AVS Forum banner

1 - 12 of 12 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
50 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I'm in the market for a 47-50" (max, I cannot fit anything larger) HDTV and I get free shipping and up to 25% off Panasonic TVs because of work.


My current set is a 37" Toshiba CCFL LCD, and I am fine with it, it doesn't play nice with my PC's resolution and Yamaha A710. ()


Anyway, should I look into their plasma sets or should I try to get their edge-lit LED panels? I'd prefer backlit-LED, but I don't think they make any. If you had to buy a Panasonic set today that was 1080p and 47-50" what would you get?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
15,517 Posts
ST50 or GT50 Panny plasma.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
50 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
I can get the TC-P50ST50 for $999.99, and the TC-P50GT50 is $1349.99, both free shipping. What do?


Am I safe to assume:

Back-lit LED > plasma > edge-lit LED > CCFL LCD?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
15,517 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverSilent004  /t/1418744/how-should-i-use-my-panasonic-online-discount#post_22191119


I can get the TC-P50ST50 for $999.99, and the TC-P50GT50 is $1349.99, both free shipping. What do?

Am I safe to assume:

Back-lit LED > plasma > edge-lit LED > CCFL LCD?

ST50 vs GT50: Go look at them to see which you prefer. The main extra you get with the GT50 over the ST50 is THX mode. IMO, the ST50 is the better value.


No, it is not safe to assume your pecking order. Many here believe plasma provides the best PQ overall. Others prefer LED. Both technologies have their pros and cons, and which is better for you depends on your viewing room situation. Plasma is generally a better value/less expensive, better viewing angles, and better handling of motion. LEDs are brighter and so may be better in rooms with bright sunshine that you can't control. Personally, I would rank them plasma > back-lit LED > edge lit LED > LCD (unless you have bright sunshine directly on your display).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
50 Posts
Discussion Starter #5
Thanks!


With the THX mode on the GT50, I'm using a Yamaha A710 receiver, so the TV wouldn't process any audio. Looks like the ST50 is a winner..?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,387 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverSilent004  /t/1418744/how-should-i-use-my-panasonic-online-discount#post_22191261


Thanks!

With the THX mode on the GT50, I'm using a Yamaha A710 receiver, so the TV wouldn't process any audio. Looks like the ST50 is a winner..?

The THX mode (cinema/day) don't have anything to do with audio. It is just a THX certification standard. It really makes a difference in my opinion. It is pretty close to a calibrated set and it comes with these settings out of the box. But you can't go wrong with the ST or GT. Both are outstanding.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
858 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverSilent004  /t/1418744/how-should-i-use-my-panasonic-online-discount#post_22191119


I can get the TC-P50ST50 for $999.99, and the TC-P50GT50 is $1349.99, both free shipping. What do?

Am I safe to assume:

Back-lit LED > plasma > edge-lit LED > CCFL LCD?


From a personal perspective: Plasma > Back-lit LCD (CCFL OR LED) > Edge-lit LCD (CCFL OR LED)...


This should hold true within most Price/Size categories:

- the Sharp Elite is an LCD that many reviewers feel beats the majority of plasma sets for overall PQ - but also costs more than any other consumer plasma, to the best of my knowledge;

- one of the higher end Sony LCDs may well beat an El Cheapo Plasma panel - but, again, at a much higher price point;

- Personal Tastes and Specific Viewing Conditions / Usage might dictate one technology over the other.


If you like Cnet's reviews, their Top 5 2012 Panels - on the basis of OVERALL PQ (Price be Da***d) - are: Pan VT50; Sharp Elite; Pan ST50; Pan GT50; Samsung E6500 - and in that order. 4 plasma panels, and one expensive LCD.


Note that they have placed the ST50 above the GT50, even though the ST lacks THX.

Also note, however, that they rank the final 3 (ST, GT, and E6500) as being VERY CLOSE in overall PQ: features, price, and/or styling could easily sway the decision.


For my $$, would take the ST50 and "invest" the saved $349 elsewhere in my system, whether in other hardware, or expanding a movie (blu-ray) library.

But, of course, these are YOUR $$s......
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
50 Posts
Discussion Starter #8

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dierkdr  /t/1418744/how-should-i-use-my-panasonic-online-discount#post_22191496

Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverSilent004  /t/1418744/how-should-i-use-my-panasonic-online-discount#post_22191119


I can get the TC-P50ST50 for $999.99, and the TC-P50GT50 is $1349.99, both free shipping. What do?

Am I safe to assume:

Back-lit LED > plasma > edge-lit LED > CCFL LCD?

For my $$, would take the ST50 and "invest" the saved $349 elsewhere in my system, whether in other hardware, or expanding a movie (blu-ray) library.

But, of course, these are YOUR $$s......
I like that idea, I do need to get new speakers as well...



Thanks for your help everyone
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
50 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
When was the ST50 released? I ask because I may want to wait for the new version to come out.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
291 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by ForeverSilent004  /t/1418744/how-should-i-use-my-panasonic-online-discount#post_22191880


When was the ST50 released? I ask because I may want to wait for the new version to come out.

With that mentality, I would just wait until 2014. Maybe even 2015...just saying!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
73 Posts
As info, I saved $170 on my 55GT50 by NOT using my 25% employee discount with Panasonic but instead ordering the TV from Amazon. My advice is to not assume that you get the best deal from Panasonic, their prices before the 25% discount are HIGH and retailers like Amazon and Paulstv etc will often beat the discounted price.
 
1 - 12 of 12 Posts
Top