AVS Forum banner
  • Our native mobile app has a new name: Fora Communities. Learn more.

My Window of Opp is About to Close for HA Lighting

1196 Views 5 Replies 4 Participants Last post by  jte372
I have read through so much on this forum and I would like to thank everyone. Without this site, newbie DIY's that are not as technical as others would be totally lost.

With that said, I am having my basement built in and the electricians are just about to wrap up the wiring portion. I figure I have about a solid week before dry-wall begins.

I want to set up the ability to set up scenes in the home theater portion of the basement. It is not a dedicated home theater...it is adjacent to a billards room and a poker room/bar area. The lighting I specifically want to control is:

1) Series of can lights in the ceiling

2) 2 lights that shine on the fire place mantle

3) Rope lighting

I have not decided on the remote or the lighting technology I want to use and would appreciate any feedback. Ideally, I would like something flexible enough to allow me to use my remote to contol the scenes along with the rest of the theater. Eventually, I would like to tie this lighting into total HA..at some point anyway.

Jason W.
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
Thanks for the reply. Yes, the HAI controller is what I am leaning towards but the dimmers and switches will be slightly behind and to the left of the seating area.

Does anyone have a recommendation? I know the Scene contorllers are IR capable but I am worried, based on their location, they may not pick up the signal.
What it your budget? If all the loads come into one box, then a Lutron Spacer system would work fine. (Except for future connection to HA system)

Another option would be Lutron's RadioRA. It will work no matter where the load boxes are can be controlled by IR or RS232. Plus it is expandable to 64 loads so it can do your whole house in the future if you choose. It is also much more expensive.
I agree that either UPB or RadioRA are good options. Both are available to DIY installers.

RadioRA will be more costly but in my opinion has better looking keypad (controller) options and also has a more complete line of products for controlling unusual and high-power loads.

The new Generation II UPB products have me re-evaluating UPB as I haven't used it much in the past, but the new GEN II stuff seems to have resolved most of my previous concerns.

Look at UPB products from HAI (Home AUtomation Inc.), SAI (Simply Automated Inc.) and PCS (PulseWorx)... they are all interoperable and can be programmed with the free UPStart software from SAI. No config software for RadioRA... you have to program by running around to each switch and controller.


See less See more
Thanks for the response everyone.

Paul, if I were to go with a UPB type system, I could I control it via a RF/IR remote. I can get a room controller but I would have to mount it behind where I would be sitting.

One option I just found was an Insteon device

What I thought I could do was mount this in the cabinet with my IR blaster that should come with a remote that I get. I am not sure about Insteon though. I have heard a lot of negatives about it on this forum.

I would like to go with HAI if I had a solid solution to control it with a Harmony or URC type remote.


See less See more
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.