[zim2dive]

See EDITs at bottom before responding...


As detailed in gory detail here... http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showt...1032645&page=2 I have reverted to nvidia173 b/c later drivers have some very adverse effects on my 8200 IGP.... the consequence of this is losing HDMI audio.. ok, no problem I thought.. on the rear of the machine (Acer X1200) I have a set of jacks 2-wide and 3-high.. the manual that came with the machine says nothing about which is which.. so I rebooted into Vista and the Audio control panel showed me a picture indicating that 3 jacks each carry 2 channels..


- orange is front L+R

- black is rear L+R

- green is Center+Sub


And under Vista I was able to click on each speaker and confirm its location with a test tone. I also downloaded several test sound clips from around the web that will speak the speaker location from each speaker.


Back to Ubuntu...


When I play the same clips under Ubuntu with aplay, the sounds maybe sorta seem to come out the right place... I think.


I can't get speaker-test to work tho... I tried
Code:

speaker-test -c6 -l1 -twav

and
Code:

speaker-test -c6 -l1 -Dplug:surround51 -twav

and only hear sound from front left/right.


When I load 5.1 clip in to VLC and set the Audio to 5.1, the center is played out both L+R and the rear sounds come out the front as well... so it seems like its being downmixed.


When I load a true 5.1 movie, its like the speakers are all rotated.. center channel audio is barely audible, seemingly coming from the wrong speakers. I dunno, maybe the jack colors is totally software configurable and Vista is picking one mapping and Ubuntu is picking another?


In sound prefs I am using HDA NVidia ALC888 Analog (ALSA) for the various pull-downs and HDA NVidia (Alsa mixer) as my mixer, with all tracks selected in the select box.


To my /etc/modprobe.d/alsa-base file I have added and then removed
Code:

options snd-hda-intel model=3stack

which didn't seem to help nor hurt.


So in the process of this I now seem to have killed sound.. so I reboot.. still no sound.. and it gets stranger.. on the small speaker/sound icon on the toolbar I hit mute and then unmute.. now I have sound, but its full of background white noise. I reboot again, same thing.. best approximation is like there is a rogue process entering in to the mixer


EDIT: I have sound again.. but still not getting it from anything other than front L/R. In VLC, if I load a 5.1 movie, it sounds "ok" if I leave VLC audio device to stereo, but when I go to 5.1, I lose dialog, etc, as the center channel signal isn't getting to my rcvr.


EDIT 2: in VLC, in advanced options, if I go to ALSA and change the ALSA device name to HDA NVIDIA:ALC888 Analog(hw:0.0) now I have center channel dialog.... so I think the remaining question is how to get speaker-test working?


EDIT3: another clip in VLC doesn't have 5.1 as an audio device, only A52 over SPDIF.. which I don't have.. so I can't get 5.1 from that ???!?!


argh.. I thought my life was going to be simpler by not using the bleeding edge HDMI audio.. but that was MUCH simpler.. it just worked (ignoring the fact that nvidia video choked on full-screen flash)


thanks for any pointers,

Mike

 

[mythmaster]



Quote:
Originally Posted by zim2dive /forum/post/15478568


- orange is front L+R

- black is rear L+R

- green is Center+Sub

This is incorrect. The winduhs software detects which speakers are plugged in where and assigns jack outputs accordingly.


Green is front L/R, but I can't remember black and orange. I think black is rear L+R (surround), though; so, orange should be center+sub.

 

[zim2dive]



Quote:
Originally Posted by mythmaster /forum/post/15478946


This is incorrect. The winduhs software detects which speakers are plugged in where and assigns jack outputs accordingly.


Green is front L/R, but I can't remember black and orange. I think black is rear L+R (surround), though; so, orange should be center+sub.

My mistake, but only in what I wrote.. they are connected already as you say.... I do get stereo front L+R with the connections as is...when I run speaker-test the only speakers I get any voice for are front left/right. I get no sound for the other speakers.

 

[mythmaster]

OK, but I've got to sleep on this one since the vino runs rampant...

 

[zim2dive]



Quote:
Originally Posted by mythmaster /forum/post/15480312


OK, but I've got to sleep on this one since the vino runs rampant...

I dunno.. it brings to mind the Doc Holiday quote (at least from the movies).. in vino veritas (tho typos tend to abound)

I suspect I need to set an option type in my alsa-base.. I just can't tell from the various google search results if there is any method other than trial/error, and if I have to reboot between each, or if I really can just do a restart on alsa-utils (a restart on alsa for me came up saying no such beast...)


EDIT:

per this thread: http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=795525 I have also already uncommented the default-sample-channels and set to 6.. no change. (also no idea if pulse is coming in to the picture or not... for HDMI audio the emphasis seemed to be on killing pulse...)

 

[mythmaster]

OK, I'm sober again.

What is the output of:
Code:

aplay -L && aplay -l

 

[zim2dive]



Quote:
Originally Posted by mythmaster /forum/post/15484221


OK, I'm sober again.

What is the output of:
Code:

aplay -L && aplay -l

Code:

$ aplay -l
**** List of PLAYBACK Hardware Devices ****
card 0: NVidia [HDA NVidia], device 0: ALC888 Analog [ALC888 Analog]
  Subdevices: 1/1
  Subdevice #0: subdevice #0
card 0: NVidia [HDA NVidia], device 3: NVIDIA HDMI [NVIDIA HDMI]
  Subdevices: 1/1
  Subdevice #0: subdevice #0

$ aplay -L
default:CARD=NVidia
    HDA NVidia, ALC888 Analog
    Default Audio Device
front:CARD=NVidia,DEV=0
    HDA NVidia, ALC888 Analog
    Front speakers
surround40:CARD=NVidia,DEV=0
    HDA NVidia, ALC888 Analog
    4.0 Surround output to Front and Rear speakers
surround41:CARD=NVidia,DEV=0
    HDA NVidia, ALC888 Analog
    4.1 Surround output to Front, Rear and Subwoofer speakers
surround50:CARD=NVidia,DEV=0
    HDA NVidia, ALC888 Analog
    5.0 Surround output to Front, Center and Rear speakers
surround51:CARD=NVidia,DEV=0
    HDA NVidia, ALC888 Analog
    5.1 Surround output to Front, Center, Rear and Subwoofer speakers
surround71:CARD=NVidia,DEV=0
    HDA NVidia, ALC888 Analog
    7.1 Surround output to Front, Center, Side, Rear and Woofer speakers
null
    Discard all samples (playback) or generate zero samples (capture)

$ cat /proc/asound/card0/codec#* | grep Codec
Codec: Realtek ALC888
Codec: Generic 10de NVIDIA MCP78 HDMI

 

[mythmaster]

Hmm...that all looks ok. I'm not sure what to try on this one.

 

[quantumstate]

You're missing two devices (digital audio devices 1 & 2) You must have bios set to HDMI for HD audio.


I can't believe that nVidia driver 180.11 doesn't work for you?

 

[zim2dive]



Quote:
Originally Posted by quantumstate /forum/post/15484465


You're missing two devices (digital audio devices 1 & 2) You must have bios set to HDMI for HD audio.

Ok... but I don't know enough to know what to take from that? also, as mentioned, the jacks do work under Vista.

Quote:
I can't believe that nVidia driver 180.11 doesn't work for you?

Any driver after 173 kills Flash performance on the nvidia 8200 (and my bug report thread at nvnews has folks with the 8300 reporting the same problems).

So with the available drivers I can choose good video or audio over HDMI, but not both, so I am trying to use the 3 2-channel audio jacks instead, which one would think should have been working long before HDMI audio was working...

 

[quantumstate]

Yes the jacks should work, but not optical. The bios setting makes you choose between spdif or hdmi out for digital audio. I know that spdif is limited to 5.1, but I don't know whether hdmi can only do stereo and 7.1 .


Oh, I remember the flash problem. I'm sure there's a way to make it work full-screen, but I just don't have time to research.

 

[zim2dive]



Quote:
Originally Posted by quantumstate /forum/post/15484865


Yes the jacks should work,

yep, that's what I'm trying to accomplish

Quote:
Oh, I remember the flash problem. I'm sure there's a way to make it work full-screen, but I just don't have time to research.

With the 8200, I am now convinced it is a true issue with the nvidia drivers.. that is also the conclusion of other folks over at nvnews, so while there may be other fixes for other nvidia products, that does not appear to be the case for the 8200, trust me, I've researched little else for the past month.

 

[Rgb]

Some things to try-


Use SMplayer instead of VLC-

http://smplayer.sourceforge.net/down...php?tr_lang=en


Be sure to update to a recent vintage Mplayer as suggested on the SMplayer site. Intrepid repos should have a recent Mplayer.


In SMplayer, set the audio channels in Options->Preferences->General->Audio


This may sound obvious, but I just checked default Gnome Volume Control applet (usually in the systray with a speaker icon), and my Surround and LFE channels are muted by default, plus there is a Duplicate Front option on the Switches tab, visible when you check it in the Preferences dialog of the Volume Control panel. I am running Nvidia audio also, but not using more than stereo analog out- doing SPDIF for DD/DTS 5.1 and 2 channel PCM.


You may need to futz with the Volume Control panel.

 

[zim2dive]



Quote:
Originally Posted by Rgb /forum/post/15488661


Some things to try-


Use SMplayer instead of VLC-

http://smplayer.sourceforge.net/down...php?tr_lang=en


Be sure to update to a recent vintage Mplayer as suggested on the SMplayer site. Intrepid repos should have a recent Mplayer.


In SMplayer, set the audio channels in Options->Preferences->General->Audio


This may sound obvious, but I just checked default Gnome Volume Control applet (usually in the systray with a speaker icon), and my Surround and LFE channels are muted by default, plus there is a Duplicate Front option on the Switches tab, visible when you check it in the Preferences dialog of the Volume Control panel. I am running Nvidia audio also, but not using more than stereo analog out- doing SPDIF for DD/DTS 5.1 and 2 channel PCM.


You may need to futz with the Volume Control panel.

I made some progress.. I ran alsaconf.. and then when I went in to alsamixer I found a setting I did not think I had before that let me chance the # of channels from 2 to 6.. .speaker-test now works for me... under VLC, I am not yet (no longer) convinced that sound is coming out in 6 ch format at all..


A quick test with smplayer looks good!


gotta head out but will debug more in a few hours.

 

[mythmaster]

LOL, I didn't see the forest for all them trees!

Thanks, Rgb

 

[Rgb]



Quote:
Originally Posted by mythmaster /forum/post/15489154


LOL, I didn't see the forest for all them trees!

Thanks, Rgb

You and the other commandline ninjas just keep doing your thing- I'll handle the obvious questions and the GUI picks

 

[Rgb]

Be sure Alsa is selected in SMPlayer Options->Perferences->General->Audio->Output Driver


and the Device in the Gnome Volume Control applet is set to (Alsa Mixer)


As a last resort, you may need to disable PulseAudio/stop it from running, in a term window-


killall pulseaudio

 

[zim2dive]



Quote:
Originally Posted by Rgb /forum/post/15488661


Some things to try-


Use SMplayer instead of VLC-

........

plus there is a Duplicate Front option on the Switches tab, visible when you check it in the Preferences dialog of the Volume Control panel.

I had a mild pref for VLC.. is there a reason not to try to get it to work as well? (I get the impression there may be a philosophical debate between the 2 players...)


Also I don't seem to have the duplicate front checkbox to enable... are you sure I should have that?


It was wierd.. I've run alsamixer no less than 40 times at this point (with all the recompiles re-installs I've done)... I've never seen that mixer channel before... could alsaconf really have added/enabled something so that it then showed up?

 

[Rgb]



Quote:
Originally Posted by zim2dive /forum/post/15494365


I had a mild pref for VLC.. is there a reason not to try to get it to work as well? (I get the impression there may be a philosophical debate between the 2 players...)


Also I don't seem to have the duplicate front checkbox to enable... are you sure I should have that?


It was wierd.. I've run alsamixer no less than 40 times at this point (with all the recompiles re-installs I've done)... I've never seen that mixer channel before... could alsaconf really have added/enabled something so that it then showed up?

No philosophical issues with VLC- in fact, it's the best Linux DVD player, and a good alternative for problem video files. All my standard loads use SMplayer + VLC.


The Duplicate Front checkbox won't show on the Switches tab unless you activate it in Gnome Volume Control->Preferences


Make sure you're using VLC 0.9.4 or higher.

 

[zim2dive]



Quote:
Originally Posted by Rgb /forum/post/15488661


Some things to try-


Use SMplayer instead of VLC-

http://smplayer.sourceforge.net/down...php?tr_lang=en


Be sure to update to a recent vintage Mplayer as suggested on the SMplayer site. Intrepid repos should have a recent Mplayer.


In SMplayer, set the audio channels in Options->Preferences->General->Audio

So now I can't get smplayer to give me audio.... argh.


Looking at the logs, the left hand giveth... SMPlayer allows you to specify your own options, the right hand taketh away...SMPlayer looks like it insists on ading its own -ao to the command line, no matter what.. so I can't get my

Quote:
-ao alsa:device=hw=0,3

to override the -ao that it inserts... ideas short of recompiling it myself and ripping out their -ao ?