AVS Forum banner

1 - 20 of 260 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,140 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
LG D2342P 23" Passive 3D LED LCD Monitor


I've got one on order at the MSRP $349. Due to arrive in a week+-.


Didn't see a thread for this one yet.


The user manual says for 3D HDMI it supports:

Frame packing 1080p 24Hz, 720p 50/60Hz

Side by Side and Top/Bottom 1080p 1080i 720p 50/60Hz

Top/Bottom 1080p 24Hz, 720p and 1080p 50/60Hz


Good entry level price to view 3D without expensive glasses.


I wonder what it will do when plugged into my Sony TD10 3D camcorder.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,836 Posts
Doesn't support horizontal interleave? I wonder why not?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,140 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by Frank /forum/post/20543932


Doesn't support horizontal interleave? I wonder why not?

Indeed - 1080i/60 3D is not listed as supportable by this monitor. This is the method used for recording by the Sony HDR-TD10.


However, the HDMI 3D output setting in the Sony HDR-TD10 menu provides Auto, Frame Pack, and also Side by Side. So I am thinking that at least the Side by Side HDMI 3D selection will work.


Since this monitor is vertically interleaved Left / Right, this might result in a double loss of resolution when used directly with the TD10 in 3D mode.


I'm thinking that software could frame pack the 60i to 24p for transport at 1080p24-3D, geting around the need for SBS mode.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
885 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by Richard Adams /forum/post/20543914


LG D2342P 23" Passive 3D LED LCD Monitor


I've got one on order at the MSRP $349. Due to arrive in a week+-.


Didn't see a thread for this one yet.


The user manual says for 3D HDMI it supports:

Frame packing 1080p 24Hz, 720p 50/60Hz

Side by Side and Top/Bottom 1080p 1080i 720p 50/60Hz

Top/Bottom 1080p 24Hz, 720p and 1080p 50/60Hz


Good entry level price to view 3D without expensive glasses.


I wonder what it will do when plugged into my Sony TD10 3D camcorder.

Why would it support 1080p/24 Top Bottom, but not 1080p/24 SBS, which is used by the satellite and cable companies?



Michael
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,140 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
My order for this monitor, placed several days ago, is listed today as "in stock, shipping soon," by the well known USA based retailer.


LG's web page has a monitor model number D2342P-PN, with the "N" added to the model number I had previously seen.


The manual I took the HDMI specs from comes from the following link, at page 20.

http://www.lg.com/us/support/product...lTab=documents


To use the above link, it can be clicked on or copied using "copy shortcut"


As of today, at this link there is the pdf manual and some other activex control that I did not choose to install yet.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,140 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by Michael2000 /forum/post/20545264


Why would it support 1080p/24 Top Bottom, but not 1080p/24 SBS, which is used by the satellite and cable companies?



Michael

It states at the following link near the end of the description,

"Interface is supported to connect 3D devices with LG's CINEMA 3D monitor. This makes it possible to view any 3D contents even without a PC. Direct connection is available with Game console, Blu-ray player, Set-top box"

http://www.lg.com/ae/it-products/3d-...ors-D2342P.jsp


At link above press the, "explore product features" button


It does say, "any 3D contents" and specifically lists "set top box"


Today I see this monitor now being advertised for sale at several national electronics retailers, though I haven't found any in stock yet.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,140 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by markr041 /forum/post/20549550


"Today I see this monitor now being advertised for sale at several national electronics retailers, though I haven't found any in stock yet."

http://www.amazon.com/LG-D2342P-23-I.../dp/B004WK3R4U

I meant that the national electronics retailers that show this monitor on their web page did not have one I could pick up immediately from their local store.


Today, Sunday, I got a UPS tracking number from the retailer I ordered from last Monday.


When it arrives, probably Wednesday or Thursday, the 3D sources I can connect and test with include PS3, PC, and Sony HDR-TD10.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,140 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
It arrived.


First impression - I like it. I adjusted the brightness lower, from default 100 down to 30.


As a computer monitor, the 1920 x 1080 native mode looks crisp for 2D, with 3D glasses off.


When connected to the Sony HDR-TD10 via HDMI, must set the TD10 to output SBS mode for 3D. Frame pack mode doesn't produce a correct image. Can view both playback and live camera through the monitor in 3D.


RealD 3D glasses from the theater work.


I have the monitor face tilt set so that with one tilt setting 3D looks correct when sitting at normal monitor distance of approx 3 feet or when standing about 9 feet away.


Lots more to try out...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,140 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by CaptainEvers /forum/post/20573402


I look forward to seeing how your experience with the PS3 and PC is.. Gaming Lag and 3D resolution specifically..

PC - The "Tridef 3d" software that comes with the monitor certainly shows off the 3D. Stills and videos in 3D provided on that CD disk look great, like Disneyworld 3D. This included player in the monitor pkg will not play my MVC 3D files from the TD10 in actual 3D like the monitor does when I directly connect it via HDMI to the TD10 camcorder playback.


I have an SBS mode 3D segment from the animated "Chicken Little" that I played in 3D using the freeware VLC player by selecting the 3D mode on the monitor. Looks good. 3D both pops out of the monitor and has depth. Images are bright.


A note about my intended reason to select this monitor is that aside from the fantastic viewfinder on the Sony TD10, I have no other display for 3D yet, and wanted to get something 3D going for my PC, especially to review home video from my Sony TD10, while I figure out which of the larger TV displays I'm going spring for it. This passive LG seems to be an economical stragihtforward all in one solution without dedicating to particular hardware. I have a list of 3D movies I missed at the theatre that I've delayed watching in 2D until I have a good 3D display going.


Got bogged down trying to use TMT5 for playing MVC files. The TMT5 trial did not work at all for my set up. Spent time uninstalling and updating drivers to no avail. When opening any file with TMT5 trial, after a few seconds, the TMT5 window turns black and the rotating progress bars freeze, but no video appears. When frozen, TMT5 terminates easily with task manager. Will be working on solving that. I want to get some sort of method to play MVC 3D hidef files working, and am disappointed that TMT5 freezes for me, with no useful error message displayed.


For the PS3, I heard there was a demo of the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit bluray 3D on the PSN. That could be good. Are there particular titles of games and or videos you'd like me to download a demo of from PSN to evaluate?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
228 Posts
You should be able to use Tridef Interleaved Mode to get 3D in games at 1920x1080. Or try IZ3D drivers again in Interleaved, Horizontal Optimized Mode. The software I mentioned are designed to play games in 3D. Your framerate will be cut in half but with a good video card, that should not matter. The interleaved mode will allow you to playback games or movies in a window at 60 fps which is not possible in Frame packing mode 24Hz.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
46 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by Brian /forum/post/20578560


I've heard Killzone 3 is real challenge for 3D displays. There should be a demo in the PSN store.

There is a 3d demo. I just deleted it off my ps3 a week ago.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
19 Posts
Dear Richard Adams

I see that you are happy with the d2342p 3D monitor. You mentionned that you could playback SBS file with VLC. My question is: with true 3d files, like the one you mentioned, is "Tridef 3D" required? I think Tridef is only useful for 2D-3D conversions, am I wrong?

Personnaly I am only interested in 3D movies (I own 10); after ripping, 3D files are displayed in the SBS format on my Full-HD monitor and viewed through my stereoscope. This is perfect but not comfortable, so I am interested in this 3D passive monitor.

Thank you for your comments.

Jacques Ligou, Switzerland
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,140 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by ligou /forum/post/20588563


Dear Richard Adams

I see that you are happy with the d2342p 3D monitor. You mentionned that you could playback SBS file with VLC. My question is: with true 3d files, like the one you mentioned, is "Tridef 3D" required? I think Tridef is only useful for 2D-3D conversions, am I wrong?

Personnaly I am only interested in 3D movies (I own 10); after ripping, 3D files are displayed in the SBS format on my Full-HD monitor and viewed through my stereoscope. This is perfect but not comfortable, so I am interested in this 3D passive monitor.

Thank you for your comments.

Jacques Ligou, Switzerland

The "Tridef 3D" package was not needed to play in 3D the SBS format 3D file segment I tried. I used VLC video player, with no special drivers and no particular 3D setup to play in 3D an SBS file.


Also the Sony HD10 camcorder displayed 3D in SBS mode when directly connected to this monitor.


The SBS mode of 3D is selected from the LG D2342P monitor menu. In this mode, the monitor interprets the input signal as an SBS mode 3D signal, and arranges the display so that the passive 3D mode works.


This means that the monitor will play 3D content from any video player for SBS mode media. Though I have not tried it, I suspect it would work in SBS mode with Mac, Linux, and other 3D camcorders where the content source was SBS. It also has an option for top / bottom mode which I have not tried yet.


Other 3D I have seen on this monitor where while connected to the PS3. The PS3 recognized it as a 23" 3D capable monitor. I downloaded several free 3D game demos and 3D movie demos from the Play Station Network. These 3D demos looked excellent on the monitor.


I read that PS3 3D movies that are not from bluray are in MP4 "frame alternate" mode.


I will post results of other sources and content that I am able to generate 3D success with.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,140 Posts
Discussion Starter · #17 ·
After lacking any progress with the TMT5 player, I am having initial success with the PowerDVD 11 player for 3D mode with this monitor.


More testing to do and report.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
19 Posts
You wrote that you could playback SBS files directly without the Tridef 3D package. This is good.


You also wrote: "The SBS mode of 3D is selected from the LG D2342P monitor menu". Unfornutalely in the Oner's Manual, it is stated that the SBS choice is enabled only for HDMI connection. On my PC, I have only 2 DVI-D outputs; does it mean that I should buy an adaptater?


On the other hand, if the "3D L/R CHANGE" option is used, a DVI-D connection is allowed, but how to specify the SBS format?


Finally is it possible to easily come back from 3D to 2D modes?


Jacues Ligou, Switzerland
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,140 Posts
Discussion Starter · #19 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by ligou /forum/post/20631279


You wrote that you could playback SBS files directly without the Tridef 3D package. This is good.


You also wrote: "The SBS mode of 3D is selected from the LG D2342P monitor menu". Unfornutalely in the Oner's Manual, it is stated that the SBS choice is enabled only for HDMI connection. On my PC, I have only 2 DVI-D outputs; does it mean that I should buy an adaptater?


On the other hand, if the "3D L/R CHANGE" option is used, a DVI-D connection is allowed, but how to specify the SBS format?


Finally is it possible to easily come back from 3D to 2D modes?


Jacues Ligou, Switzerland

The manual is correct for only being able to select SBS 3D when using the HDMI input connection on the D2342P.


The video card for all my testing done thus far only has a DVI-D output and no HDMI. When I used a DVI to DVI input on the D2342P monitor, I could not select SBS. So I switched to using a DVI to hdmi cable, going to the monitor's HDMI input. That input connection allowed the SBS selection through the front panel menu buttons on the D2342P. All of my 3D testing since then has been via the HDMI input on the D2342P monitor.


I have not used the L/R change option.


The front panel menu allows selecting 2D mode of display, though when an SBS signal is input to the monitor in the monitor's 2D mode, the two side by side images appear on the monitor.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
19 Posts
To R. Adams

Thank you for your posts. I see now more clearly how to proceed with this monitor. I will use the HDMI 1.4 connection, but on the page 20 of the owner's manual there is a list of the accepted 3D Formats.

Did you use an SBS format without horizontal compression (Frame Packing) or, as it is allowed, the usual Side-by-Side (Half)?


By the way, I mainly obtain my 3D files with the FujiFilm 3D W3 which is a cheap camcorder producing very good videos (720p). With Roxio-11, I can edit these files and chose many export formats (mp4, wmv, etc...; SBS, Top-and-Bottom, etc...).


I have also ripped from many 3D Bluray discs, complete movies with the program DVDFab; I can get SBS100% or 50%SBS files with the formats mp4, wmv, avi, etc...I hope that I will be able to playback these movies with this monitor. I normally use VLC for playingback HD movies.



Thank you again
 
1 - 20 of 260 Posts
Top