AVS Forum banner

1 - 20 of 95 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
463 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I posted this on the Crestron Yahoo group but no one seems to have an answer.


I was wondering if anyone has used the CEC protocol on a Samsung LED, specifically the UN55B8000 55" 1080p LED HDTV , within a Crestron DM (Digital Media) environment?


I am planning 2 separate projects with DM and I want to control the Samsung LED with CEC. The descriptions of the DM system on Crestrons website says "Through proper CEC signal management, Crestron allows you to take control of each device as you like."


Has any one done this or something similar? If so how difficult was it to implement and is it reliable for Power (On/Off), input selection, etc?


Thanks in advance.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
405 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by GoGo Delicious /forum/post/17380439


I posted this on the Crestron Yahoo group but no one seems to have an answer.


I was wondering if anyone has used the CEC protocol on a Samsung LED, specifically the UN55B8000 55" 1080p LED HDTV , within a Crestron DM (Digital Media) environment?

I haven't used it so I'm not really helpful. But IMO I just cant trust it.. its not standard for all equipment yet and is still fairly new. I hate trying things and then having to redo them because "it should have worked" if you do try it however, I'd like to know how it turns out.


EDIT: Also I'm curious to know what devices crestron tested this with and the scenario in which they tested. (since they post that it you can use the CEC protocol)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
463 Posts
Discussion Starter #3

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dahwoo /forum/post/17381753


I haven't used it so I'm not really helpful. But IMO I just cant trust it.. its not standard for all equipment yet and is still fairly new. I hate trying things and then having to redo them because "it should have worked" if you do try it however, I'd like to know how it turns out.

Thanks for the reply. The CEC protocol is part of the HDMI standard and the reason I decided to go with CEC is that this particular display Samsung states on it's web site that "HDMI-CEC" is a feature of the UN55B8000 55" 1080p LED HDTV .


I was hesitant on the Samsung display, due to the lack of an RS-232 port, but after 4 Pioneer Elite plasmas, which are great by the way, I wanted to try something different plus I have picked out all displays in our house and my wife wanted to pick this one. By the way this DM system is for our house.


We are in the process of running Fiber to all the display in our house, as this will be a Fiber based DM system, and I wanted to run just one HDMI cable from the room controller ( DM-RMC-100-F ) for video and display control.


I will let you know how it goes, using CEC as a control protocol.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
463 Posts
Discussion Starter #4

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dahwoo /forum/post/17381753


EDIT: Also I'm curious to know what devices crestron tested this with and the scenario in which they tested. (since they post that it you can use the CEC protocol)

My next step is to give TB a call and ask that very same question.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
520 Posts
At TB DM training I attended last month it was suggested to turn off any form of CEC. In practice I always turn off CEC...


YMMV
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
870 Posts
CEC never works right, first thing I suggest doing when setting up any equipment is turning it off, the only chance of it working is when you have lets say a samsung tv and a samsung blu-ray then it might work, but even then I wouldn't rely on it, make sure you have a second way to control that TV or device, either by hauling cat 5 for an IR Repeater or eye or RF or serial control cable.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
463 Posts
Discussion Starter #7

Quote:
Originally Posted by roddymcg /forum/post/17391139


At TB DM training I attended last month it was suggested to turn off any form of CEC. In practice I always turn off CEC...


YMMV

When I was at DM training over at Crestron West they actually had CEC working and showing how it can control a display (PON, POF, Input). Since I am installing this in my house I am going to really try hard to make CEC work, specifically PON and POF. I only want one cable, Fiber, from the DM system to the Room Controller ( DM-RMC-100-F ) and from the room controller to the display a very short HDMI cable.


I am going to call TB this afternoon and see what I need to do to control the Samsung. If I can not get CEC to work with the Samsung, I am going with the Pioneer Elite Pro-141FD since I can control it via Ethernet and the DM-RMC-100-F has an Ethernet port.


Going the Pioneer route I will have two cables coming from the room controller, an HDMI cable and an ethernet cable both going to the Pioneer display. Either way I will still only have 1 fiber cable, going to each of the 5 locations, which will carry Data (Ethernet, RS-232, IR, USB/HID), Audio and Video.


I should have this installed and completed by the end of next week. If I get it to work via CEC I will post my results. Although the results will only be beneficial for those running a Crestron DM system.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,118 Posts
"I should have this installed and completed by the end of next week. If I get it to work via CEC I will post my results. Although the results will only be beneficial for those running a Crestron DM system."



And if you can't...................DON'T JUMP



Actually, I have been reading this thread and discovered liquid forming at the corners of my mouth. I WANT IT. I only have three locations to send it to but it's a finished house and the thought of a single run of fiber is making me feel all funny inside
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
463 Posts
Discussion Starter #9

Quote:
Originally Posted by GoGo Delicious /forum/post/17393174


I should have this installed and completed by the end of next week.

I have decided post my experience, and pics, on setting up a Crestron DM system. For those of you who dont know what a "DM" system is, it's Crestron Digital Media distribution system you can read more about what it is HERE .


I have stated in a previous post that "I should have this installed and completed by the end of next week." but alas, a call into Crestron this AM inquiring about shipping status of the DM system makes me alter my install schedule. I received a email stating that my shipment was going out on the 21st. Which was partially true, the DM-RMC-100-F's were shipped. But I was told that the DM system itself won't ship until Thursday the 28th. So this means I will not have the DM system "installed and completed by the end of next week" but more likely the week of the 30th and maybe even the weekend of the 4th.


The reason for the delay is that Crestron actually installs all the cards, input and output, that you specified on the order. I am installing a DM-8x8 and I was under the impression, from DM training, that all the cards are field installed by the dealer with the exception of the output cards for the DM-16x16 , and that Crestron pre-installs those cards. I guess Im wrong.


What I have done so far? Not much. I have pulled and terminated fiber to two of the five rooms so far. I am running multimode/multi-strand, 50 micron, SC/SC fiber.


So where are the pics you ask? I would have taken pics to post of the fiber install and termination but I already have the TV's backup and I really didn't think about pics until I thought of doing this post. At any rate I will have pics of the fiber, DM system being installed, configured, etc once I actually start the install.


More to come . . . . .
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
463 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
UPDATE

The Crestron DigitalMedia Install Progress - I ordered the DM system and all the cards, DM-RMC-100-F's , etc back in the beginning of October. My DM system is a fiber based system and the output cards needed, the DMCO-13, were not released yet. In fact they were released about a week ago and I was notified that the DM 8x8 has shipped and I should be receiving it tomorrow. As far as the DMCO-13's go, they are suppose to ship out Friday 12/11 or Monday 12/14. Fiber has been pulled and terminated so I am waiting on the DMCO-13's in order to get the complete system up and running.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,118 Posts
Yo, GG hows the DM system coming along???
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
463 Posts
Discussion Starter #12

Quote:
Originally Posted by stefuel /forum/post/17747324


Yo, GG hows the DM system coming along???

Here is what I was told by Crestron on Tuesday the 15th. It looks like another 1 to 2 weeks before the DMCO 13's ship. I have everything except the DMCO 13's which is holding up my project. See the email' from Crestron below. At the end of the second email it states, and I quote, "This date is tentative and subject to change."


**************

From Crestron Support to Crestron Sales


From: Deborah Calimlin

Sent: Tuesday, December 15, 2009 3:49 PM

To: Jean Fontana

Subject: DM Order#*****


Jean:

Can you please “reply all”


James would like an ETA on the shipment of his DMCO-13 from Order#******.


Thank you


Deborah Calimlin

Advanced Technical Support Group

**************


Below is the response I received from Jean at Crestron Sales support


**************

Hello Deb/James,

The current lead time on this as of today is about 1- 2 more weeks. This date is tentative and subject to change.

Thank you!

**************


HOPEFULLY, they will ship next week. If not we are looking at January for the actual install.


Also, I did get some news from Crestron regarding CEC control. The reason I was talking to Debbie from Crestrons Advanced Technical Support Group was to discuss CEC implementation. She emailed me a document, published by HDMI, LLC that has all the CEC codes needed to control HDMI devices. Also, Crestron released a firmware update for the DM-MD8x8 & 16x16 that specifically address CEC, among other things. In regards to CEC the release notes state;


CEC Device control on the following devices

DMC-HD

DMC-HD-DSP

DM-TX-100

DM-TX-100-F ( The one's I am using)

DM-TX-200


The HDMI CEC document, with all the HEX codes, is what was needed to implement CEC control with the new firmware update. Once I get the DMCO-13's I will let everyone know how it's working out.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
463 Posts
Discussion Starter #13
I received an email from Crestron that the DMCO-13's have shipped via UPS Ground and according to UPS I should be receiving them on the 29th.


With that in mind, I am looking to do the install on the week of Jan 4th.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,118 Posts
Crap, I wish you lived closer. I'd come and help for free just to see how it works. My curiousity level has peaked.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
463 Posts
Discussion Starter #15

Quote:
Originally Posted by stefuel /forum/post/17771843


Crap, I wish you lived closer. I'd come and help for free just to see how it works.

And you would be more than welcome to come by! ! !
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
463 Posts
Discussion Starter #17
So I finally receive the DMCO-13's this afternoon and started installing the DM system.


Here is a pic of one of the DMCO-13's.



There are2 Fiber outputs and 2 HDMI outputs on each card. The fiber outs will be going to the DM-RMC-100-F's and the HDMI outputs, for audio, will be going to the corresponding rooms receiver (Each room has it's own receiver). You also see 2 channel audio break out but I will not be using those. Note all equipment is centrally located in a rack so the HDMI runs to the receiver are 3ft. at the longest.


Here is a quick summary of the Crestron system I have installed. Once I have the DM system completely installed I will post details of my system including lighting, shades and HVAC, including pics and network information.


Controllers communicating via EISC

Pro2 (Audio/Video)

PAC2M (Lighting, Shades, HVAC, Whole house aromatic system ( ScentAir ))

Touch Panels

TPMC-8X (Living Room)

TPMC-4X (Master BR)

iPhone (Media Room)

iPhone (Den)
AV Switching

Neothings Avalon 8x8 (now used for Digital Audio, Coax/TOSLINK, only)

Crestron DM8x8 Fiber Based w/DM-RMC-100-F's
AV Equip.

Receivers

Denon AVR2807 (Living Room)

Denon AVR2807 (Master BR Room)

Pioneer Elite SC-05 (Den)

Pioneer Elite SC-25 (Media Room)
Displays

Pioneer Elite Pro FHD-01 (Living Room)

Pioneer Elite Pro-111-FD (Master BR)

Samsung UN46B8000 46" 1080p LED HDTV (Den)

Pioneer Elite Pro-141-FD (Media Room)
Video Sources

Kaleidescape KServer-1500 1U Server 4 1TB Drives. Wil be upgrading to 4 2TB drives this month

Kaleidescape 1080p player (Living Room)

Kaleidescape 1080p player (Master BR)

Kaleidescape 1080p mini player (Den)

Kaleidescape 1080p Mini player (Media Room)

AppleTV

Cable Box (Only 1 for the whole house)

MacPro

Wii
Audio Sources

Crestron CEN-Track w/ Am/FM/Sirius Digital Card

Kaleidescape

AppleTV
Here is a pic that I took today showing the DM-RMC-100-F installed. Right now I have the entire living room running on the DM system. Tomorrow I will have the rest of the house completed.


Here you see the DM-RMC-100-F attached to the wall along with the the fiber cable connecting to it (D & M) and power (G & 24). The DM 8x8 sends the following to each DM-RMC-100-F, one is located at every display in our house, over a single pair of, 2 strand, fiber.
1) Uncompressed HDMI 1.3 video with support for Deep Color
2) Uncompressed Multi-channel Audio (Dolby® TrueHD 7.1, Dolby Digital Plus 7.1, Dolby Digital AC3 5.1, Dolby Digital EX 5.1, DTS-HD Master Audio™ 7.1, DTS-HD High Res 7.1, DTS 5.1, DTS-ES Matrix 5.1, DTS-ES Discrete 6.1, DTS 96/24 5.1, up to 8ch PCM)
3) Ethernet (10/100)
4) RS-232 (1 Port)
5) IR (2 Ports)
6) USB (1 Port)
7) Relay (2 Ports)
8) Digital/Contact
9) Ability to embed CEC commands directly within the HDMI Channel and send to any display
10) IP Phone System - Not only that I am able to run 1-9 above, but also our entire phone system over the same fiber cable that the DM system uses.




As for the DM8x8 here is a pic of it before all the cards were installed. As you can see 2 HDMI cards are missing as well as both the output cards, the DMCO-13's




Once I have the entire house completed I will post complete details.


Thats all for now.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1 Posts
Curious if youve been able to get it to work and if so will it do a PON and POFF? Thanks for all the detail already.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
463 Posts
Discussion Starter #20

Quote:
Originally Posted by osninc /forum/post/17836159


Curious if youve been able to get it to work and if so will it do a PON and POFF? Thanks for all the detail already.

I have not tried to use PON/POF via CEC. Since my last post I have been swamped (which is a good thing).


I am hoping to post a detailed schematic that includes 2D CAD drawings of my entire system, network, A/V routing, lighting, shades, HVAC and CEC details by the end of this month.
 
1 - 20 of 95 Posts
Top