AVS Forum banner
  • Get an exclusive sneak peek into our new project. >>> Click Here

So are there NO good gaming flat panels out there?

12923 Views 229 Replies 46 Participants Last post by  thewretched22
Plasmas aren't ideal for gaming because if you game for more than 10 minutes you get burn in. Exaggeration, I know. I don't want to have to babysit my TV nor do I want to be forced to change the channel every 20 minutes.


I should dictate what I watch, not the TV.


LCDs don't have the burn in risk but I've yet to hear of a unanimous "this lcd tv has NO ghosting/blurring/artifacts/etc" LCD TV. Also, the poor blacks on LCDs hurt PQ, especially in games.


So are there any truly great gaming flat panels out there? I'm getting frusturated. I find a model in the store that looks nice, come back here, and read that "this and that" is wrong with it. And of course, the gaming on these TVs is always one of the things "wrong" with it.


The last thing I want to do is blow $2000 on a TV that ends up being worse than my 26" Sanyo SDTV (any ghosting automatically makes the TV worse; same with burn in).


Recommend me something, please! I'm getting desperate.


30-37"; ~$2000 budget although I could go a few hundred more.
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 20 of 230 Posts
I game on my plasma all the time, so do lots of other people. Burn-in isn't a problem anymore, in my opinion. The worst you'll get is temporary image retention, maybe 5 minutes or so, not a big deal.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cutwolf
So are there any truly great gaming flat panels out there? I'm getting frusturated. I find a model in the store that looks nice, come back here, and read that "this and that" is wrong with it.
You are absolutely correct. The nature of this forum (and probably all forums) today is that there is almost nothing that isn't criticized in one way or another. Threads usually turn into bitchfests. If 1000 "items" are discussed, two of them will have 99% positive comments. The rest, well... If you want proof of this, just read the thread on rainbow effects on plasmas:

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=603995


Use the threads for a general feeling about a product. Then roll the dice and take your chances. Nothing is perfect and nothing is guaranteed. Read the three new threads each week asking if it's safe to transport a plasma lying flat with requests for hand holding and guarantees that nothing will happen. What nonsense. Children want guarantees. Adults understand there is some risk in just about everything. Same with plasma burn in. No one can guarantee anything, regardless of their personal experiences.
See less See more
I set up a new gaming box in late November and to my suprise I haven't even hooked it up to my CRT computer monitor. My 50" Panny offers such a vastly improved gaming experience that I can't go back. :) Most of my gaming hours have been Civ IV and Oblivion. Both have static screen elements, esspecially Civ.


If you break the screen in for a few hundred hours before gaming I don't think there'll be an issue. After extra long sessions I ran the white scroll bar just in case, and I have no issues whatsoever with image retention. The break-in period can be done with a special video 24 hrs / day if you want, which obviously speeds up the process greatly. Even a looping powerpoint slideshow with Red, Green, and Blue screen alternating would probably do the trick.


FWIW if you're considering plasma then read about the green trails / rainbows, and take a look to see if you can see them. I haven't noticed them at all in many hours of Oblivion so I don't think everyone sees them.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Felgar
I set up a new gaming box in late November and to my suprise I haven't even hooked it up to my CRT computer monitor. My 50" Panny offers such a vastly improved gaming experience that I can't go back. :) Most of my gaming hours have been Civ IV and Oblivion. Both have static screen elements, esspecially Civ.


If you break the screen in for a few hundred hours before gaming I don't think there'll be an issue. After extra long sessions I ran the white scroll bar just in case, and I have no issues whatsoever with image retention. The break-in period can be done with a special video 24 hrs / day if you want, which obviously speeds up the process greatly. Even a looping powerpoint slideshow with Red, Green, and Blue screen alternating would probably do the trick.


FWIW if you're considering plasma then read about the green trails / rainbows, and take a look to see if you can see them. I haven't noticed them at all in many hours of Oblivion so I don't think everyone sees them.


I was looking at the TH-37PX60U in Best Buy and Circuit City and didn't see anything out of the ordinary.


Does the Th37PX60U happen to have a QAM tuner? I've heard differing reports.



What also gets me - actually I find it amusing - is how nonchalantly people talk about breaking the tv in for "a few hundred hours." Is it just me or is that an extremely long time? People act like its something that will be done in a week, but unless you use that 24/7 break in dvd (and thus not being able to watch it at all for that week), its going to take quite awhile.
See less See more
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cutwolf
I was looking at the TH-37PX60U in Best Buy and Circuit City and didn't see anything out of the ordinary.


Does the Th37PX60U happen to have a QAM tuner? I've heard differing reports.



What also gets me - actually I find it amusing - is how nonchalantly people talk about breaking the tv in for "a few hundred hours." Is it just me or is that an extremely long time? People act like its something that will be done in a week, but unless you use that 24/7 break in dvd (and thus not being able to watch it at all for that week), its going to take quite awhile.
Yeah... If the main purpose is gaming then it's best to do the 24/7 break-in thing. Or like 18 hrs/day and just watch movies or whatever else in the other 6 hours that you'd want to use it.


Dunno about the tuners. I have the whole surround sound HT setup anyways, so the consumer models never interested me much.


Also, are you running a PC or just consoles. If you're running a PC then the VGA input might be of use to you. However, the issue you'll have with smaller sizes is insufficient resolution. The ED panels have res that's too low to make it ideal for gaming (but not useless) and the HD 37" and 42" models with 1024x768 have rectangular pixels which then makes a PC image appear too wide if running 1024x768 on the PC, or else blurred if running 1366x768. IMO the 50" 1366x768 models are the ideal solution. The game can be run in Native Resolution and that's a pretty manageable res in terms of video processing power. Visual Apex (forum sponser on the top of the page) sells the 50" commercial version for not thaaat much more than your budget.
See less See more
Quote:
Originally Posted by Felgar
Yeah... If the main purpose is gaming then it's best to do the 24/7 break-in thing. Or like 18 hrs/day and just watch movies or whatever else in the other 6 hours that you'd want to use it.


Dunno about the tuners. I have the whole surround sound HT setup anyways, so the consumer models never interested me much.


Also, are you running a PC or just consoles. If you're running a PC then the VGA input might be of use to you. However, the issue you'll have with smaller sizes is insufficient resolution. The ED panels have res that's too low to make it ideal for gaming (but not useless) and the HD 37" and 42" models with 1024x768 have rectangular pixels which then makes a PC image appear too wide if running 1024x768 on the PC, or else blurred if running 1366x768. IMO the 50" 1366x768 models are the ideal solution. The game can be run in Native Resolution and that's a pretty manageable res in terms of video processing power. Visual Apex (forum sponser on the top of the page) sells the 50" commercial version for not thaaat much more than your budget.


37" is basically my max. I'm in a college campus apartment and this will be in my bedroom.


Not going to use this as PC. Only console gaming (pretty much exclusively Xbox 360).


That change anything?



Oh, side note, Panasonic just told me (on the phone) that the TH-37PX600U isn't coming state side and that the 42PX600U msrp is $2995. Not sure if that was already known or not.
See less See more
I have a Pioneer 43"plasma.


I game every single day for 2 to 5 hours.

Halo 2, Battlefield 2, GRAW, COD2, Oblivion and Live Arcade games.


I only "broke in" my plasma for like 75 hours. I couldn't take the waiting to play games on it. ZERO PROBLEMS AFTER 1 1/2 years of use.


The break in can happen in a week or less. As your watching regular tv, HDTV or DVD's (even with bars on top and bottom) that all counts as "Break-in" hours.


Pyt your tv on MTV and go to the store, go to class, etc. Justr leave the tv on.


I suggest MTV becaue they rarely use static logos. They are one of the few channels that don't use a station logo pasted to the screen all day everyday.


For me I just watched tv as usual and watched DVD's as usual. Trying to watch DVD's with a 1.78 aspect ratio (to fill the whole screen), but didn't really worry about it.


Times flies. You'll have this plasma for many years so what's 2 weeks or less of "break-in" time.

My brother in-law bought the 42" Panasonic and went straight to X360 gaming. No break in at all and he has ZERO problems. So maybe you don't even need to break it in.


BUY A PLASMA. IT IS THE BEST FOR ALL AROUND USE. SD tv, DVD's, HDTV and Gaming. No ghosting or lag with a plasma either.


You'll love it.
See less See more
I am a big fan of plasma - Burn-in is still possible but very unlikely. The manufacturers have done a lot to help prevent burn-in from occurring, so they can help get rid of that 'sales hurdle'.


I have a 32" Samsung LCD hooked up to a DVD player and Xbox360. Call of Duty 2 looks absolutely amazing! The only 'complaint' that I would have is that some rooms or in-door portions of the levels are pretty dark. Maybe the contrast has something to do with the lack of detail in those areas, or maybe the game was intended to be dark. Anyone else here played COD2 on the 360?


The latest LCDs have dramatically increased their contrast and shaved off more milliseconds from the response time.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cutwolf
What also gets me - actually I find it amusing - is how nonchalantly people talk about breaking the tv in for "a few hundred hours." Is it just me or is that an extremely long time? People act like its something that will be done in a week, but unless you use that 24/7 break in dvd (and thus not being able to watch it at all for that week), its going to take quite awhile.
Thing is, even playing a game is breaking it in. Plasma pixels loose brightness as they are used, and the loose that brightness much more quickly when they are new with the rate that they fade going down quickly from there. So by displaying anything including a game you are working a plasma past it's inital quick burning phase. Durring that phase you just have to aviod extended viewing games or TV channels with static screen elements that are high contrast, white HUDs and white station logos and such on dark sceens, as those static elements will cause the pixels they are displayed with to fade quicker than the ones around them. So you can do nothing but game on a plasma even for breaking it in and never have a problem; you'll be fine as long as you understand what can cause problems and switch to a different game as needed to aviod image retention and even people with no clue on those things tend to come out fine as modren plasmas pixels fade much slower than the older plasmas did.
See less See more
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cutwolf
Is it just me or is that an extremely long time? People act like its something that will be done in a week, but unless you use that 24/7 break in dvd (and thus not being able to watch it at all for that week), its going to take quite awhile.
I've had my new TH-42px60u for 3 weeks now and in that time it's literally never been off. I just leave it on DiscoveryHD when i'm not watching it because it rarely has a logo, and is always showing widescreen content. You don't need a break-in DVD, anything will work as long as the whole screen changes what it's showing - no bars, tickers, etc. It's really not a big deal. After i get to 1000 hours i'll probably start turning it off, but for now i'll just let it break-in while i still enjoy my wonderful TV.
Hmm...its a real shame the 37PX600u isnt coming stateside; I would love the PIP. Argh. Is Panasonic releasing a new 37" any time in the coming months or is the 60u going to be the most recent for awhile?
Have you looked at the new LG 37" LCD? I know LG doesn't get a lot of play around here, but I took a good hard look at the new 37" and 42" LC2 series just yesterday. I didn't mean to. I was there to drool over the new Samsung 1080p DLP (if only I had room for 56"!). The LG 42" was sitting next to it, along with the 42" Panny HD plasma.


Until I took a close look at the placard, I thought it was a plasma. Actually, I thought it was a damn fine plasma. :)


The 37" was just as good. Brilliant colors, bright, well saturated, and very good black performance.


I don't know what the specs are, but suggest at least taking a good hard look at that TV.
Do you have the model #? I'm going to head back to best buy today (I'll probably actually bring my 360 to hook up to the TVs) and check out some.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Revolutionary
Have you looked at the new LG 37" LCD? I know LG doesn't get a lot of play around here, but I took a good hard look at the new 37" and 42" LC2 series just yesterday. I didn't mean to. I was there to drool over the new Samsung 1080p DLP (if only I had room for 56"!). The LG 42" was sitting next to it, along with the 42" Panny HD plasma.


Until I took a close look at the placard, I thought it was a plasma. Actually, I thought it was a damn fine plasma. :)


The 37" was just as good. Brilliant colors, bright, well saturated, and very good black performance.


I don't know what the specs are, but suggest at least taking a good hard look at that TV.
Don't even go NEAR the LG. It's awful.
See less See more
LOL......again Yoda1, I ask why is somebody who has so many problems with displays, giving display advise? ;)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Yoda1
Don't even go NEAR the LG. It's awful.
I will respectfully disagree. I will also suggest that absolute conclusions that add up to nothing more than your individual opinion, which is quite famously subject to more than a handful of "idiosyncrasies," aren't at all helpful to someone who is trying to make up their own mind.


Further, be sure you've seen the new LGs, the 42LC2D and 37LC2D. I was impressed, (and I know what to look for).
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cutwolf
Hmm...its a real shame the 37PX600u isnt coming stateside; I would love the PIP. Argh. Is Panasonic releasing a new 37" any time in the coming months or is the 60u going to be the most recent for awhile?
Anyone know?
Its really a matter of preference. If your going to something over 40" then go Plasma. But if you are under that then id go for lcd. LCD tvs don't have alot of the problems you listed as long as you get a quality panel. once again ill be posting my impressions of the Samsung for you early next week.
I really want to wait for the LN-S3296D but that one hasn't even been officially announced and I want a TV by mid-August.



As a side note, what LCD TV model (by any company) is generally considered the highest performance LCD?
1 - 20 of 230 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top