new SS-2000 is much better suited for digital HD OFF-AIR reception than the SS-1000 because of the confusion caused by the difference in the UHF/VHF gain in the non-amplified version (SS-1000). Winegard says that the SquareShooter utilizes non-traditional electromagnetic antenna design for superior performance and, at the same time, provides that new contemporary “look and feel” desired by DTV/HDTV consumers, and states that it will outperform all but the largest high-band VHF/UHF directional antenna systems.


Increased front-to-back ratio is obtained using a rear "scatter plane" to block signals from the back of the antenna. The good front-to-back ratio, absence of side lobes, and quite narrow acceptance angle should all contribute to excellent performance under multipath conditions. A key feature of the sinuous antenna is its equal sensitivity to signals of all polarizations – a technique suggested by others but not previously implemented in a consumer product. Field tests have shown that, as well as providing rejection of multipath echoes when receiving the main signal, the antenna allows reception in urban environments using a signal reflected from an adjacent building. The antenna has no internal preamplifier. However, Winegard has a new external preamp (HDP-269) for DTV with very uniform gain over the full band and excellent intermodulation performance, which is suggested for long feeder runs.


The SquareShooter antenna element is produced using conductive ink that is screen-printed onto a polycarbonate base. The element is housed in an enclosure size 16” x 16” x 4” suitable for indoor or outdoor use, with a wide range of mounting options.



http://www.winegarddirect.com/viewitem.asp?p=SS-2000





.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
Stick Style Antennas



Philips MANT950




This antenna and the RCA ANT806 along with the Terk TV-55 are reviewed on this page . VHF and UHF.


Quote:
VHF amplification 18 dB and UHF amplification 15 dB

Channels 2-69

Dual element design for best possible reception, up to 40 miles

Weather resistant with paintable surface

20' Coaxial cable and mounting kit

RCA ANT806




This antenna along with the Philips MANT950 and the Terk TV-55 are reviewed on this page . UHF and VHF.


Quote:
Ultra-low noise amplifier provides clear powerful reception

Optimized for HDTV reception

18dB power injection boosts UHF/VHF signals

Ultra-durable weatherproof housing


Winegard Sensar III GS-1100 and GS-2200





Quote:
Winegard Sensar® III Digital Ready Antenna System GS-2200/GS-1100

Perfect for home use, Winegard Sensar III antennas are digital ready! These antennas are bidirectional (VHF), directional (UHF) and will provide excellent reception 0-50 miles from the broadcast source. The redesigned head updates the Sensar III appearance, and the embossed “rib” improves stability of the wing.


The attractive gray housing and elements will blend with any siding or roof when mounted. Both models, GS-1100 and GS-2200, fit on masts up to two inches in diameter. For mounting as off-air companion antenna to an 18 inch satellite dish, use Winegard’s universal home mount, DS-1111.


Model GS-2200 is an amplified antenna recommended for viewing areas 20 to 45 miles from television signal transmitter. This model features a built-in digital preamplifier with a gain of 15.5 dB average ideally suited for DTV/HDTV reception. It also includes a power supply, hardware and easy-to-install mast clamp assembly.


Model GS-1100 is a non-amplified antenna designed for reception in metropolitan areas up to 25 miles away from television signal transmitters.


Sensar III shown mounted with Winegard’s 18 inch home satellite dish, on our DS-1111 mount meeting all wind load requirements for DIRECTV® and DISH Network® . This mount is designed for use with most home satellite mounts. DS-1111 shown here.


Antenna Specifications


Antenna/bracket width .......... 6.25”

Antenna length .....................46.5”

Fixed FM trap .................... -15 dB

Impedance ........................ 75 ohm

Amplifier gain

VHF ......................... 15.5 dB avg.

UHF ......................... 15.5 dB avg.

Bandpass..................54 - 850 MHz

Power Requirement......................

Current Usage 60 ma @ +12 VDC

Average Noise.......................3 dB


Total Input .....VHF/UHF 200,000 μv

Output ...........75 ohm / 68 channel


Reception Range:


GS-2200 ................. 20 - 45 miles

GS-1100 ................... 10 - 25 miles


Ship weight .......................... 5 lbs.

Carton Dimensions .....49” x 7.5” x 4.25”

Ships UPS


Made in U.S.A.

http://www.winegarddirect.com/sensar...II-antenna.asp
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
RV Style Antennas



Radio Shack 15-1634 Omni-Directional



Quote:
The omnipresence antenna

This 21" diameter antenna for suburban/urban areas, along with RVs, trailers, and boats. The estimated range for the low-profile Omnidirectional Amplified TV Antenna is about 30-35 miles with good, open terrain. It's great for areas where TV stations are located in different directions, with its 360-degree reception there's no need for an antenna rotator.


Weather resistant

Built-in amp boosts signals 20dB

Ideal for areas where TV stations are located in different directions
Winegard MS-2000 MetroStar




Quote:
MS-2000 MetroStar, for homes, apartments, mobile homes, condos, townhouses, offices; excellent VHF/UHF reception.


Receivers signals from all directions

Comes with 50 FT of 75 Ohm cable and a 6 FT TV coax cable

Perfect companion for DBS installations

Box size: 21¾ x 22¾ x 2¾

Home Owners Associate friendly


Omnidirectional for install-&-forget convenience; no rotator system needed, built-in preamplifier to boost signal strength—up to six times the received signal on VHF, nine times on UHF. Easy to install with hand tools on any antenna mast or light-duty antenna mount. Includes antenna, power supply, 50 75 ohm coaxl cable, 6 TV set cable, hardware, mounting bracket. Good companion for digital satellite systems.


Bandpass.............................................VHF-54 to 88, 170 to 216 MHz

............................................................ ....................UHF-470 to 810 MHz

FM Trap (fixed)................................Attenuates 88 to 108 MHZ, -15dB

Amplifier Gain.................................VHF-15.5 dB avg. UHF 19.5dB avg.

Impedence................................................... ..........75 ohm unbalanced

Response.................................................... .................... .25 per 6 MHz

VSWR........................................................ ..................... 1.8:1 maximum

Power Required..........................................117 VAC, 60 Hz, 4.3 watts

Weatherproof Housing........Engineered thermoplastic, 21-1/2" wide

Mounting Type................................................Round mast up to 2" OD

http://www.winegarddirect.com/images...lar_MS2000.gif

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #10 ·
On Deck - The Batter's Circle


Jensen TV-920




A Neutronics AN AV 891





Quantum FX ANT-104





Quantum FX ANT-105






MaxView OmniSat Omni UHF/VHF



.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
The Dog House


Not recommended by this author....


Jensen TV-931

Radio Shack 15-1870

Samsung Axession TV DA-1000

GE Contempo

GE Infinity

GE Futura Indoor
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #12 ·
Some very informative articles, reviews, tests, shootouts, and websites. I highly recommend checking these out.



Lots of great information on this website. The list of antennas below is hotlinked to pages which address each antenna individually with comments charts and graphs. The navigation on that site isnt the best, here is a link to the HDTV Primer home page which contains all kinds of HDTV information, antenna and otherwise.

Quote:
HDTV Primer


Comparing some commercially available antennas


Net Gain for some common UHF antennas




A Channel Master 4228 8-Bay

B Channel Master 4221 4-Bay (3021)

C Channel Master 4248 Yagi/Corner-Reflector (3023)

D Televes DAT-75 Yagi/Corner-Reflector

E Winegard PR-8800 8-Bay

F Winegard PR-4400 4-Bay

G Channel Master 4242 VHF/UHF Combo

H Channel Master 3018 VHF/UHF Combo

I Zenith Silver Sensor indoor LPDA

J Small indoor loops

K Double-Bow

L AntennasDirect DB-2

M Winegard Square Shooter

N Winegard PR-9032 Yagi/Corner-Reflector

O Channel Master 3671B VHF/UHF Combo

P MegaWave Wideband Indoor Antenna

Q Winegard SharpShooter Indoor Directional Antenna

R AntennasDirect DB-4 4-Bay

S AntennasDirect DB-8 8-Bay

T AntennasDirect XG91 Yagi/Corner-Reflector

http://www.hdtvprimer.com/ANTENNAS/comparing.html


This one is a little less intimidating for newbies.


Here is Fox Charlotte's Digital Dude on HDTV antennas. Humorous and informative.


Consumer Reports has a nice friendly guide to Televisioin Issues.


These three pages from the HDTVexpert contain shootouts of various models of indoor antennas. Testing equipment is used to ascertain relative performance. Very informative, check out his home page too, where he discusses Broadcast issues and Reviews equipment, such a Converter Boxes, Tuners, Antennas, and Signal Analyzers.

Quote:
HDTVexpert


HEAVY METAL, PART 2


Comparisons of indoor antennas for VHF-UHF DTV reception


by Peter H. Putman, CTS

http://www.hdtvexpert.com/pages/antin.htm
Quote:
HDTVexpert


WINEGARD’S SS-1000 SQUARE SHOOTER: A BETTER MOUSETRAP?


by Peter Putman, CTS, ISF

http://www.hdtvexpert.com/pages/squareshot.htm
Quote:
HDTVexpert


Winegard SS-2000 Square Shooter TV Antenna


Peter Putman, CTS, ISF

http://www.hdtvexpert.com/pages/winegardss.htm

Quote:
HEAVY METAL, PART I


VHF-UHF Antennas Compared for Outdoor DTV Reception


by Peter H. Putman, CTS

http://www.hdtvexpert.com/pages/antout.htm

Quote:
Five (Antennas) To Get Ready


PETER PUTMAN, CTS

http://www.hdtvexpert.com/pages_c/Five_Antennas.html


This is the WALB News 10 report which includes information from the presentation at the Spring 2008 Broadcast Engineering Conference. I havent been able to get more data on this....but there is good stuff present in this WALB report non the less.




The Kyes Antenna site is almost as informatioin loaded as the HDTVprimer site. Nice commentary on How to Get the Most out of Rabbit Ears, Common TV and FM Antenna Types, Amplifiers: The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly, and much more.





Other good sites for antenna reviews.

Quote:
Amazon.com has quite a few reviews at their site under individual antenna headings.



HDTV Antenna Labs has a good review site with rankings as well.

http://www.hdtvantennalabs.com/indoor.php


This AVS subforum has city by city threads where locals discuss the local reception environment and issues, and is a good place to find what antennas, others in your area and situation have found success with. Find your area in the list and click....then read, search, join the discussion, and post questions.



Here is the thread about rotors, antennas, boosters, amplifiers, splitters, attenuators, masts, towers, grouding blocks, and all kinds of antenna accessories. The first page has lots of good links to information on the web. Join the discussion and ask questions.


This is The Official AVS Antenna Topic! Join the discussion and ask questions. Lots of antenna gurus frequent this thread.


DIY Quickie Antenna Reflector


If you are having trouble with your current antenna. You can give this homebrew solution a try. All you need is some cardboard and aluminum foil. Lets say you have a basic unamplified RE & Loop antenna....and you are struggling to bring in a couple of UHF stations. Cut out a piece of a sturdy coardboard box, the sturdier the better, apporximately 4" wider on all sides as the loop. Then wrap in aluminum foil. Now turn your loop so that one side is facing the towers you are trying to reach.....and position your new homebrew reflector screen about 4" behind the loop. Youve just made your bi-directional UHF loop into a directional antenna, increasing forward gain. Move the reflector screen forward and backwards from the 4" position until you find the sweet spot. Also this reflector can be used to shield your antenna from electrical noise and interference from other home devices like computers.


Here is a pic to help vizualize the reflector. This one is much larger than is necessary for the antenna in the picture.

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
Oldies but Goldies...Discontinued but not Forgotten...



Radio Shack Double Bow Tie




This is the legendary RS Double Bow. Now discontinued. Some people mistake it for art! Great little antenna with reflector and feet for standing up. However its bows are a bit too small for the best UHF performance. The DB2 and CM4220 surpass it with their larger bow ties. Still an excellent performer....even better if you add an amplifier. UHF only.


EDIT: This one has made a reappearance as the Channel Master 4149, which is still available for sale, online.




Radio Shack 15-1862




This is the legendary RS 1862. Now discontinued. "The Holy Grail of Indoor Antennas." Amplified. UHF and VHF.




Radio Shack 15-1880




This is the legendary RS 1880. Now discontinued. This one was available after the 1862 was discontinued. Besides the silver accents and the green power on indicator light (previously red), the most important difference between the 2 is a slightly lower gain amplifier on this newer version. I have 2 of these. They are pretty reliable at 45 miles from the towers at my location. UHF and VHF.



Samsung TV5.4 SAX




Samsung made a quick entrance and exit in the TV antenna marketplace. It had a couple of models out. Not much info out on them, but this one looks promising as a Silver Sensor clone. Looks like the wider base will make them more stable, a thoughtful design improvement. Looks like they might be adjustable at the arm/base interface which would also be welcome. Has a Star Trek aesthetic look to it. UHF only.


Addendum: This one may have been discontinued and forgotten. LOL!





Recoton 350 UHF/VHF/FM Color Antenna




This one recieves COLOR transmissions! LOL!


.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #14 ·
Working on these ideas


How to find a sweet spot

Antenna aiming and Rabbit Ear positioning

Paper Clip Antenna






My Antenna List


DB2

RS 1880

RS DA 5200

RS Classic Single Bow

RS UFO

RCA ANT108

RS Double Bow Tie

Channel Master 4220

Winegard HD-4400

FM Dipole

Terk TV-2

Petra SuperPower 32db

Channel Master 4221

RS 1874 Budget

AntennaCraft G1483 4 Bay Gray Hoverman

Antennas Direct ClearStream1 Convertible

GE Quantum

Philips 2750

Artec Special

GE Optima



Returned or Sold



Youtube 4 Bay

RCA ANT1020

Channel Master 4030

Terk TV-5

Terk TV-1

RCA ANT806

Philips MANT950

Philips MANT940

RCA ANT1500

Godar Model 1

Godar HD-3

Terk TV-3

GE Infinity

AntennasDirect PF7 Picture Frame Antenna

Antennas Direct Clearstream 2

RS 1634

Terk TV-55

GE Infinity

GE Futura Outdoor

RS 1868

Jensen TV-931

xg91

RS 1870

Winegard SS-3000

Terk HDTVa

Philips PHDTV1 Silver Sensor

Samsung Axession TV-DA1000/GE Contempo

Philips MANT510

GE Futura Indoor

Philips PHDTV3
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
464 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by EscapeVelocity /forum/post/14047874


Winegard Sensar III GS-1100 and GS-2200







My DISH installer put the gs1100 on my roof. WHY?? The 622 is a digital only receiver. It failed many times to pick up my locals at only 21 miles. I compared it against my Youtube on the garage TV. No comparison. The gs- 1100 went out with the trash.

61231
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
Thanks for the input spokybob.


Like all antennas, YMMV. Im sure that we will have many that disagree, clarify, and specify. At least Im hoping. I hope others share some of their favorites, too.


That being said.


My friend has one on his camper out on "the land," which is 45 miles from the towers and he gets good signals on analog. I dont know if its the GS-2200(amplified version) or the GS-1100, though. I was pretty impressed though.


But I do know that these are bipolar on vhf and highly directional on uhf as the charts show, perhaps the install was bad.


No doubt the Quad Bow Ties rock.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
965 Posts
Those triple threat antennas like the MANT510, how do you aim 'em? Two dipoles plus a UHF loop has got to be a problem. 3x360. That Terk one...has anyone actually used that for both UHF and VHF at the same time? The status of the dipoles definitely influences UHF reception.


I recently drove several streets in the neighborhood in search of someone with a 4228 on the roof, but couldn't find one. I'll try again.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,772 Posts
Discussion Starter · #19 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by deltaguy /forum/post/14050998


Those triple threat antennas like the MANT510, how do you aim 'em?

Like a classic Rabbit Ears and Loop.


Quote:
That Terk one...has anyone actually used that for both UHF and VHF at the same time?

No.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
965 Posts
I've been aiming, and re-aiming, a 510 for over a year and a half. It can do things the classic dipoles and bowtie can't. The uhf square can be pointed up or down for example. One of my latest crazy ideas was to point one of the dipoles down towards the patio hoping for a rebound. It helped.


I would have thought some folks would already have experience trying to get DTV via both vhf & uhf. In the bay area channel 12 is being used by San Jose's KNTV. It's too far away for me. I'll have a shot next year when 9 & 10 will be used in Sacto.
 
1 - 20 of 3347 Posts
Top