AVS Forum banner

Over The Hedge: Review Thread

2546 Views 36 Replies 26 Participants Last post by  sethwas
Hello all,

Just another short review of Tim Johnson and Karey Kirkpatrick's adaptation of Over The Hedge, based on the comic strips of Michael Fry and T Lewis.


In short, this is one of the better effort from Dreamworks Animation. Much better than last year's Madagascar and the ill-fated Shark Tale. It didn't have the rapid fire visual jokes that the Shrek franchise has. It could also be that the jokes are so American-centric that people half-way across the world didn't get the reference. I did get the Dr. Phil joke. :D


But what it does have is some great voice acting by the cast and amazing character animation by the animators. Make no mistake - the script is much more polished, creating a familiar family story with a lot of potshots taken at the expense of the craziest animals of all - humans! I've never read the comic strip but the movie seems to jive with what the strip is about, which is the study of the idiosyncracies of human in suburbia.


It has an all-star cast: Bruce Willis, Garry Shandling, Steve Carell, Wanda Sykes, William Shatner, Nick Nolte, Thomas Haden Church, Allison Janney, Eugene Levy, Catherine O'Hara, Avril Lavigne, and Omid Djalili.


Like Madagascar, Dreamworks Animation and PDI have refined their pull-and-stretch animation techniques. All of the furry creatures, including the sole amphibian, are rendered beautifully. Johnson and Kirkpatrick should take full credit for that. But they also have to take full credit for not fully utilizing the mix! It wasn't an enveloping mix, like most of Pixar's sound mixes are.


I feel that while kids may dig some part of this movie and the toys, it is the adults who would truly get what it is like to live on their side of the street. Over The Hedge will struggle to get an Oscar nod next year, but at the very least, it was very entertaining. A smart, smart movie.



fuad
See less See more
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 20 of 37 Posts
Let the Summer 2006 Animation Wars begin! Dreamworks' Over the Hedge has fired the first volley and Pixar's Cars already has its work cut out for it! Over the Hedge is the funniest and most cleverly written animated movie since The Incredibles. Maybe not quite on par with The Incredibles but certainly the best since IMHO. My son is seven and he absolutely loved it. If you're a parent and are looking for a good family film this is it. Its certainly the best film released this weekend. As one critic who debunked the DaVinci Code put it, "Don't go see Monks. Go see Chipmonks instead!" Did anyone else catch this flick this weekend? Lets hear what you thought.
The clips I've seen of it look cute, but I fear many people will consider this one more Madagascar clone.


BTW, last week's time magazine had a long article on Cars and called it "the best movie of the year so far".
Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveFi
The clips I've seen of it look cute, but I fear many people will consider this one more Madagascar clone.
Oh, no. It's nothing like it. In this one, the animals go from the wild to civalization - not the other way around. It's completely different... ;)
Quote:
Originally Posted by NetworkTV
Oh, no. It's nothing like it. In this one, the animals go from the wild to civalization - not the other way around. It's completely different... ;)
If it's actually funny then it's no Madagascar clone.
The songs weren't that good. It had it's funny scenes, but it wasn't Shrek, The Incrredibles or Madagascar.


I should have rented it. As always, the trailer shows all the best scenes!
Yeah, but Wanda Sykes is in, so that's 1 "-" right off the bat.
My wife and I saw it and thought it was fun! It didn't have the laughs of Madagascar or the cleverness of Incredibles, but it was still very entertaining. The animals' view of the human's suburbanite life is particularly funny.
I'm sure I posted my advance review of this somewhere on this thingymagicky...



fuad
I took my 11yr old daughter and 3yr old son. And they both loved it. I really didn't like Madagascar. My son is a huge race car "Nascar" fan and is real excited to see Cars.
Found it. Can the moderator please merge the thread? :cool:



fuad
threads merged. A PM will get my attention or report a thread with a link to the dupe. I may not always see or remember existing threads.


larry
It truly delivers as a family movie, just plain meaningful and fun. I like the character Verne - one simply just feels with him as the story moves along.


Glad Dreamworks is given a new lease of life with this movie. SharkTale, Madagascar, and a few other works after Shrek 2 were not really up to the bar set by the early Dreamworks animated features.
I liked the movie and personally found most of the jokes to be rather funny. One of the noticeable improvements in this movie compared to other PDI movies is the animation quality, which in my opinion is now equal to Pixar. One of the few negatives of this movie is the songs which seemed a tad poorly chosen. In order of past PDI movies I would consider this to be the third best after Shrek and Shrek 2.
Verne definitely is an amazing character. What makes him work is that Gary Shandling doesn't sound like Gary Shandling, thereby pulling you more into the more.


While Bruce Willis as RJ is like Addison in Moonlighting, except furrier and funnier, with his take on human life.


William Shatner and Nick Nolte are virtually undistinguishable.


Best scene has gotta belong to Hammy. :D:D:D



fuad
See less See more
Why were these threads combined?
Quote:
Originally Posted by BZiggyZ
My wife and I saw it and thought it was fun! It didn't have the laughs of Madagascar or the cleverness of Incredibles, but it was still very entertaining. The animals' view of the human's suburbanite life is particularly funny.


If this is honestly how you feel then you and I have very different senses of humor OR Over the Hedge is one of the most boring movies of the summer. Madagascar was so utterly forgettable that Dreamworks should be embarrassed.
good but nowhere near Shrek(ONE,two sucked!!) good!
Has anyone picked up the dvd and can comment on the transfers pic and sound quality?
Good on both counts....


movie is much more entertaining that Madasgascar!
1 - 20 of 37 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top