AVS Forum banner
1 - 20 of 26 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,492 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Like the topic suggests, I'm trying to learn how to record live TV, then encode it into a smaller file. For some reason, there aren't many guides on this at all. The only ones I found were from 2005-2008. Nothing recent at all.


I did find a couple people asking about it in 2012 but I'm guessing things have chance since last March 2012.


My goals are this:

Record live TV

Encode into 720p mkv file that isn't too large (1.2 gigs or less for 1hour shows).


What do I need to record live TV and encode it and what are you guys using to do this if you are.


Thanks!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,492 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
That doesn't remove the commercials though.


I'm just looking to see how people have theirs set up really because I've never had a cablecard or tuner before and it seems like there area LOT of obstacles when recording cable TV.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,538 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by tential  /t/1470418/how-to-record-tv-and-encode-it-into-smaller-file/0_40#post_23256499

That doesn't remove the commercials though.


I'm just looking to see how people have theirs set up really because I've never had a cablecard or tuner before and it seems like there area LOT of obstacles when recording cable TV.
That's true, but that's also not what you asked. Personally I think removing the commercials is a waste of time. That's what the 'skip 30 seconds' button is for. For that matter shrinking them is a waste of time to me too. There's not much on TV worth watching more than once or twice, IMHO.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,492 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Well that's your opinion. And there is no way I'd use skip 30 seconds. After watching TV shows without commercials, i'll NEVER go back. Just crazy to do so. I've rewatched a lot of shows as well.


I don't really see why the information isn't available in a simple guide. High quality 720p torrents of tv shows are available right after they are aired, not sure why there isn't a guide on how to reproduce the same content. You can record 4 TV shows at once with a Ceton card, so not sure how I can't find it but no google searches turn up what I'm looking for.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
180 Posts
MCE Buddy can do what you want: mcebuddy2x.codeplex.com


There's a guide somewhere on that site, but it's pretty straightforward to use. The show will need to be completely recorded before MCEBuddy can start (that's going to be true of any option to reencode a file.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,282 Posts
Yes mcebuddy. You just need to do a few test runs to see what encoding option you want to use. Another neat feature is you can set it up that once you delete the file off of your htpc Recordings folder it can also delete the file off the server where it was encoded.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
159 Posts
Yes MCB does a reasonable job but has a few flaws with the add removal software.


I did a guide on the freeware way of doing this a while ago as I used to do this myself if you do a bit of a search you should find it on the forum from memory it took about 3 to 4 steps to get the job done.


Now I use Video Redo TV Suite but you have to pay for it its not free but does an excellent job with windows 7 recordings. You can also re-encode with this as well but I then bulk process the edited files with Handbrake which I think is faster and easier to set the settings for.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
467 Posts
My only experience with mcebuddy wasn't an especially positive one. I couldn't find the right settings that would make it strip commercials from a .wtv file and leave it in the recorded TV folder. It always converted to mp4 or some other kind of file that caused playback errors.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,879 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by tential  /t/1470418/how-to-record-tv-and-encode-it-into-smaller-file#post_23256172


Like the topic suggests, I'm trying to learn how to record live TV, then encode it into a smaller file. For some reason, there aren't many guides on this at all. The only ones I found were from 2005-2008. Nothing recent at all.


I did find a couple people asking about it in 2012 but I'm guessing things have chance since last March 2012.


My goals are this:

Record live TV

Encode into 720p mkv file that isn't too large (1.2 gigs or less for 1hour shows).


What do I need to record live TV and encode it and what are you guys using to do this if you are.


Thanks!

What kind of TV? OTA or Cable?


Cable may or may not be encrypted, and may or may not be copyright protected.


Encrypted is OK, copyright protected you are SOL. There is nothing you can do with the file that has been copyright protected, you can move it to a different machine, but it will only play on the machine it was originally recorded on. You can't edit it, or remove commercials from it.


So, you end up with Terrabytes of storage, like us. 17 Tb!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,492 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by blueiedgod  /t/1470418/how-to-record-tv-and-encode-it-into-smaller-file#post_23262707


What kind of TV? OTA or Cable?


Cable may or may not be encrypted, and may or may not be copyright protected.


Encrypted is OK, copyright protected you are SOL. There is nothing you can do with the file that has been copyright protected, you can move it to a different machine, but it will only play on the machine it was originally recorded on. You can't edit it, or remove commercials from it.


So, you end up with Terrabytes of storage, like us. 17 Tb!

I'm actually trying to do EXACTLY what you have set up. I have Verizon FIOS, and I want to record and save as much TV as possible. I don't want Copyright protected material though. If I can't play it on another machine, it makes zero sense to have it to me. No reason to have huge WTV files of a television series that takes up 100 gigs for a season or something crazy. I'm simply trying to figure out how to record TV, compress it into something similar to what all the release groups do with torrents (it can be a little bigger than those files since I know I'm doing it myself and don't have the same setup). The problem is so much information is outdated so thats why I came here. Following a guide from 2008 is great and all, but a ton of technological advances have happened since 2008 and 2013. It's surprising to not find a recent guide on ripping TV to small but high quality files.


I have no intention of throwing out my other boxes (Well it's my family), but I do want to make the tv watching experience better for everyone so that's why I'm trying to figure this out. My mom has no clue how to DVR a show and then pull it up. I'm hoping if I can set this up to automatically record all of our favorite shows and import them into XBMC, that she and the rest of the family, won't have to worry about understanding DVR or ondemand. EVerything will just be there.


I'm currently only at 6TB of space. 4TB drives though are under 150. I plan on picking up more of them as I need more space.


I really want to understand how to make high quality encodes though similar to ones people download off the internet. I don't see a reason anymore of downloading TV when I could save the bandwidth and just get a Ceton Quad Tuner for 200 dollars. I'd rather use my bandwidth to play games and for other things haha.
Quote:
Originally Posted by dazzo17  /t/1470418/how-to-record-tv-and-encode-it-into-smaller-file#post_23261402


Yes MCB does a reasonable job but has a few flaws with the add removal software.


I did a guide on the freeware way of doing this a while ago as I used to do this myself if you do a bit of a search you should find it on the forum from memory it took about 3 to 4 steps to get the job done.


Now I use Video Redo TV Suite but you have to pay for it its not free but does an excellent job with windows 7 recordings. You can also re-encode with this as well but I then bulk process the edited files with Handbrake which I think is faster and easier to set the settings for.

I don't mind paying an upfront fee if I have to. Besides, if I really don't want to pay for software there is a way around it. I'll take a look into it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
912 Posts
I believe the reason you don't see too many guides is because what you suggest is not the most efficient way to do it and not many people do it anymore.


Bit torrent releases are fast because they either record straight to h264 format on the fly (using real time encoding devices) or they capture already encoded h264 streams (Dish network uses h264 to encode their HD feeds so it arrives to your STB already to go). Either way re-encoding is not necessary, just some basic editing and packaging in .mkv (takes about 10-15 minutes after the show is done airing).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,538 Posts

Quote:
I really want to understand how to make high quality encodes though similar to ones people download off the internet. I don't see a reason anymore of downloading TV when I could save the bandwidth and just get a Ceton Quad Tuner for 200 dollars. I'd rather use my bandwidth to play games and for other things haha.
It takes practice. And lots of reading. Start here: https://trac.handbrake.fr/
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
159 Posts
If you want the freeware option use MC TV converter its freeware and converts the WTV files to something that MPEG Streamclip can use (to cut adds) also freeware then Handbrake. Its all possible with freeware just takes more time and the learning process is longer.


From Memory I think I used MC TV converter and converted the files to transport stream, The problem is the WTV files there is no freeware program I am aware of that can just edit the adds which is why I switched to Video Redo.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,879 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by tential  /t/1470418/how-to-record-tv-and-encode-it-into-smaller-file#post_23263445


I'm actually trying to do EXACTLY what you have set up. I have Verizon FIOS, and I want to record and save as much TV as possible. I don't want Copyright protected material though. If I can't play it on another machine, it makes zero sense to have it to me. No reason to have huge WTV files of a television series that takes up 100 gigs for a season or something crazy. I'm simply trying to figure out how to record TV, compress it into something similar to what all the release groups do with torrents (it can be a little bigger than those files since I know I'm doing it myself and don't have the same setup). The problem is so much information is outdated so thats why I came here. Following a guide from 2008 is great and all, but a ton of technological advances have happened since 2008 and 2013. It's surprising to not find a recent guide on ripping TV to small but high quality files.


I have no intention of throwing out my other boxes (Well it's my family), but I do want to make the tv watching experience better for everyone so that's why I'm trying to figure this out. My mom has no clue how to DVR a show and then pull it up. I'm hoping if I can set this up to automatically record all of our favorite shows and import them into XBMC, that she and the rest of the family, won't have to worry about understanding DVR or ondemand. EVerything will just be there.


I'm currently only at 6TB of space. 4TB drives though are under 150. I plan on picking up more of them as I need more space.


I really want to understand how to make high quality encodes though similar to ones people download off the internet. I don't see a reason anymore of downloading TV when I could save the bandwidth and just get a Ceton Quad Tuner for 200 dollars. I'd rather use my bandwidth to play games and for other things haha.

I don't mind paying an upfront fee if I have to. Besides, if I really don't want to pay for software there is a way around it. I'll take a look into it.

Well, copyright protection is not up to you, me, or the provider, it is mostly the content owner that sets the protection. Whether the re-broadcaster, like Verizon follows it or not is somewhat gray area. Verizon has not been flagging anything, but I got a letter saying that they will start to enforce copyright protection rules.


If your mother or your family can use XBMC, they will most definitely be able to use WMC, without the added layer of having to convert anything. You just have to get extenders (cheap compared to the cost of HTPC), and not additional PC's to play content on multiple TV's in the house.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,044 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by blueiedgod  /t/1470418/how-to-record-tv-and-encode-it-into-smaller-file#post_23270946


Well, copyright protection is not up to you, me, or the provider, it is mostly the content owner that sets the protection. Whether the re-broadcaster, like Verizon follows it or not is somewhat gray area. Verizon has not been flagging anything, but I got a letter saying that they will start to enforce copyright protection rules.


If your mother or your family can use XBMC, they will most definitely be able to use WMC, without the added layer of having to convert anything. You just have to get extenders (cheap compared to the cost of HTPC), and not additional PC's to play content on multiple TV's in the house.
Verizon does flag the premium channels, but nothing else. With that being the case you can use individual PCs at each TV instead of extenders. It's more expensive but it gives you the most flexibility. You can play any show recorded on another PC on any other PC since there's no copy once flag involved. You can add the RecordedTV folder from another PC to the one on a different PC so all recordings show up in a single folder, regardless of which PC it was recorded on. The one area that extenders provide an advantage is the ability to access the scheduled recording list and modify it remotely. You can't do that with individual PCs. If you're like me and have a media server you can play any type of files you want on any PC. Extenders are extremely limited in what they can play other than recorded TV shows. I have XBMC on all of my PCs and use it to play DVDs and Blu-Rays ripped to mkv files using MakeMKV. I've used just about every kind of extender ever produced and they all pretty much suck, IMHO. The UI is extremely laggy and sometimes doesn't respond quickly enough to remote commands. You don't have that problem with standalone PCs. A mini-iTX PC or the new Intel NUC would make a nice remote PC.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
467 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by captain_video  /t/1470418/how-to-record-tv-and-encode-it-into-smaller-file#post_23276277


The one area that extenders provide an advantage is the ability to access the scheduled recording list and modify it remotely. You can't do that with individual PCs.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought Ceton's "my media center" app did that ( http://cetoncorp.com/products/companion/ )? I believe it works in a network tuner configuration as well.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,555 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by dazzo17  /t/1470418/how-to-record-tv-and-encode-it-into-smaller-file#post_23261402


Yes MCB does a reasonable job but has a few flaws with the add removal software.


I did a guide on the freeware way of doing this a while ago as I used to do this myself if you do a bit of a search you should find it on the forum from memory it took about 3 to 4 steps to get the job done.


Now I use Video Redo TV Suite but you have to pay for it its not free but does an excellent job with windows 7 recordings. You can also re-encode with this as well but I then bulk process the edited files with Handbrake which I think is faster and easier to set the settings for.

Hey, dazzo17, which version of Video Redo TV Suite do you use? The $75 one or the H.264 version?

I'm asking because as far as I can see, the cheaper one can't import WTV files directly (according to the feature comparison list). So you still have to convert the recording to DVR-MS or TS files b4 editing. If that's the case, I don't see the point of buying it as opposed to using Streamclip (free). Does it have a better interface, or is it somehow easier or faster? I can see getting the $99 version if you also edit H.264.


Also, what is your workflow? Convert to TS, edit, then encode with Handbreak?
 
1 - 20 of 26 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top