AVS Forum banner

what do you prefer for a main TV Plasma or LCD?

  • LCD (I own(ed) BOTH LCD and Plasma)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Plasma (I own(ed) BOTH LCD and Plasma)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • LCD (ONLY have owned LCD)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Plasma (ONLY have owned Plasma)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 20 of 420 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,396 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
out of my own curiosity i thought up this poll


please provide honest answers
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,396 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by bill4903485 /forum/post/18276311


I believe only total anonymity will yield much nearer to 100 percent honest answers.

I was thinking the other way around actually, that having the results public will help to keep people honest
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,149 Posts
This poll, like mine before, proves that the plasma camp is grossly overrepresented here at AVS.


In the real world where normal people congragate the LCDs outsell plasmas 3 to 1 in the 40 and up category so please don't start me with the computer monitors. This translates into a 24 to 1 overreprentation factor.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,967 Posts
^ It absolutely proves nothing of the sort.


First, seeing it's anything but a scientific poll, it's all but impossible to make ANY verifiable correlation whatsoever.


That said, a very strong argument can be made that folks who frequent this site are MUCH more likely to have either a strong knowledge base and/or experience with display technology (certainly more than the average or even "above" average consumer) and therefore can make a more "educated", or, at least substantiated opinion over those who spent 30 minutes (or none at all) researching their last television purchase.


Now, if that means plasma will be "over represented" as the superior or most desired TV tech, so be it, I guess. A reasonable person who witnessed such a differentiation on a site dedicated to technology would likely infer that there's probably some substantial or at least clear performance differences.


And, in this case, that reasonable person will have reasoned correctly. :p


James
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,967 Posts
It's like going on a car driving enthusiast site and being surprised that rear-wheel drive autos are grossly preferred to front wheel drive, even though FWD outsells RWD nearly 10 to 1 in the "real world".


meaningless.


James
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
518 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by mastermaybe /forum/post/18276918


^ It absolutely proves nothing of the sort.

...

Now, if that means plasma will be "over represented" as the superior or most desired TV tech, so be it, I guess.


James

Exactly. If anything, it goes to show that those "in the know" overwhelmingly prefer plasma and that should be more important to the potential buyer than what the majority of uninformed consumers purchase.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
45 Posts
I for one have only owned LCD, but am wishing that I would have gotten a plasma. There was no choice on the poll for me...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,149 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by mastermaybe /forum/post/18276918


^ It absolutely proves nothing of the sort.

It proves exactly what I said. I didn't go into the reasons why the plasma owners visit this folder in such large numbers compared to those that prefer LCDs. The naked and undisputable fact is that they do and vote accordingly.


Or let me try something simpler: Assume that in a room we have 50 people that bought plasmas and 50 that bought an LCD as their primary set. We asked them to raise their hands to show what they have as their primary set. I would expect a 50-50 outcome. Wouldn't you?


Now let's adjust for the actual ownership stats. Let's stipulate that there are three times as many owners of LCD vs. plasma out there in the world. Would you say the the 50-50 group is a representative? No, it's skewed for some reason. If you want to claim that LCD guys are uneducated dupes, go for it. The fact still remains that the 50-50 group doesn't reflect what is out there.


Because of that the poll, for whatever reason, shows, at least at the time I posted my comments, only one thing: 8 to 1 ratio is 24 time out of alignment with the reality of ownership accross the country.


If you want to claim that some LCD owners bought their LCDs but prefer plasmas, that would not pass the giggle test.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,496 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by ramazur /forum/post/18276885


This poll, like mine before, proves that the plasma camp is grossly overrepresented here at AVS.


In the real world where normal people congragate the LCDs outsell plasmas 3 to 1 in the 40 and up category so please don't start me with the computer monitors. This translates into a 24 to 1 overreprentation factor.

Another way to say that is this:


9 out of 10 TVs sold now are LCDs.


Part of this is the fact that there are more LCDs on display at places like Best Buy.


What it doesn't mean is that there is a shortage of Plasma TVs for sale.


From Sears TV salesman, (and AVS member), Steve S, we know that there are "spiffs" or cash incentives for retail salesmen to direct buyers to certain brands, notably, Samsung. According to Steve this happens at Best Buy and most other retail stores. And, while Samsung sells some plasmas, Samsung is much more focused on LCD, especially, LED. Samsung should be ashamed of itself for confusing the general public by making it seem like LED is something other than LCD.


The OP continues to look for ways to promote 720P plasma, after having ignored/dismissed plasma for some reason before stumbling across the inexpensive 50 inch 720P Panasonic 50 inch plasma.


For those with sufficient light control, plasma is a good choice, although the rising black levels issue must be keeping some people from buying Panasonic plasma. Ordinary shoppers will never even hear of that issue, but the people on this Forum aren't ordinary shoppers, so it's hard to say how many potential Pansonic plasma shoppers are going to skip Panasonic plasma due to the rising black level.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,967 Posts
Again, no it doesn't. This is a forum that represents most wholly, A/V technology...specifically, a significant amount of gear that is aimed at mid-upper to the hi end fans. Because most LCD televisions do not fall into this category, the folks "here" are PERFECTLY representative of that fact. Again, there is a reason why "here" contains more PDP "lovers".


Further, nothing speaks more to (and beyond) this simple reality than EIGHTEEN out of TWENTY respondents who own BOTH LCD and PLASMA PREFERRING PLASMA.


That's 18/20.


90%.


I'm certain that number will only increase.




Although not scientific and a rather sparse number of respondents thus far, this is going just about the way any dolt could have predicted:


Plasma is the preferred display technology of the "learned" folks overall AND, more crucially, it is the preferred display tech of "learned" folks who own BOTH LCD and PDP.


very straightforward, really.


James
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,967 Posts
Where "720 resolution PDP's" enter in to any of this is beyond my grasp, apparently.


Sounds like a cat fight carrying over from another thread.


The poll is about as clear as possible.


James
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,967 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by ramazur /forum/post/18278545


It proves exactly what I said. I didn't go into the reasons why the plasma owners visit this folder in such large numbers compared to those that prefer LCDs. The naked and undisputable fact is that they do and vote accordingly.


Or let me try something simpler: Assume that in a room we have 50 people that bought plasmas and 50 that bought an LCD as their primary set. We asked them to raise their hands to show what they have as their primary set. I would expect a 50-50 outcome. Wouldn't you?


Now let's adjust for the actual ownership stats. Let's stipulate that there are three times as many owners of LCD vs. plasma out there in the world. Would you say the the 50-50 group is a representative? No, it's skewed for some reason. If you want to claim that LCD guys are uneducated dupes, go for it. The fact still remains that the 50-50 group doesn't reflect what is out there.


Because of that the poll, for whatever reason, shows, at least at the time I posted my comments, only one thing: 8 to 1 ratio is 24 time out of alignment with the reality of ownership accross the country.


If you want to claim that some LCD owners bought their LCDs but prefer plasmas, that would not pass the giggle test.

This post makes it VERY obvious you have no idea what I (and one or two others) are even contending.


It seems that your fatal error revolves around the fact that you insist that a "fair" or "representative" response to the poll is predicated upon a 50/50 (or near 50/50) ownership of tech (or equal visitation of LCD and PDP leaners visiting this thread (which would NEVER occur, BTW)). This is of course preposterous.


The best this poll can offer you is, again, the CLEAR distinction between what folks who own BOTH techs prefer. Which is now 19-2 in favor of plasma, BTW.


James
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,967 Posts
^ and this matters how?


But just to entertain the non-topical comment, this should, in an "everything being equal world" only increase the LCD representation on a poll such as this, and, assuming LCD buyers are as satisfied or MORE satisfied than PDP purchasers, cause a sea change in this poll. But, apparently, without any rhyme or reason, PDP owners (even though out-numbered 3 to 1) are much more prevalent in this region of AVS country.


And what "region" is this, you ask? "Flat Panel GENERAL and New FP Tech"


good grief.



James
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,396 Posts
Discussion Starter · #18 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by mastermaybe /forum/post/18278715


Again, no it doesn't. This is a forum that represents most wholly, A/V technology...specifically, a significant amount of gear that is aimed at mid-upper to the hi end fans. Because most LCD televisions do not fall into this category, the folks "here" are PERFECTLY representative of that fact. Again, there is a reason why "here" contains more PDP "lovers".


Further, nothing speaks more to (and beyond) this simple reality than EIGHTEEN out of TWENTY respondents who own BOTH LCD and PLASMA PREFERRING PLASMA.


That's 18/20.


90%.


I'm certain that number will only increase.




Although not scientific and a rather sparse number of respondents thus far, this is going just about the way any dolt could have predicted:


Plasma is the preferred display technology of the "learned" folks overall AND, more crucially, it is the preferred display tech of "learned" folks who own BOTH LCD and PDP.


very straightforward, really.


James

Thats exactly why i posted this poll, not really to see how many perffered plasma or LCD but to see how many of the LCD owners have never owned a plasma


the numbers speak for themselves the vast majority of people who have owned both prefer plasma and there are very few people on here that prefer LCD if they've owned a plasma before

Quote:
Originally Posted by mastermaybe /forum/post/18278750


Where "720 resolution PDP's" enter in to any of this is beyond my grasp, apparently.


Sounds like a cat fight carrying over from another thread.


The poll is about as clear as possible.


James

Spyboy likes to throw the "hes trying to justify buying a 720p plasma" into any thread i mention plasma in, don't mind him


he seems to think that it discredits me or makes me feel regret over it being 720p. yet hes never admitted to owning a plasma before so his opinions IMO are worthless
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,538 Posts
You where in favor of the word superior thats why i used it.


It seems that most tv forum visitors are plasmaowners.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,396 Posts
Discussion Starter · #20 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by 8mile13 /forum/post/18278890


Most people are in the lcd section on AVsience .


LCD has superior sales.

yes and a great majority of those people in the LCD section are not regular's on these forums and it really shows due to all the

"what LCD should a buy threads"

"whats wrong with my LCD threads"

"why does my LCD have image retention threads"


people come to these forums looking for answers and the less informed people are looking at LCD's clearly the difference between the plasma section and the LCD section exemplifies this
 
1 - 20 of 420 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top