I own an LC37D42U Sharp (not the 32") and think it's a great set. It needed tweaking but once calibrated looked Sharp (pun intended). I don't own a ps3 yet or an xbox but many others that do say the set is fine for game play. Basically the 42U and the 43U are the same set, which is why I'm posting. That said, I think Panasonic makes great LCDs and Plasma sets period, and I would recommend the Panny as well. If you can get them both from Costco it seems that you are in good shape, b/c if there is an issue, you can take one back no questions asked- well maybe one or two questions but nothing you can't handle. Buy the panny and see what happens- if you are not happy, take it back. I think they're both good sets, but I hear fewer complaints about the Panasonics here...Then again, I am not paying as close attention to them b/c I am a Sharp Owner right now.