There are several details that option B allows that will improve your sound isolation through decreased flanking via the main/elevated slab. Design the drop slab as a separate pour from the main slab with a gap around the perimeter of the drop slab to prevent any contact between the main and drop slabs. Prepare a compacted sand bed for the drop slab as opposed to compacted gravel or earth. Build all of the interior room as a separate structure contained on the drop slab, including ceiling joists. No part of the interior room framing should contact the exterior room framing. Use steel strap or wood diagonals in a “V” or “X” pattern on the outer face of all the interior walls for racking resistance which will allow you to forgo the usual resilient connections between the inner and outer walls when this step is skipped. Don’t forget to add any plumbing and wiring conduit (both for line voltage and for low voltage / signal wiring) for the drop slab before the pour.
In this manner you can achieve the best possible sound isolation with very little added cost over a traditional drop slab.
Mike
In this manner you can achieve the best possible sound isolation with very little added cost over a traditional drop slab.
Mike