I second everything that jakehall states above. I have a Toshiba 34" widescreen in the family room and a 55" Mits widescreen in my home theater and I would only add that to me it would depend on the type of viewing you expect to do. The direct-view is nice and bright and viewable from anywhere in the room regardless of light. IMHO the RPTV looks better in the theater where seating is more controlled and viewing is mostly "head-on" and in somewhat softer light. The direct-view is an absolute bear to move. It is very heavy for it's size, nearly 200 lbs., and is quite "front heavy". It has to be on a very solid base because all of it's weight is on top. The RPTV is heavier, but it is on rollers and not as top-heavy. Much easier to move safely I feel. My 34" direct-view is too small for a home theater in my opinion, but is a great family room set.