AVS Forum banner

How to set up a media server???

862 Views 17 Replies 7 Participants Last post by  jagouar
Ive been searching and reading and searching and reading and cant seem to make sense of anything. I want to build an HTPC, using an X11, but use the htpc as a media server for movies and music. But how does it all fit together?


How can I do this for say 4-8 Hard drives, when my motherboard ( DFI nf3 lanparty) doesnt have that many inputs for hard drives and the case doesnt have that many 5.25 slots??


And if I need an external case for all the hard drives ( which im assuming I do), how do i cool that, connect that to the HTPC, etc etc??


Sorry, I have no idea how to set this up, for about 1.5TB and expandable potential. Can anyone help a media server newb or at least direct me towards some good reading material where i can figure it all out?


Thanks alot guys


Ashok
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
First you have to ask yourself a question. Not to be a smart a?? but why would you get a case that can't handle the hard drives that you want to put in it? You can always use Controller cards to add more drives to your machine. Look up Controller cards and you will see what I mean. Before you try to do the 1.5tb setup and media server, spend more time getting grounded in the why and how. Because honestly, if you do not understand that, you will have a very frustrating user experience. Many people here have cut their teeth on small systems and gradually advanced from 1 hard drives, to USB drives, to JBOD, Raid1, Raid5 and on. But you must understand the why.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ashokn225
Ive been searching and reading and searching and reading and cant seem to make sense of anything. I want to build an HTPC, using an X11, but use the htpc as a media server for movies and music. But how does it all fit together?
Short answer, you get a box (be it PC or specialized) stick HDDs in it, and share the storage to your other computers. Really that's it.

Quote:
How can I do this for say 4-8 Hard drives, when my motherboard ( DFI nf3 lanparty) doesnt have that many inputs for hard drives and the case doesnt have that many 5.25 slots??
On the case part, well, you simply get a case that will fit the drives, additionally, you can pick up the "3 in 2" HDD cage/drive coolers to fit a few more in. But there's really no getting around the need to just buy a case with enough bays.


As for motherboard, you're going to have to get additional HDD controllers (PCI/PCI-X/PCIe) for the extra drives. Be it a nice RAID controller or just simple HDD controllers. The Coolermaster Stacker is a popular media server case.


Quote:
And if I need an external case for all the hard drives ( which im assuming I do), how do i cool that, connect that to the HTPC, etc etc??
You can get external HDD enclosures, ones with dedicated PSUs that connect to the PC various ways (USB, Firewire, SATA), Norco makes some, MacGurus carries some also.

Quote:
Sorry, I have no idea how to set this up, for about 1.5TB and expandable potential. Can anyone help a media server newb or at least direct me towards some good reading material where i can figure it all out?
Based on the questions you're asking (no offense), and where it seems like you are, I would seriously consider an Infrant ReadyNAS NV . In addition to my PC media server (1.75TB RAID-5) I have a ReadyNAS X6 (predicessor to the NV) and it's great. It will take up to 4 drives, you can add them as you go and it will expand on the fly. It provides redundancy, and it's completly self-contained.


Grab an NV and a 750GB HDD, and you'll be on your way to a 2TB array. Just note that as of today, Infrant hasn't released firmware supporting the 750s. yoh-dah (Infrant rep) says they're hoping for a beta firmware supporting the 750's in the next week.
See less See more
Just FYI...Cooler Master also makes a "4 in 3" drive bay. It allows you to fit 4 3.5" hard drives in 3 5.25" drive bays, if you have that many available.
I got my Antec Sonata II exactly b/c it can hold 11 drives.


I don't got a PS that can power 11 drives, but that's by choice.
Quote:
Originally Posted by stanger89
Short answer, you get a box (be it PC or specialized) stick HDDs in it, and share the storage to your other computers. Really that's it.
Well actually, this isnt a media server per say, because only my computer will be using it, so its more just a way to have huge storage capability

Quote:
Originally Posted by stranger89
On the case part, well, you simply get a case that will fit the drives, additionally, you can pick up the "3 in 2" HDD cage/drive coolers to fit a few more in........



Based on the questions you're asking (no offense), and where it seems like you are, I would seriously consider an Infrant ReadyNAS NV. In addition to my PC media server (1.75TB RAID-5) I have a ReadyNAS X6 (predicessor to the NV) and it's great. It will take up to 4 drives, you can add them as you go and it will expand on the fly. It provides redundancy, and it's completly self-contained.


Well ive been reading a bit more and trying to figure this all out. And ive found the SuperMicro 5 in 3 hard drive enclosure which would allow me for 5 HDDs in the box. So that plus a hdd controller would come to about 220 shipped vs the NV which is about 600, but then again the NV alllows for basically unlimited on the go storage potential.


So if i get the supermicro enclosure and a sata 4X pci controller, would I be able to hook up 5 drives? Im thinking a 37gb 10k-rpm for my OS plus 4 500gb drives. And also, stranger, u mentioned that the NV doesnt have the firmware for 750 GB drives. Does that mean ( sorry another stupid question probably) that motherboards have a maximum storage capacity? In other words, would i be able to use the supermicro and the 5 drives seamlessly? Also, what other concerns such as heat or PS should i be concerned about and how would i be able to take care of those issues?

Quote:
Originally Posted by stranger
Based on the questions you're asking (no offense)
And no man, i dont take any offense. I really appreciate the help, and i can admit i know nothing about this stuff, so its all good haha. Its annoying when people in a position of knowledge are unwilling to help newcomers to a specific topic. I hate it when people get pissed at newcomers who dont know as much as they do. Doesnt make sense to me---defeats the purpose of a forum. I need help in media storage, you help me out. You need help buying a vintage car, I could help you out haha.


Anyways, back to the computer. And yeah, i defintely want the X 11, even if it means getting an external HD enclosure that hooks up via USB or something because the setup will require an IR/VFD, DVD player etc etc. Its going to be the corner piece of my home theater system and I dont want it looking like a server.
See less See more
Quote:
Originally Posted by ashokn225
Well ive been reading a bit more and trying to figure this all out. And ive found the SuperMicro 5 in 3 hard drive enclosure which would allow me for 5 HDDs in the box. So that plus a hdd controller would come to about 220 shipped vs the NV which is about 600, but then again the NV alllows for basically unlimited on the go storage potential.
Between a good RAID card (to match the ReadyNAS capabilities) plus an enclosure and you'll be much closer to the NV price than $220 probably.

Quote:
So if i get the supermicro enclosure and a sata 4X pci controller, would I be able to hook up 5 drives?
Should be able to.

Quote:
Im thinking a 37gb 10k-rpm for my OS plus 4 500gb drives. And also, stranger, u mentioned that the NV doesnt have the firmware for 750 GB drives. Does that mean ( sorry another stupid question probably) that motherboards have a maximum storage capacity? In other words, would i be able to use the supermicro and the 5 drives seamlessly?
It will probably depend on how big the discs are, but you should be able to. I'm not really sure what the "problem" is with the 750's on the ReadyNAS, but it has it's own custom OS so that's probably part of it, it may be that Infrant just hasn't officially qualled the 750's yet. Just doublecheck that there are no limitations on the controller you choose (there really shouldn't be).

Quote:
Also, what other concerns such as heat or PS should i be concerned about and how would i be able to take care of those issues?
For 4 drives, I wouldn't worry much about PSU, any quality PSU should be able to handle that much. I didn't start running into problems until I hit 8-10 drives.

Quote:
Anyways, back to the computer. And yeah, i defintely want the X 11, even if it means getting an external HD enclosure that hooks up via USB or something because the setup will require an IR/VFD, DVD player etc etc. Its going to be the corner piece of my home theater system and I dont want it looking like a server.
So it sounds like you're building an HTPC, and want some mass storage for that.


If I could give some advice from my "journey":


Storage should be kept as cool as possible/practical. Heat is what destroys HDDs, more than anything else. That means fans, moving a good bit of air.


HDDs are loud, I don't care what anyone says, if you take care to choose quiet component, you'll end up with the HDD being obnoxious, especially if you have more than one.


This all comes to one conclusion, storage is noisy, the more storage, the more noise, and it's really hard to quiet it without sacrificing something (money or durability).


My advice to you, would be to get a laptop HDD for the boot/OS drive in the HTPC, speed is not very important, but noise is IMO, and laptop drives are the only way to get quiet storage (other than solid state).


For the mass storage, put it in another room where you can keep it nice and cool, and not worry about how loud it is. If I were aiming for 1-2TB of storage, I'd definitely go with a ReadyNAS NV. Drop a 500 or 750GB drive in to start, and add more as you need room.
See less See more
Quote:
Originally Posted by stanger89
Between a good RAID card (to match the ReadyNAS capabilities) plus an enclosure and you'll be much closer to the NV price than $220 probably.
What is RAID exactly and what does it do ( advantages)? And would i just set that up in my bios?


Quote:
Originally Posted by stranger89
So it sounds like you're building an HTPC, and want some mass storage for that.


If I could give some advice from my "journey":


Storage should be kept as cool as possible/practical. Heat is what destroys HDDs, more than anything else. That means fans, moving a good bit of air.


HDDs are loud, I don't care what anyone says, if you take care to choose quiet component, you'll end up with the HDD being obnoxious, especially if you have more than one.


This all comes to one conclusion, storage is noisy, the more storage, the more noise, and it's really hard to quiet it without sacrificing something (money or durability).


My advice to you, would be to get a laptop HDD for the boot/OS drive in the HTPC, speed is not very important, but noise is IMO, and laptop drives are the only way to get quiet storage (other than solid state).


For the mass storage, put it in another room where you can keep it nice and cool, and not worry about how loud it is. If I were aiming for 1-2TB of storage, I'd definitely go with a ReadyNAS NV. Drop a 500 or 750GB drive in to start, and add more as you need room.
Yes, i was concerned about the heat, and dont want a ton of fans running in the background of my music and movies. As far as the laptop HD, is that just an IDE HD? And also, ive wondered what the speed of a hard drive actually has to do with the hard drive in itself. When you access files, isnt it the speed of the processor that allows faster accessibility? Or is it the speed of the hard drive? The only reason i chose the 10k rpm HD was because i read somewhere that it allows for almost instant boot ups and faster access to media files.


Ok, well if im going with the NV, i have to stretch my budget which I dont like because it means Im going to have to cut corners somewhere else in my whole setup ( im about to dive into a major HT/HTPC setup). But if its the most cost effective/reliable option WITHOUT having to buy a server case, then I might just do it. So with the NV, how does it operate ( you said it has its own OS). Would i just stick in all the HD's and then usb it to my htpc? And if its in another room, how would i do that? Also, it would be hard for me to put it away from the whole setup. I'd have to set it up in the closet or something. ( I have a single room at school and cant put it in the hallway even though that would be really funny :D ).


Again, thanks for the help stranger. I love learning about this stuff--feels so much better to know I can put one of these together ( as simple as it may be) then to go out and buy an overpriced media storage center.


Ashok
See less See more
A crazy thought just entered my head!!! What if i just bought a server case, had the whole shebang put into there, forget the X11, have one cabinet of my tv's stand basically treated for noise and heat and have a slot loading DVD drive machined into some part of the stand!!!!! So all you see is the slot for the drive, my a/v reciever, and my 360!!! That would be sick!


.....now the real question....doable? lol...With the money I save from not buying the X11+not buying the NV, I could probably pay a professional to "install" it in my coffee table and not even the stand. ::dreams of slot loading dvd drives in coffee tables::
Quote:
Originally Posted by ashokn225
What is RAID exactly and what does it do ( advantages)? And would i just set that up in my bios?
RAID is (something to the effect of): Redundant Array of Independent (or Inexpensive) Disks.


In a nutshell, depending on "level" it provides redundancy so that if a disc in the array fails, no data is lost (RAID-0 is an exception that provide no Redundancy).


RAID-5 is the most common/popular RAID level for media servers, it provides the highest efficienty, using only one drive's worth of space for redundancy.

Quote:
Yes, i was concerned about the heat, and dont want a ton of fans running in the background of my music and movies. As far as the laptop HD, is that just an IDE HD?
Yes, but you'll need to get an adapter because laptop drives use a different connector.

Quote:
And also, ive wondered what the speed of a hard drive actually has to do with the hard drive in itself. When you access files, isnt it the speed of the processor that allows faster accessibility? Or is it the speed of the hard drive?
No, the speed of the HDD is, by far, the biggest bottleneck in a PC these days (depending on application). CPUs can process data much faster than a HDD can read/write. Of course notice the big "depending on application" qualifier there.

Quote:
The only reason i chose the 10k rpm HD was because i read somewhere that it allows for almost instant boot ups and faster access to media files.
There are probably two big factors in HDD speed:

Density (how much data/size, usually related to total size but not always).

RPM.


Basically the higher the density the faster.

The Higher the RPM the faster.


Higher RPMs reduce "access time" (aka "latency") meaning if you're reading/writing lots of different little files (random access), latency is the biggest bottleneck. Server environments are where this comes into play bigtime.


However on media PCs, you don't do a lot of "random access", most access on media PCs is more "sequential", thus access time is a minimal bottleneck.


All in all, you may notice a minor difference in performance with a laptop vs 10k drive, but IMO, for an HTPC it's not worth the noise/heat tradeoff. You don't boot often. Nor will the OS disk speed help you if the media files are on a different disk.

Quote:
Ok, well if im going with the NV, i have to stretch my budget which I dont like because it means Im going to have to cut corners somewhere else in my whole setup ( im about to dive into a major HT/HTPC setup). But if its the most cost effective/reliable option WITHOUT having to buy a server case, then I might just do it.
FWIW, if you look around, you can find other NAS solutions (Buffalo Terrastation, etc) that may be cheaper.

Quote:
So with the NV, how does it operate ( you said it has its own OS). Would i just stick in all the HD's and then usb it to my htpc? And if its in another room, how would i do that?
The NV is a NAS ("Network Attached Storage") you just plug it into your network, and it sits out there, all by itself, providing storage. It's got a nice web interface for what (little) management you have to do (basically just initial setup).

Quote:
A crazy thought just entered my head!!! What if i just bought a server case, had the whole shebang put into there, forget the X11, have one cabinet of my tv's stand basically treated for noise and heat and have a slot loading DVD drive machined into some part of the stand!!!!! So all you see is the slot for the drive, my a/v reciever, and my 360!!! That would be sick!


.....now the real question....doable?
Probably, though I wouldn't ;) No real particular reason why, though.


The one other option you've got, which is really a pretty new one, is to just drop a 750GB drive or two in the case. I had 4 drives in my HTPC for a while, while I was in school. And it worked. And with 750GB drives it's actually practical to have a video library on a drive or two these days.


Then down the road, if you wanted, you could get a NAS (like the NV) drop a 750 or two in there, and then copy the data from the drives in your HTPC and migrate the drives into the NAS. I'd still consider the laptop drive for boot though.


This is actually probably the best way for you to go for now, IMO.
See less See more
Wow, thanks for all the info man. I think what im going to do is go for the coolermaster stacker with a pair of 500GB's to start along with a 160 GB internal that i have lying around ( which i could use for the OS/programs/etc) and an external 160 gb I use with my laptop right now. Thatll give me like 1.3 TB to start which is enough for me now , and Ill go from there. And ill just shove it all in a drawer in my tv stand and put soundproof panels on the inside along with the back open for ventilation. And then just buy an external dvd-rw, the LaCie in particular since it matches my external Lacie 160 gig hd. Should be a cool setup i think, and work pretty effectively. And then if ( when) i move out of the house ( frat house that i live in) and get my own apartment, ill get the NV for easier access and reliability. Once i get all of it setup ( should be within the next two weeks), ill post pics and first impressions.


Thanks again for all the help stranger


Ashok
Quote:
Thanks again for all the help stranger
At 6800 posts in 3.5 years, he's certainly no stranger.


But, he is a 'stang-er though. See his SageTV forums avatar if you want to know the double-secret meaning there. (speaking of which, as an AVS club member you could put that same avatar here too...)
since you have a 360 already (assuming you do as i saw 360 referenced earlier) you dont need to have anything at your tv.... here is what my setup consists of:


I have a massive server case in my wiring closet (where the router and cable modem is) and just put a ton of HD's in there (when vista comes out im planning on raiding them all for ~1.2 tb) but if you install media center edition you can use your 360 as a "extender" to your media center (and it will be more or less silent compared to running a computer at your tv)


But my 360 is able to stream live tv, recorded tv (recorded to the media center), music, hdtv clips, etc.


But this requires you to have media center edition (if you dont aready) but then you can just find the biggest server case you can find and put in tons of HD's and stick it in some closet and run an ethernet wire to said closet and you are ready to go. I dont even have a monitor or keyboard on my server anymore as you can do pretty much any maintnence over remote desktop.

http://features.teamxbox.com/xbox/13...etup-Guide/p1/
See less See more
Yes, I do have an xbox 360, but I still need my server/htpc case nearby as I am using it for the dvd playback too, which doesnt even compare to 360's dvd playback. Also, I dont have a closet that I could just stick it all in. In the house, we have a closet that has all the network and cable stuff racked in, but theres no room for me to put my server in. Plus the fact that I can just access the computer right there in my room whenever I need to is good, in case something goes wrong.


But yes, Ive thought about using the 360 as an extender. Its a great option for those that have MCE, no need for ffdshow......and a closet LOL.


Haha, thanks though for the help man


Ashok
For what this comment's worth, the XBOX360 is by no means a quiet machine. Especially when it is playing an HD feed from a MCE box or gaming at HD resolutions. It gets louder than any MCE machine I have ever built.


Jim
Quote:
Originally Posted by jimbighoss
For what this comment's worth, the XBOX360 is by no means a quiet machine. Especially when it is playing an HD feed from a MCE box or gaming at HD resolutions. It gets louder than any MCE machine I have ever built.


Jim
mine only gets loud when playing games... its pretty quiet other than actual gaming. (and i stream hd to it)
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top