AVS Forum banner
1 - 8 of 8 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
48 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
This is kindof two different questions but they're related. Sorry that I made a somewhat similar thread earlier in the week, but I think this is a different enough subject.


I just moved into a new apartment that is lacking in overall square footage but still feels very open (for Manhattan) thanks to ceilings that are around 11.5 feet tall and enormous windows. This is a really rough floor plan, which is all I really have:



As you can see the entire place is about 20'x18' - the bathroom, and the space where sound actually matters is about 20'x11'.


So, sure, satellites make sense here (to everyone not on AVS that is), but I really don't want to resign myself to a system totally reliant on a subwoofer for bass, and don't want to pay extra for said system.


What I'd honestly like to do is go with two semi-low profile towers as mains, and then slowly mount large bookshelves in place of typical sattelites since I can afford the vertical space. I'd have 5.1 in the "living room" and an additional two bookshelves in the corners above the bedroom to use when playing music.


The only drawback I see, is that these would need to be mounted rather high, which is less than ideal for movies, but would it be passable to someone who only watches movies 25% of the time if angled correctly?


Here are a few more pictures to give you an idea of what I'm working with:







Second question/issue:


I've decided to settle on a decent 2.1 setup for now, since my budget is limited by the fact that I also have to actually furnish my apartment. I set out to spend $400 on a pair of mains, then it went up to $500, and then $650 when I ran into the Aperion 4T towers...At that price it'll be another month at least before I can even afford a subwoofer at $300-400 (looking at the HSU STF-02), and with bass being fairly important to me I'd really like to do a full 2.1 around $750 if possible. The other constraint is that given the size of my apartment, towers need to be rather small (I've looked at Aperion Intimus 4Ts @ $650/pr. and Energy Take TWRs at $400/pr.)


Ideal placement would actually be on top of the middle wall (bookshelves), but I don't know if that will limit the sound, which is why I'm looking to towers.

So ideally I'm looking for reccomendations of a pair of mains, bookshelves or low-profile towers, at around $400-700, that will be able to make up for the fact that the rest of my system may, in fact, be comprised of unimpressive satellites. While I'd like to spend no more than $500, if the jump in performance is great enough, I can go up to around $700 since these will be the systems backbone.

Other factors that may be relevant:

-My receiver will be a Pioneer VSX-919

-Neighbors are not an issue, my apartment building is a remodeled linens factory with insanely thick concrete walls and floors. I have only 1 direct neighbor and have a large outdoor deck between myself and his nearest wall.

-I plan to spend about $500 every three months until I'm completely finished.

-The couch will be in the space where all that clutter currently is, and is fairly low, putting ear level at about 3.5ft.


Sorry if this seems like another "I have no money, and no space, but I want an awesome system" thread, but I promise that's not the case! Any help would be greatly appreciated, thanks!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
22,124 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by infiniteengine /forum/post/16891571


.


Sorry if this seems like another "I have no money, and no space, but I want an awesome system" thread, but I promise that's not the case! Any help would be greatly appreciated, thanks!

well, actually, it is...


imo, bookshelves + sub would be your best bet... there's nothing at all wrong with a subwoofer providing the bass, and in a space like yours that has potential to be "difficult", it's likely that you will get better bass by having the ability to put your subwoofer in an ideal location...


imo 2, if you are planning on spending 500 every 3 months, save for 6 months and up your speaker budget to $1000... otherwise you will end up throwing good money after bad... decide what you want, and when you have the funds, purchase it...


imo 3, speaker height is as important for music as for ht...


imo 4, your budget doesn't match your desires... that's not uncommon...
 

· Registered
Joined
·
48 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by ccotenj /forum/post/16891607


well, actually, it is...

You're right, it is, but I just wanted to make it clear that this is not my setup, I'm planning on spending a reasonable amount of money given the overall size of the apartment. I feel like most posts I've sorted through are looking for a 7.1 system for $500 and such, with my receiver at $330, and a budget of around $700 for just a 2.0, I feel like $1030 isn't completely unreasonable, but I guess its all relative.


I would honestly consider $1000 right now if the decision were as easy as "this is certainly my best option" but I feel like with all the options out there, and quality being so subjective I'm too unsure of myself to go that high. On the other hand, I'd really like somethingup and running while the weather's still nice enough to have people over all the time for BBQs.


Thanks for the reccomendations, I think I need to do quite a bit more research on speaker height before moving forward...


(Also, I just realized I accidentally posted this in the Speakers sub-forum instead of Audio Theory, sorry, I'll try to get it moved.)
 

· The Village Idiot
Joined
·
9,905 Posts
I'm not sure just how far you are from Hillsborough NJ -
pick these up and there are no shipping charges - but you could get these at auction and sell the center speaker. You'd be able to get $150 or better from it based on a
recent ebay auction s. And you won't need a subwoofer for them for music. You may even decide you like having a center speaker. A recent auction of the same 3 speakers sold for just under $400. It would be very difficult to buy something new that would match the Infinity Beta 50.


Your post is exactly where it should be - it is about speakers after all.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
48 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by Knucklehead90 /forum/post/16891742


And you won't need a subwoofer for them for music. You may even decide you like having a center speaker. A recent auction of the same 3 speakers sold for just under $400. It would be very difficult to buy something new that would match the Infinity Beta 50.


Your post is exactly where it should be - it is about speakers after all.

They're nice, but I think a bit too big for my apartment. I think the Aperion Intimus 4Ts are about as big as I can get away with at 5x7.5" with an 8"x10" base; thanks though.


I asked that this be moved to the Audio Theory/Setup sub-forum as I feel its more about what kind of speakers and speaker placement will work in my situation and less about which actual speakers to get (though thats still an issue.)
 

· The Village Idiot
Joined
·
9,905 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by infiniteengine /forum/post/16891843


They're nice, but I think a bit too big for my apartment. I think the Aperion Intimus 4Ts are about as big as I can get away with at 5x7.5" with an 8"x10" base; thanks though.


I asked that this be moved to the Audio Theory/Setup sub-forum as I feel its more about what kind of speakers and speaker placement will work in my situation and less about which actual speakers to get (though thats still an issue.)

Well now, it looks like I posted the wrong link for you. I meant to post a link to these speakers . I got two different threads crossed up I guess.


I think those would work great in an apartment - their footprint is small - and they are a three way sealed speaker design. And there are no ports to worry about covering up.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
48 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
Ah, those are also nice, but a bit out of my pricerange.


I'm thinking about buying a used Aperion Intimus 532 set at $550 with shipping. If its a little underpowered I figure I can throw in the 4T towers as mains and use the extra bookshelf set in the "bedroom" area...still not sure.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
15,916 Posts
 http://emotiva.com/erm1.shtm


Terrific little speaker and a steal at the closeout price. Add a sub and you have an incredible little 2.1 system. Later, they could easily be used as surrounds.


Craig
 
1 - 8 of 8 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top