From review:
High bitrate AVC is better than VC-1 on HD DVD ...at least in this case.
High bitrate AVC is better than VC-1 on HD DVD ...at least in this case.
-
Our native mobile app has a new name: Fora Communities. Learn more.
1 - 20 of 28 Posts
What does he say in the very next sentence?
![]()
What does he say in the very next sentence?
Great that the pq is good, but would it have killed them to put a lossless track on it
![]()
That's the real ssue. Where is the Lossless audio.
I can't believe how excited everyone is getting over the "tiniest" difference in an "identical" transfer. The way it sounds to me is that the difference is sooooooo minor it could even all be in his own perception.
Quote:
Originally Posted by H9K_ /forum/post/0
Great that the pq is good, but would it have killed them to put a lossless track on it![]()
That's the real ssue. Where is the Lossless audio.
I can't believe how excited everyone is getting over the "tiniest" difference in an "identical" transfer. The way it sounds to me is that the difference is sooooooo minor it could even all be in his own perception.
PQ quality wise, the difference is nothing to get excited about. I'll hopefully get this from Blockbuster online and see for myself.
True, he shouldn't have even posted here either because you know trolls always lurk
![]()
True, he shouldn't have even posted here either because you know trolls always lurk
Oh but the difference is NOT perceptible there according to blu only fans
![]()
Oh but the difference is NOT perceptible there according to blu only fans
I have the same question....cuz Flags just shipped from Netflix
![]()
I have the same question....cuz Flags just shipped from Netflix
Well Flags was made first. And it's two sides of the same story. Letters is rated better, and it seems to have better AQ.
So my thinking is I'm going to watch Flags as the appetizer and Letters as the main course. Save the best for last.
But I like doing move marathons. like watching LOTR for 12hrs.
![]()
Quote:
Originally Posted by ajamils /forum/post/0
I have the same question....cuz Flags just shipped from Netflix![]()
Well Flags was made first. And it's two sides of the same story. Letters is rated better, and it seems to have better AQ.
So my thinking is I'm going to watch Flags as the appetizer and Letters as the main course. Save the best for last.
But I like doing move marathons. like watching LOTR for 12hrs.
If you want to talk about audio quality doesn't Blu-ray win in that area easily with its more common use of PCM/lossless audio? That is unless you believe that lossy audio is good enough in which case one would have to prove that 1.5 Mbps DD+ is noticeably better than 640 Kbps DD.
Actually in all seriousness it depends on the poster. Some posters think that 640 Kbps DD/DD+ is good enough, some posters think that 1.5 Mbps DD+/DTS is good enough, and some posters think that PCM/lossless audio is best of all.
Also from the looks of it both Peter M. Bracke and Kenneth Brown are basically just giving out an extra half a star for every new HD DVD titles that use 1.5 Mbps DD+ based on the apparent belief that it sounds better. A bit strange considering they never heard any difference between 640 Kbps DD and 1.5 Mbps DD+ before now.
If you want to talk about audio quality doesn't Blu-ray win in that area easily with its more common use of PCM/lossless audio? That is unless you believe that lossy audio is good enough in which case one would have to prove that 1.5 Mbps DD+ is noticeably better than 640 Kbps DD.
Quote:
Originally Posted by HPforMe /forum/post/0
Oh but the difference is NOT perceptible there according to blu only fans![]()
Actually in all seriousness it depends on the poster. Some posters think that 640 Kbps DD/DD+ is good enough, some posters think that 1.5 Mbps DD+/DTS is good enough, and some posters think that PCM/lossless audio is best of all.
Also from the looks of it both Peter M. Bracke and Kenneth Brown are basically just giving out an extra half a star for every new HD DVD titles that use 1.5 Mbps DD+ based on the apparent belief that it sounds better. A bit strange considering they never heard any difference between 640 Kbps DD and 1.5 Mbps DD+ before now.
1 - 20 of 28 Posts
