L&R ceiling help!
-
Now Available: Tech Talk Podcast with Scott Wilkinson, Episode 19 Click here for details.
1 - 20 of 22 Posts
Joined
·
15,712 Posts
First, let me apologize if this post comes across as overly blunt. I actually mean this in a most helpful way.
Having said that, it is ill-advised to spend the kind of $$$ you are talking about and then compromise the speaker positions so greatly. The front soundstage needs to be consistent and coherent. Music, dialogue, sounds that "pan" across the soundstage need to sound the same as they move from one speaker to another. If the speakers are different timbre, (and down-firing in-ceilings will, by their nature, be different timbre than a stand mounted, front-firing CC), those pans will *change* as they move across the soundstage. Add to that the height differential, and pans will totally lose their "lock-up" with the video image.
For example, if a car is moving left to right across the screen, the sound should move left to right across the soundstage. In your proposed system, the sound will move from top left to bottom center to top right. This will be a totally unnatural movement of the sound, incoherent with the on-screen image. More importantly, the timbre, (or pitch), of the sound will change appreciably as it moves from speaker to speaker.
I would encourage you to use an all-stand-mounted system for the front soundstage, if at all possible. This will result in a much more cohesive and coherent front soundstage. If that is not possible, for practical, aesthetic or WAF factors, then an all in-ceiling system would be better than your proposed system. Alternatively, an all in-wall system could work also, (actually this would be preferable to the "overhead" imaging of an in-ceiling system.)
If you decide that you absolutely must use architectural speakers, (in-walls or in-ceilings), I would encourage you to use self-enclosed speakers. To understand why this is important, please read this article:
http://www.cepro.com/article/how_to_...peaker_systems
There are many choices of self-enclosed architectural speakers in your price range. Def Tech, Polk, Klipsch, Snell, Traid and others all make self enclosed architectural speakers.
Bottom line, the front soundstage is the most important part of the HT audio experience. Whatever you decide to do, make the front soundstage as consistent, coherent and cohesive as possible.
Good luck.
Craig
First, let me apologize if this post comes across as overly blunt. I actually mean this in a most helpful way.
Having said that, it is ill-advised to spend the kind of $$$ you are talking about and then compromise the speaker positions so greatly. The front soundstage needs to be consistent and coherent. Music, dialogue, sounds that "pan" across the soundstage need to sound the same as they move from one speaker to another. If the speakers are different timbre, (and down-firing in-ceilings will, by their nature, be different timbre than a stand mounted, front-firing CC), those pans will *change* as they move across the soundstage. Add to that the height differential, and pans will totally lose their "lock-up" with the video image.
For example, if a car is moving left to right across the screen, the sound should move left to right across the soundstage. In your proposed system, the sound will move from top left to bottom center to top right. This will be a totally unnatural movement of the sound, incoherent with the on-screen image. More importantly, the timbre, (or pitch), of the sound will change appreciably as it moves from speaker to speaker.
I would encourage you to use an all-stand-mounted system for the front soundstage, if at all possible. This will result in a much more cohesive and coherent front soundstage. If that is not possible, for practical, aesthetic or WAF factors, then an all in-ceiling system would be better than your proposed system. Alternatively, an all in-wall system could work also, (actually this would be preferable to the "overhead" imaging of an in-ceiling system.)
If you decide that you absolutely must use architectural speakers, (in-walls or in-ceilings), I would encourage you to use self-enclosed speakers. To understand why this is important, please read this article:
http://www.cepro.com/article/how_to_...peaker_systems
There are many choices of self-enclosed architectural speakers in your price range. Def Tech, Polk, Klipsch, Snell, Traid and others all make self enclosed architectural speakers.
Bottom line, the front soundstage is the most important part of the HT audio experience. Whatever you decide to do, make the front soundstage as consistent, coherent and cohesive as possible.
Good luck.
Craig
What's on the other side of the hallway right of the TV (picture 1).
Picture 2 gives a good view to the left of the TV (and shows a mantle that could hold a bookshelf speaker; now if the other one could be on a stand on the other side of the hallway...)
Picture 2 gives a good view to the left of the TV (and shows a mantle that could hold a bookshelf speaker; now if the other one could be on a stand on the other side of the hallway...)
That space is quite a nightmare.. something similar to what I had to deal with in my living room. My left speaker is actually to the right of my TV
![]()
It sucks, but I really had no choice. Thankfully I have to other rooms in the house that have, or will have, 5.1 and 7.1 audio with superior setups.
Instead of thinking in-ceiling for L/R and a standard C (which will have the odd movement issues described above), think about in-ceiling for all three.
Because you will be sitting quite a bit away from the in-ceiling, get ones that provide angle, like:
- Paradigm AMS-150R-30
- KEF Ci300.3QT
Because you will be sitting quite a bit away from the in-ceiling, get ones that provide angle, like:
- Paradigm AMS-150R-30
- KEF Ci300.3QT
Yep, looks like it. That would certainly make the install a bit tougher, but not impossible (and maybe if you always want them down you don't need power).
The Paradigm site shows several lines and sizes that have that 30 degree offset, and their offset is hidden under the flush grills.
The Paradigm site shows several lines and sizes that have that 30 degree offset, and their offset is hidden under the flush grills.
Joined
·
15,712 Posts
Consider a Soundbar placed on top of the TV. LCR all in one cabinet.
http://www.pinnaclespeakers.com/quantumplasma7.html
http://www.pinnaclespeakers.com/quantumplasma9.html
http://www.miragespeakers.com/na-en/...in-1-overview/
Any of these would be a *much* better option than all in-ceilings or some combination of in-ceilings and a center speaker on a stand.
You could also build shelves above the TV for your components and put the speakers on the first shelf.
Craig
http://www.pinnaclespeakers.com/quantumplasma7.html
http://www.pinnaclespeakers.com/quantumplasma9.html
http://www.miragespeakers.com/na-en/...in-1-overview/
Any of these would be a *much* better option than all in-ceilings or some combination of in-ceilings and a center speaker on a stand.
You could also build shelves above the TV for your components and put the speakers on the first shelf.
Craig
Joined
·
95 Posts
Mount a flat panel over the fireplace. Place onwalls on either side, with center channel above.
Convert the nook into built-in bookshelves.
Lots of brands to choose from, but this is what I mean.
![]()
Convert the nook into built-in bookshelves.
Lots of brands to choose from, but this is what I mean.
Is it wise to try and squeeze LRC on a shelf with only 58 inches to work with?
Building a shelf above the TV is very doable.
But that TV is on its way out, its being replaced with a http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-LN55A9...1545321&sr=8-1 sitting on a stand http://www.amazon.com/BDI-Novia-8428...446&sr=1-3that will be 52 inches wide by 28 high.
Building a shelf above the TV is very doable.
But that TV is on its way out, its being replaced with a http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-LN55A9...1545321&sr=8-1 sitting on a stand http://www.amazon.com/BDI-Novia-8428...446&sr=1-3that will be 52 inches wide by 28 high.
How about LR in walls and center on TV stand? I have 10 inches on the right of the TV, between the media niche and hallway.
How about http://www.ehifi.com.au/b-w/CustomIn...n/cwmlcr7.aspx with a matching center?
How about http://www.ehifi.com.au/b-w/CustomIn...n/cwmlcr7.aspx with a matching center?
1 - 20 of 22 Posts
