You have a DirecTV receiver with no analog audio output? Are you sure?
-
Our native mobile app has a new name: Fora Communities. Learn more.
HDMI & red white cable issue
I have an older hdtv. It has 2 hdmi inputs (video only) and to get the audio you have to connect red white cables to the audio inputs on the tv. The problem is that the dvd players and direct tv box I have don't have red/white rca slots.
My direct tv box has a coaxial and optical digital audio out slot next to the hdmi slot
My dvd player only has a optical digital out slot next to the hdmi slot.
I've been just using the g,b,y,r,w,r slots, but I am planning on selling the tv soon and I know if I can't get a cable that will make it work with newer hardware I will never be able to sell it.
Solutions?
My direct tv box has a coaxial and optical digital audio out slot next to the hdmi slot
My dvd player only has a optical digital out slot next to the hdmi slot.
I've been just using the g,b,y,r,w,r slots, but I am planning on selling the tv soon and I know if I can't get a cable that will make it work with newer hardware I will never be able to sell it.
Solutions?
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
The red, white on the receiver are only for the yellow,blue, green outputs.
The coaxial and optical outputs are for the hdmi, trust me I already tried.
I found these...which one would I need to do the trick?
http://www.monoprice.com/products/pr...mat=4#feedback
http://www.monoprice.com/products/product.asp?c_id=104&cp_id=10423&cs_id=1042302&p_id=8127&seq=1&format=2
Quote:
Originally Posted by petern /forum/post/20844082
You have a DirecTV receiver with no analog audio output? Are you sure?
The red, white on the receiver are only for the yellow,blue, green outputs.
The coaxial and optical outputs are for the hdmi, trust me I already tried.
I found these...which one would I need to do the trick?
http://www.monoprice.com/products/pr...mat=4#feedback
http://www.monoprice.com/products/product.asp?c_id=104&cp_id=10423&cs_id=1042302&p_id=8127&seq=1&format=2
What's the model number of your DirecTV receiver? It's on the sticker in the card slot door.
The Yellow RCA is Composite video output (not HD).
The Green, Blue, & Red RCA video outputs are component video (480i/p, 720p, 1080i).
The Red and White analog audio outputs, and the Digital Coax and Digital Optical should be always active no matter which video output you are using.
The Yellow RCA is Composite video output (not HD).
The Green, Blue, & Red RCA video outputs are component video (480i/p, 720p, 1080i).
The Red and White analog audio outputs, and the Digital Coax and Digital Optical should be always active no matter which video output you are using.
The receiver model number is hr22-100
on the HD box you have, all outputs are ALWAYS hot.
Connect your HDMI and red/white.
What TV/monitor is this, cause I don't ever remember an HDMI equipped device where the HDMI didn't include audio.
Connect your HDMI and red/white.
What TV/monitor is this, cause I don't ever remember an HDMI equipped device where the HDMI didn't include audio.
Quote:
This is indeed an odd one. HDMI, by current specification, includes audio. HDMI 1.0 was intended as an improvement to DVI-HDTV which did not include audio. The OP's manual didn't have a date, as far as I saw, but I would guess 2002 or 2003.
| Originally Posted by schan1269 on the HD box you have, all outputs are ALWAYS hot. Connect your HDMI and red/white. What TV/monitor is this, cause I don't ever remember an HDMI equipped device where the HDMI didn't include audio. |
I have tried hooking up the red white every which way possible, then went back and tried all options again with no luck. Either they aren't always live or the red white on the tv don't work.
The thing that gets me is that when I have the red white and hdmi just hooked up and going into the cable box accordingly and I change the source to hdmi I get sound for about a second then it goes silent. Every time I change to another source and then back to hdmi it does the same thing.
The thing that gets me is that when I have the red white and hdmi just hooked up and going into the cable box accordingly and I change the source to hdmi I get sound for about a second then it goes silent. Every time I change to another source and then back to hdmi it does the same thing.
I just read the manual.
Apparently only HDMI audio 1 works with the red/white analog inputs near it (page 27)
HDMI 2 is out of luck cause it is explained nowhere.
Your Directv box SHOULD have the red-white hot at the same time as the HDMI(I have 3 HD DVR's and 1 regular HD box...and they all have ALL outputs hot ALL the time). If not, call Directv for a new box.
The other problem could be in internal problem of the TV. Try connecting something else to the Directv box for sound directly off the box...if that works, but not on the TV(per page 27), then your TV has problem.
Your other solution is to completely ignore the HDMI. There is ABSOLUTELY NO DIFFERENCE in running Component Video to this TV over HDMI...ABSOLUTELY NO DIFFERENCE.
Edit:
On page 85, they did a typo on the
Intput Terminals
Video Input (rear Side)
Input 3 and 4
They should match. They typo'd those.
Or, here is another option(cause this is so inexpensive...)
http://www.amazon.com/Onkyo-HTX-22HD...3820699&sr=1-1
Edit 2:
This is the first TV I've ever run across where the HDMI didn't include the audio.
Edit 3:
I am starting to think the TV is having a problem, but I might have a solution. The Headphone jack(page 28) may have dust in it, if you have a can of compressed air(like for a computer), spray it out. Re-reading page 27 leads me to believe the TV has an internal switch for that ONE SET of RCA to switch between the three video input, so you can only hook up one of three things for the audio. This is a very poor design.
Edit 4:
Just to let you know. You are probably doing NOTHING wrong. Based on re-reading page 27, how you design one set of RCA audio inputs to cover 3 video inputs, 2 HDMI and VGA, is beyond me.
Apparently only HDMI audio 1 works with the red/white analog inputs near it (page 27)
HDMI 2 is out of luck cause it is explained nowhere.
Your Directv box SHOULD have the red-white hot at the same time as the HDMI(I have 3 HD DVR's and 1 regular HD box...and they all have ALL outputs hot ALL the time). If not, call Directv for a new box.
The other problem could be in internal problem of the TV. Try connecting something else to the Directv box for sound directly off the box...if that works, but not on the TV(per page 27), then your TV has problem.
Your other solution is to completely ignore the HDMI. There is ABSOLUTELY NO DIFFERENCE in running Component Video to this TV over HDMI...ABSOLUTELY NO DIFFERENCE.
Edit:
On page 85, they did a typo on the
Intput Terminals
Video Input (rear Side)
Input 3 and 4
They should match. They typo'd those.
Or, here is another option(cause this is so inexpensive...)
http://www.amazon.com/Onkyo-HTX-22HD...3820699&sr=1-1
Edit 2:
This is the first TV I've ever run across where the HDMI didn't include the audio.
Edit 3:
I am starting to think the TV is having a problem, but I might have a solution. The Headphone jack(page 28) may have dust in it, if you have a can of compressed air(like for a computer), spray it out. Re-reading page 27 leads me to believe the TV has an internal switch for that ONE SET of RCA to switch between the three video input, so you can only hook up one of three things for the audio. This is a very poor design.
Edit 4:
Just to let you know. You are probably doing NOTHING wrong. Based on re-reading page 27, how you design one set of RCA audio inputs to cover 3 video inputs, 2 HDMI and VGA, is beyond me.
This might be a case where a Home Theater in a Box might be a good solution. Usually consists of a relatively lowend A/V receiver and a set of 5 speakers.
Where did that long post go? I wanted to re-read it this morning.
I can confirm that all the direct tv receiver ports are always hot. However When I plug into the red white for the hdmi sound no audio works either.
I also compared the component video quality to the hdmi video quality using SciHD as a reference and the component actually looked better, a little better color and more crisp....now how does that make sense?
I also compared the component video quality to the hdmi video quality using SciHD as a reference and the component actually looked better, a little better color and more crisp....now how does that make sense?
You may have to configure the HDTV in the menu to 'look' at the analog audio inputs, or the HDMI port you are using may require a specific set of red/white analog inputs to be used.
Another possibility is the HDTV simply is broken, with zero audio output from any source.
Because technically HDMI video quality and component video quality for 1080i and 720p are the same.
Further, how the DirecTV HD box and the HDTV are designed and manufactured may affect HDMI and component video quality.
Quote:
Originally Posted by kyleax1 /forum/post/20845749
I can confirm that all the direct tv receiver ports are always hot. However When I plug into the red white for the hdmi sound no audio works either.
You may have to configure the HDTV in the menu to 'look' at the analog audio inputs, or the HDMI port you are using may require a specific set of red/white analog inputs to be used.
Another possibility is the HDTV simply is broken, with zero audio output from any source.
Quote:
I also compared the component video quality to the hdmi video quality using SciHD as a reference and the component actually looked better, a little better color and more crisp....now how does that make sense?
Because technically HDMI video quality and component video quality for 1080i and 720p are the same.
Further, how the DirecTV HD box and the HDTV are designed and manufactured may affect HDMI and component video quality.
So is the assumption now that ever if I got a convertor that it should not make a difference because if the audio was working it would have worked at some point during all these testing attempts?
Right.
All the converter does is take digital audio and makes it analog. If the HDTV won't do analog from the DVD player or the DirecTV box now, it won't do it from the converter.
Quote:
Originally Posted by kyleax1 /forum/post/20846246
So is the assumption now that ever if I got a convertor that it should not make a difference because if the audio was working it would have worked at some point during all these testing attempts?
Right.
All the converter does is take digital audio and makes it analog. If the HDTV won't do analog from the DVD player or the DirecTV box now, it won't do it from the converter.
Ok, I looked at the manual. At the beginning it specifically references HDMI carrying both audio and video on a single cable, so I don't think the analog inputs are the only option for audio input. This is in spite of the picture on page 27 showing the use of HDMI for video and analog l/r stereo for audio. I may be wrong about this, but the only way to know is to try it.
It's possible the set can only accept Dolby Digital audio on the HDMI input, and the DirecTV HD box is set for PCM (CD type) audio. Can you verify the DirecTV HD box digital audio output?
Since you've already seen that component video looks better, you might as well use component video and analog l/r audio for both the DVD player and DirecTV HD box, and be done with it.
It's possible the set can only accept Dolby Digital audio on the HDMI input, and the DirecTV HD box is set for PCM (CD type) audio. Can you verify the DirecTV HD box digital audio output?
Since you've already seen that component video looks better, you might as well use component video and analog l/r audio for both the DVD player and DirecTV HD box, and be done with it.
The OP stated early on that his DirecTV box HAD NO analog output. His only R/W audio out of his DirecTV box was part of the component output, and not live all the time(?). Being there sure would make this easier.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ken H /forum/post/20846389
Right.
All the converter does is take digital audio and makes it analog. If the HDTV won't do analog from the DVD player or the DirecTV box now, it won't do it from the converter.
The OP stated early on that his DirecTV box HAD NO analog output. His only R/W audio out of his DirecTV box was part of the component output, and not live all the time(?). Being there sure would make this easier.
All DirecTV boxes have analog audio out, and all the outputs are active all the time.
Indeed.
Quote:
Originally Posted by domino92024 /forum/post/20848226
The OP stated early on that his DirecTV box HAD NO analog output.
All DirecTV boxes have analog audio out, and all the outputs are active all the time.
Quote:
Originally Posted by domino92024 /forum/post/20848226
Being there sure would make this easier.
Indeed.
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
- This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
AVS Forum
A forum community dedicated to home theater owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about home audio/video, TVs, projectors, screens, receivers, speakers, projects, DIY’s, product reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!
Full Forum Listing
Top Contributors this Month
View All
WilliamR
872 Replies
BASSAHOLIC
487 Replies
mrtickleuk
402 Replies
Recommended Communities
