AVS Forum banner
  • Get an exclusive sneak peek into our new project. >>> Click Here

Ruby Color Balance Issue?

850 Views 17 Replies 11 Participants Last post by  ColorChange
I think my new Ruby has a gray scale calibration problem (the old one was fine). The misconvergance is good but this one has a weird color balance problem. I have not been able to see it on normal viewing but you sure can see it in some screen shots.


It appears mostly around 50% white, and is most prominent in the lower left corner, and less so the lower right corner, but can be seen. Is this simply a color temp calibration issue?


http://forums.rennlist.com/upload/color_1.jpg



http://forums.rennlist.com/upload/color_2.jpg
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
This is a "shading" issue. Welcome to LCOS :) Usually it manifests itself with green ting on the right of the screen and red on left.


Check out the shot's of my D-ILA. See any shading issues? ;) William Phelps has software that can fix this with D-ILAs. And I'll bet he'll have something for SXRD $oon. :D

http://gallery.avsforum.com/data/501...tpictures1.jpg
I see the same thing with my 004, but not to this degree. WmP has got the fix for the 004, I'm sure the Ruby is next on the list.
William Phelps process starts with his proprietary software coupled with the sensors that measure 1" square quadrants of the screen for white level. After measuring them all it adjusts them to achieve near perfect white field balance. Then comes gamma and all the other calibration. This process has been perfected for the Qualia and HD2K. I can't wait to get my Ruby done. Get it working William, go!


If I have incorrectly described the WN process I'm sure he will let me know.. ;).
OK, This is interesting. The first unit had none of it. I have a third one coming. Maybe the third time will be a charm.
Tryg how wide is your screen. Looks about 10 feet?

What material?

Boy am I nosey:)


Looks good, I like the framed curtains.
So you can't adjust grey scale on the rupee?


Or Convergence???


Or color and/or brightness uniformity for different regions of the screen?


I thought these new pj's would at least have the features of the older models they replaced.


There ought to be a "pro" version of the rupee with some adjustments available for calibrators.


-B
See less See more
Tim,


This is weird, but on my unit, I get a little pinkish tinge at certain IREs on the gray scale pattern, but its pretty uniform (i.e. its everywhere on that IRE level of the pattern). This using DVI, from the OPPO player. Using DVI again, from my ATI 9800 at 1920 X 1080p60, I get virtually perfect gray scale (no color). Weird. I'm still investigating.


As Tryg pointed out, your screen shots appear to be shading. My JVC G-10 had very slight shading issues, and it manifests usually as color shifting on a 100IRE full field pattern. Is yours only showing up on the gray-scale pattern ?


I think my color tinging only at certain IRE levels points toward gray-scale tracking, whereas yours in "vague" areas of the screen seems more like shading.


The good news is both can be addressed - I would bet Darin is hard at work on these and other issues! (I hope anyway). I also hope that the adjustment procedures / fixes for these issues end up being "open source", so that packing up the unit and $ending it in for a complete calibration won't be the only way to address them. Not that I have anything against that method, but AVS is largely a group of interested DIYers, and sharing the info to get things done has been the hallmark of this forum. I ultimately chose Dilard -vs- a Richard Martin calibration way back when because I enjoyed the tinkering, as I do now. Perhaps WM (I believe the only current calibrator of these types of displays) will produce some DIY tools like he did for the G-xx series JVCs (shading tool, I think it was). I didn't have to use it, but it was reportedly a great tool that got the job done, and IIRC, was priced reasonably.


Bottom line is we may need to wait a bit to get the know-how and the tools to correct some of these issues. It's like deja-vu, because many issues were the same, and it was a very similar situation way back when when I got my G-10. The big difference was that then, they were unusable for HT out of the box. At least now, the issues seem to be somewhat subtle.


- Chris
See less See more
Chris:


It appears to be most visible on about 50% gray screen. Mine was from an Oppo too. I

will try it from my denon dvd 9000 and see if this makes a difference.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Alan Gouger
Tryg how wide is your screen. Looks about 10 feet?

What material?

Boy am I nosey:)


Looks good, I like the framed curtains.
10 foot wide. White PVC.


This shot was taken 5 years ago
See less See more
Quote:
Originally Posted by Iamjcl
I also hope that the adjustment procedures / fixes for these issues end up being "open source", so that packing up the unit and $ending it in for a complete calibration won't be the only way to address them.
good luck!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brian Hampton
So you can't adjust grey scale on the rupee?


Or Convergence???


Or color and/or brightness uniformity for different regions of the screen?


I thought these new pj's would at least have the features of the older models they replaced.


There ought to be a "pro" version of the rupee with some adjustments available for calibrators.


-B
Yah know... I'm tired of reading usless, sourgrape infected information. That person who spouts usless information has been added to my ingnore list :). Tis the first entry. He should be honored.
See less See more
You won't see this post but.. I dis-agree. I think it's actually important information.


=B


p.s. Your avatar doesn't conform to forum rules.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tryg
good luck!


Thanks - I may need it.


- Chris
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tryg
This is a "shading" issue. Welcome to LCOS :) Usually it manifests itself with green ting on the right of the screen and red on left.


Check out the shot's of my D-ILA. See any shading issues? ;) William Phelps has software that can fix this with D-ILAs. And I'll bet he'll have something for SXRD $oon. :D
On current production LCOS the old left/right issues have been solved; all current LCOS units use zone shading.


I already have a working tool for SXRD, but it is expensive and not practical for DIY. I've got months of my time invested in learning how to do this, and it takes some expensive equipment as well. I might consider producing a tool similar to the one I did for the G series projectors that allows manual adjustment by selected area, gotta give that some thought...


While I'm on the topic of uniformity, I've seen a few posts saying "no uniformity issues here" or the like. I suspect that in fact if you take measurements you will find that the image is less uniform than you think. In the course of working on this problem I've learned a great deal. One thing that is really quite dramtic is just how much having dead on brightness uniformity, not just color, does for the image. I find most LCOS, and even quite a few DLP, vary significantly in brightness over the screen image. Put up a full field white at 100 IRE and measure the illumination at the screen in the corners, top and bottom center, and center, and see what you get.


William
See less See more
When you say "at the screen" do you mean off the screen? Or do you take the measurements directly from the projector using a diffusor?


Also, now that you have me thinking about brightness uniformity, does it change with the zoom of the lens? i.e. at full-zoom there's less issues, at minimum zoom there's more- because the light-beam isn't in the "sweet spot" of the lens?


Dan
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brian Hampton
So you can't adjust grey scale on the rupee?


Or Convergence???


Or color and/or brightness uniformity for different regions of the screen?


I thought these new pj's would at least have the features of the older models they replaced.


There ought to be a "pro" version of the rupee with some adjustments available for calibrators.


-B
Yep, someone else noticed these limitations too! I had assumed that these magnets around the CRT neck/yoke days were just bad, faded memories.

Well truth be known, the magnets are gone, but the same picture quality flaws exist, with the difference being that they are now completely uncorrectable.


ISF calibration ain't going to help either...
See less See more
I retested the same thing using my Denon DVD-9000 source and it was there, so it's not from the oppo.
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top