AVS Forum banner
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 7 of 7 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
763 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
By now I hope I have not worn out my welcome, but wanted to share some additional insight we have on the SW12.


Since these are more observations and not questions I started a new thread.


I have never heard bass like this before. It is an amazing piece of equipment.


I would suggest that you not pass judgement on this unit based upon it's price until you hear it. One cavet, it has to be set up right.


The first time I tried it I thought "where the beef". I was expecting it to do more than it was doing. This was due to my ignorance and not having it set up and tweaked properly.


For those of you who think, as I previously did, that there is not that much data below 100hz and that tweaking a sub (s) is a waste of time, don't think this way. As it truns out both of these ideas I previously had were wrong. There is something that happens to either music or movies with this sub that make a tremendous difference.


I do not understand how this happens, but I really don't care. I know what I hear. Plus, my wife, who does not have the "eyes glaze over at the mention of hime theater syndrome" also hears it.


Both of these things, as it truns out, are important. That is, where you put it and tweaking it once you have teh right spot.


Yes, it's a hassle to move a piece of equipment that weights 130 pounds. But, it's worth it.


We now have the two Velodyne's in the rear corners of the room. Thanks to Steve, TV , Mark and Jerry, the one in the right rear is a bit more forward than the one in the left. This gets them to put out the same amount of data and roughly the same level.


I calibrated each Velodyne by itself in the system (MC1) and without the Aerial SW12 in the system. Once I felt we had a "good" location and the levels were right I put the SW12 in line with the front mains. That is I set the low pass filter on the SW12 to 70 and also set the high pass filter to 70. I took the interconnects out of the MC1 for the front left and right channels directly into the SW12. using the HP Output from the SW12 I took another set of interconnects into the amp for the front left and right. i then calibrated the front left and right to 75 db with internal pink noise.


Then I played some movies. The Fifth Element is just amazing with this setup. What blows me away is the combination of very deep signals that are playing and I can also hear everything else at the same time. For example, when the priest is talking with the professor at the beginning of the movie I now hear the echo that is in that building as they talk. They continue to talk and you hear the space ship landing. You can hear the dialog while you are hearing the space ship landing. That is new for us. Amazing.


We played some music. Rock first (Eagles, Hell Freezes Over LD). The first track begins with the combination of a bass drum, kick drum and large bongos. You can distinctly hear all three. When Don Henley starts to sing you can still pick out each of these three drums but also clearly hear the vocals.


Next we played some jazz (Dianna Krall). The acoustic bass here goes all the way down. You can clearly hear the deep notes while she is singing. In fact, you can hear the bow working the strings even on the low notes and still not miss any nuance of her voice.


We then watched the full movie of Twister. We are now hearing things we did not hear before. A friend emailed me with the question "Do you think your sound now overpowers your video". In other words he was asking if the sound was not matching the level of the movie, I think both in quality and in level.


Quite the opposite. Now, the sound is more accurate. Not louder, just better. I still control the volume, so the sound is there. Now, when a storm blows I hear it distinctly all the way down and still do not miss all of the other things that are in what we are listening to. Not louder, more accurate.


At first I was listening for the loud boom one has become acoustomed to in so many subs. After a few listens I realized I was not hearing the boom, I was hearing what the artist put there. WHen that dawned on me I was amazed at what I had been missing.


Incidently, I did notice that I can now listen to things louder without any strain on my hearing, should I choose to do so. But again what is so impressive is I don't have to crank up the volume to get the low notes. They play back at every level accurately.


So, as you can image I ordered another SW12 last night. Do not think I am crazy until you seriously audtion this subs like we did.


Nice work Mike Kelly. Hope you sell a ton of them.


Chuck
 

· Registered
Joined
·
22,573 Posts
Gee, I just told Michael Kelly yesterday that I knew you'd be ordering your second SW12 shortly - but even I didn't anticipate so quick!!!! You are de MAN!


Despite how much you luv the Aerial sub and current placement of your subs, when you get the second Aerial sub, you've got to do your sub moving and placement trials again! My educated guess is that you should then try each Aerial sub around each front corner, and take the two Velodyne subs and stack them or place them next to each other in one room corner next to an Aerial sub. That way you'll get some smoothness of the Aerials in two corner areas, and your two Velodyne subs for LFE only next to the Aerial sub in the other corner will give deeper and easier extension. Of course, this is sort of modeled after what worked for me in my room, two SW12s in one corner and one SW12 in the other front corner. It is quite possible that the bass will really carry, like it does at my place, and with this arrangement, even at the back of the room if you close your eyes you'll think the subs are very close to you! TV emphasizes, in particular for LFE, that multiple LFE subs around the room will cause nulls and cancellations in some LFE, and his is absolutely right - although I do feel that having subs in opposite corners or by their respective front left and right speakers is helpful in smoothing the bass. So with two Aerial subs and two Velodyne's, you can have your cake and eat it too!

 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,308 Posts
Chuck,

Im glad to hear youre so happy with the sub http://www.avsforum.com/ubb/smile.gif


From doing some research on the topic, but unfortunately no real world trials, Im thinking that having subs spread out will create a more immersive bass sensation, while having subs closely placed will create greater bass output. I think which one you choose is just a personal preference. My choice would be greater immersion.


- Jerry
 

· Registered
Joined
·
22,573 Posts
Jerry is right on, except that Chuck, you probably don't have to settle for "either - or". Try what I said to do above, with the two Velodyne's stacked next to an Aerial sub in one corner or thereabouts, and the other Aerial sub in the other corner. And of course you could always sell the two Velodyne's and then buy that third Aerial sub and be as crazy as I am!!!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
763 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Mike called today with the shipping number. So I will have the second one by next weekend. Although it is a pain to move these guys it is well worth it. I have discovered the where its at is very important.


Jerry has emailed me with a very interesting idea that I think I am going to try. I want to try the second one is the "traditional" manner first to get a point of reference and then try Jerry's idea.


I like the idea of being in the middle of a movie and he may be on to something.


Regards


Chuck
 

· Registered
Joined
·
22,573 Posts
I like being in the middle of the movie, too! What was that lously movie where Schwartenegger came alive out of the movie in the middle of it?

The point I am making is that if it works in your room and setup like it does mine (you don't know unless you try), using the front room corners or nearby for all of your subwoofers will minimize nulls and cancellations, emphasize bass smoothness at the same time, and believe me, no matter where you sit or stand in the room, you will think that you're in the middle of the movie when it explodes or gunshots roar! But again, maybe my room defies the laws of physics and yours don't, so try all our ideas, and you'll not only end up looking like Mr. America (Mr. Muscles), but your room will really boom everytime you flex your muscles, too!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
763 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
Steve:


That is a very good point. BTW, thank you and TV, Jerry and Mark for the generous time and support in helping me get this going.


I noticed that one corner where the Velodyne's are is much more "live" than the other corner. I had not thought about stacking one on top of the other, but I guess that would work?


Stacking the Aerials is quite another issue due to their weight and mass.


I think initially I will try the second unit to the outside of the right 10T. The existing SW12 is to the inside of the left 10t (cable restriction currently).


Currently the Velodynes are run with the sub out from the MC1 to the first one and line out from the first one to the second one.


We are picking up a used pair of model 7's to put it into the rear. We are thinking on trying them on top on the Velodyne's.


If this works I'll post the results.


Regards,


Chuck
 
1 - 7 of 7 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top