Thanks for the link. With the HDCAM SR's introduction, mentioned some months back here, I got the impression it was aimed more at cinema use than broadcasting. Don't have the numbers at hand, but recall it has a higher bit rate and eliminates the >1440 filtering of the HDCAM.
Curious, though, this extra fidelity is being adopted to a format restricted to 1280X720p instead of potentially extending the fidelity of 1080i sources. Then again, if recent discussions saying professional Panasonic HD D5 machines restrict telecined films to 800-1300-pixel resolvable detail are valid, perhaps it doesn't make any difference whether the HDCAM SR is applied to 1080i or 720p. Hmm. Looks like it's time for a HD D5 versus HDCAM SR spectrum-analysis shootout. There's still two final fidelity 'gates', though: prefiltering/lossy MPEG-2 compression at stations, and resolution limits with most HD displays. -- John
Curious, though, this extra fidelity is being adopted to a format restricted to 1280X720p instead of potentially extending the fidelity of 1080i sources. Then again, if recent discussions saying professional Panasonic HD D5 machines restrict telecined films to 800-1300-pixel resolvable detail are valid, perhaps it doesn't make any difference whether the HDCAM SR is applied to 1080i or 720p. Hmm. Looks like it's time for a HD D5 versus HDCAM SR spectrum-analysis shootout. There's still two final fidelity 'gates', though: prefiltering/lossy MPEG-2 compression at stations, and resolution limits with most HD displays. -- John