AVS Forum banner
  • Get an exclusive sneak peek into our new project. >>> Click Here
  • Our native mobile app has a new name: Fora Communities. Learn more.

Samsung HL-S6188 or HL-S5679?

695 Views 3 Replies 3 Participants Last post by  wsfanatic
Hi guys,


I've been floating around and reading this forum for a long time now. I've finally registered and need some advice. I've done a ton of research on both Samsung units above. I am in the market to purchase one of the two. Ideally, I would like to have a 61". I have seen both units on display and I do think IMO, that the 79 series with the new LED lighting system does look a little better in PQ and brightness. But obviously, there is no 61" in that series.


I was told that the HL-S6188 isn't exactly a true 1080p television because there is a 25% compression on that size TV. This was a rep at a Magnolia Best Buy. He did say that the 79 series has no compression and it is the real true 1080p.


Overall, I think that both units have great PQ and brightness, giving a slight edge to the 79 series. But is it truly worth spending an extra $1,000+ on it?


I will be hooking up my HD receiver through HDMI, and I will be purchasing the new PS3 when it comes out for my gaming and Blu-Ray movie player, also through HDMI.


I would love to hear your opinions and/or experiences with either set.


Thanks!

Craig
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 4 of 4 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kegger5150
Hi guys,

I've been floating around and reading this forum for a long time now. I've finally registered and need some advice. I've done a ton of research on both Samsung units above. I am in the market to purchase one of the two. Ideally, I would like to have a 61". I have seen both units on display and I do think IMO, that the 79 series with the new LED lighting system does look a little better in PQ and brightness. But obviously, there is no 61" in that series.
The specs, for whatever they're worth, indicate a lower contrast ratio for the 79. I haven't compared myself, but I'd be surprised if it were brighter using the same settings.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kegger5150
I was told that the HL-S6188 isn't exactly a true 1080p television because there is a 25% compression on that size TV. This was a rep at a Magnolia Best Buy. He did say that the 79 series has no compression and it is the real true 1080p.
There is no compression on the 88. It does have overscan enabled by default, but you can turn it off in the service menu. With overscan off, you get full 1:1 pixel mapping of 1080 content, but you still do get a little cropping around the edges. I'd be shocked if the 79 didn't do this as well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kegger5150
Overall, I think that both units have great PQ and brightness, giving a slight edge to the 79 series. But is it truly worth spending an extra $1,000+ on it?
I think you'll need to wade through the threads on various sets to get a a sense of what the pros and cons are. I went with the 88 b/c the DLP w/colorwheel seemed to be a proven technology and I didn't want to take the risks associated with being an early adopter of DLP w/LED technology.


The only problem is that even though I didn't see rainbows in the store, I do see them at home. LED technology changes colors faster than colorwheel technology, so rainbows should be less of an issue.


I'll probably switch to LCOS or DLP w/LED when I feel those technologies have matured.
See less See more
Thanks for your response. I think that I'm going to go ahead and buy the 6188.
Get the 6188. I did and I don't regret it one bit. I also looked at the 5679 but was a little concerned with it being a first gen set. I will say the 5679 has better color saturation. The lower CR isn't too apparent.
1 - 4 of 4 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top