AVS Forum banner

281 - 290 of 290 Posts

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,394 Posts
Believe it or not, it’s out and I have it finally. Ordered it in July and got it today, Dec 29th. Have already added it as a device to my Harmony profile but haven’t paired it yet so I can’t speak to if it works as advertised. Sure hope so...on/off and total PS4 functionality has been a long time coming.
See my post 6 up from this one. I received mine today and setting it up as I type this.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
I can't get the thing to connect. It connects right after it is paired to the PS4, and shuts the system off fine. Then, after waiting a few minutes, it will turn my TV and receiver on but won't turn on the pS4. Then when I turn it on with the DS4, it goes into a system error mode and asks me to send Sony info on the error and what I was doing. Had this happen twice. Also, when I do get into the system, under Bluetooth devices, it tells me to press any button on the Bluetooth device to connect the PDP receiver. Uh, ok but isn't this why we bought the thing in the first place so we don't have to always use the DS4 for everything? Don't know where the problem lies with Logitech or Sony or PDP...maybe all three or a combination. Have you had any luck?
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
OK, so I think I have it figured out. You have to delete the PS4 (or PS4 Pro) from your PS4 Activity on your Harmony remote profile AFTER you've paired it with the PS4. Then, set up the PS4 Activity again in your profile using your TV and/or receiver (as before); then use the PS4 IR Receiver as one of the devices instead of the PS4. Of course, this is assuming the IR receiver is already set up as a device in your profile using the instructions that come with it. Then, put all of the button commands, etc. on the IR Receiver instead of on the PS4. I used the PS button for turning the system on and it works like a charm. However, there still isn't a Power Off command on the IR receiver profile, so I'm still using macros to turn the system off. Hopefully, we'll get that fix soon.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
Well I got it working in my various activities, it definitely turns on the device and navigates through the menus.

It connects via bluetooth btw, in case anyone is curious

I am now trying to figure out how to create a macro for the turning off option:


  • Im in the PDP PS4 IR, ive selected that I want the device to turn off.
  • Ive adjusted the power settings to "I want to turn off this device when its not in use"
  • Picked "a button on the remote for On, and a different button for Off"
  • "I dont have the original remote, but i know the command" - selected PS command
  • Then "I dont have the original remote, but i know the commands", selected more than one command.
  • I have selected PS, Down, Down, X, X.
The issue is, I dont know how to program a hold of "PS" the PS/Power button. Pressing it once just quick switches the windows. I need to figure out how to hold it, so it enters the power menu.

Another option if you are on the main dashboard is "up" and then ten right arrows, x, x, but that is a lot of commands to send and would really slow down the power off process for those that don't want to stay line of sight for that whole time.

Ideas?
Here is a quick snapshot (see attachment) of how you can do it using the Quick Menu. I edited my Quick Menu to only have one or two things on it and rarely use it anyway, so this turns the system off within 5 seconds provided you leave the Quick Menu cursor set on Rest mode. Remember, you must do it on the "Devices" tab not the "Activites" tab and it must be the IR Receiver, not the PS4. (Remember that you program everything to the IR Receiver once you have paired it and not to the PS4 any longer.)
Also remember, the key is to set the Power Off Settings "PS" button to 2 seconds. This is how you set the duration of the button press
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
404 Posts
Here is a quick snapshot (see attachment) of how you can do it using the Quick Menu. I edited my Quick Menu to only have one or two things on it and rarely use it anyway, so this turns the system off within 5 seconds provided you leave the Quick Menu cursor set on Rest mode. Remember, you must do it on the "Devices" tab not the "Activites" tab and it must be the IR Receiver, not the PS4. (Remember that you program everything to the IR Receiver once you have paired it and not to the PS4 any longer.)
Also remember, the key is to set the Power Off Settings "PS" button to 2 seconds. This is how you set the duration of the button press
Unfortunately the duration options are not available on the harmony one. Well, maybe I need to test the My Harmony Remote app? Because its not an option in the Harmony Remote software 7.7.0.

*edit* holy cow, so all this time I thought 7.7.0 was the most recent software as it never updated, didnt realize they changed platforms. Guess i have some exploring and finagling to do in the newer app
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
Unfortunately the duration options are not available on the harmony one. Well, maybe I need to test the My Harmony Remote app? Because its not an option in the Harmony Remote software 7.7.0.

*edit* holy cow, so all this time I thought 7.7.0 was the most recent software as it never updated, didnt realize they changed platforms. Guess i have some exploring and finagling to do in the newer app
Yes, the Harmony One along with many of Logitech's other remotes went to the "MyHarmony" desktop software for everything a few years back. I should have mentioned that in my posts: "You must be using the MyHarmony desktop software" to follow the instructions I gave. The latest iteration looks like the attached on your desktop.
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
Yes, the Harmony One along with many of Logitech's other remotes went to the "MyHarmony" desktop software for everything a few years back. I should have mentioned that in my posts: "You must be using the MyHarmony desktop software" to follow the instructions I gave. The latest iteration looks like the attached on your desktop.
Oh and one final note. The 'Duration" does not have to be set to 2 seconds. I have tried it at 1.5 and so far that works better for my setup. With two seconds it was not only turning the system on but going to the last game I played and I wanted it to only get to the XMB startup screen. I have not tried it at one second yet so someone else may want to try that if it will benefit them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
358 Posts
Does the PS4 play blurays any better than the PS3? If not, then I will just skip this thing because the harmony elite works perfectly with the PS3.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,244 Posts
Does the PS4 play blurays any better than the PS3? If not, then I will just skip this thing because the harmony elite works perfectly with the PS3.
The PS4 is no better than the PS3 for Blu-ray playback, except the PS4 can do simultaneous 3D + Dolby TrueHD and the PS3 can’t. The Harmony control of the PS4 doesn’t even work (on screen controls only, unless you also get that IR receiver thing).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
541 Posts
I just got and set up my brand new Harmony Elite yesterday and am still working on it. Feverishly, to be honest. lol

The PS4 is no better than the PS3 for Blu-ray playback,
Actually its worse. At least from a remote controll interface standpoint. Although I get your point about the 3D + Dolby TrueHD, and that's certainly fair. However, for reasons I cannot even begin to fathom, on the PS4 the Blu-Ray control-scheme is separated and different from the controls for DVD playback. DVD is intuitive and easy, and you can use the more obvious buttons. Blu-Ray is a nightmare. I have to boot up my bedroom setup as that one still has a PS3. Since I use it mostly for gaming and streaming, and not for Blu-Rays, I don't remember for certain, but I want to say that I seem to remember Blu-Rays playing much easier and more intuitive, in terms of BD Remote interface than the PS4, which is a freaking nightmare of circuitous buttons for Blu-Ray playback, even with the Sony BD remote made specifically for the PS4.


The Harmony control of the PS4 doesn’t even work (on screen controls only, unless you also get that IR receiver thing).
Yeah this is an absolute horror show, I have to admit. It is a total and complete mess of non-responsive Blu-Ray controls on the Harmony. As I said above, they completely suck on the Sony remote as well, but at least they are somewhat navigable. On the Harmony Elite, the Blue-Ray playback is completely untenable. All you can really do with the Harmony is launch the Blu-Ray and sit there and let it do whatever it wants. Oh, and lol you can exit Blu-Ray playback! I tried this both with CEC on, from the TV menu, because that is the only way I can use the Harmony to turn on my PS4, since I have a75" UHD Bravia, I use Bravia Sync. I thought that maybe the problem was that the PS4 doesn't like me attempting blue-ray playback while in the "TV" device on the Harmony, so I switched to the PS4 device, and the same thing.

In Logitech's defense, however, as much as this really blows, I think this is all on Sony. I think that's what you are saying, too, so I don't want you to think I am calling you out. But I tried playing Blu-Rays on my XBox One S, with the Elite, and it was fine. So I have to conclude this is just Sony idiocy, along the same lines as blocking non Sony OEM PS4 remotes from turning on the PS4.

Under the heading of Who gives a flying crap, DVD playback on the PS4 Pro is fine with the Harmony Elite. But no go for Blu-Ray. So from now on I will just use my XBox One S for Blu-Rays. lol Oh well. But like I said, I think we can blame Sony for this, not Logitech. I am saying NO to the PS4 IR Receiver. Why should I give those corporate thugs at Sony another $29.99 because they screwed me (us) on PS4 third party remote control functionality. I would buy it grudgingly if I had to. But I have my XBOne, so Sony can lick me.
 
281 - 290 of 290 Posts
Top