From the Boston Globe:
----
ON TV
The beauty of Edie Falco: Her stellar portrayal of Carmela Soprano is complex, subtle
By Matthew Gilbert, Globe Staff | June 3, 2004
In the most recent episode of "The Sopranos," Carmela Soprano sold her soul for a $600,000 parcel of land. But it wasn't a despicable move. It was an awesomely executed power play, in which she reminded herself -- and viewers -- of her great worth to Tony. It was a financial and emotional triumph, even more empowering than the time she assured Meadow's college prospects with an innocent ricotta pie. And it was solid evidence that Carmela, with a temper as sharp as her fingernails, will never be left to crawl with the worms, like Adriana.
If "The Sopranos" has psychological arcs that reach back to the first episode, one of them is Carmela's coming into consciousness. Slowly, she has been changing from a spoiled wife in blissful denial into a knowing woman who has to fight for herself. As her children have defected, leaving her without easy leverage over Tony, she has been forced into ever more deliberate action to protect her way of life. She has had to smarten up, when playing dumb like other mafia women is a whole lot easier.And the peeling away of Carmela's denial is only one of the beauties of Edie Falco's work in her years on HBO's "The Sopranos," which wraps its fifth season on Sunday night at 9. Falco has made her mafia wife into a multilayered woman ping-ponging between avoidance and painful awareness, between the beige heaven of her bourgeois manse and the moments when her moral compass is pointing to hell. Carmela could easily have become a purely kitschy creation, easy to mock with her hairsprayed coifs and her complaining New Jersey accent. See Michelle Pfeiffer and Mercedes Ruehl in "Married to the Mob." But Falco has protected her brassy character from comic reduction, turning Mrs. Soprano into not only the heroine of "The Sopranos" but pop culture's most formidable mob spouse.
Indeed, Edie Falco is the best dramatic actress on TV -- right now, and possibly ever. While there have been many classic comic actresses on TV over the decades, from Carol Burnett and Jean Stapleton to Mary Tyler Moore and Julia Louis-Dreyfus, there have been only a handful of great serious turns. Yes, Sada Thompson was a fount of strength and love on "Family"; cast members on all of the Zwick-Herskovitz series (including "thirtysomething" and "Once and Again") deserve note; each of the leads on "Six Feet Under" is extraordinary; and some would argue that Tyne Daly has brought unequaled emotional intensity to "Judging Amy."
But TV drama series have tended to be about ongoing narrative, plot evolution, and ensemble interaction, rather than individual performances that are richly layered each week. The Joan Collinses and Richard Thomases of TV history are entertaining, and sometimes captivating, but they're usually not models of acting chops.
Falco, on the other hand, delivers movie-level performances each time the writers hand her a scene. Earlier this season, for example, she provided a delicately subdued climax to an episode called "Unidentified Black Males," during which Carmela learned that Tony had tainted all the divorce lawyers within reach. At the end of the hour, Carmela is talking to Meadow on the phone while watching Tony floating in the backyard pool. When Meadow says she's engaged, we see a flood of feelings cross Carmela's face -- envy of her daughter's innocence, anger about her own marital problems, grief over the lost ideals of marriage. It's an exquisitely quiet storm, as Falco plays these emotions, and others, all at once, making it clear that Carmela's tears are not joyful.
Falco can also let loose like few others on the small screen, as she proved in last season's explosive finale, when she laid into Tony for his infidelity and kicked him out of the house. Those were disturbing scenes, as visceral as many of the show's mob fights, and they brought her a third Emmy for best dramatic actress. Carmela frequently operates on only a half-conscious level, such as when she seduced AJ's school counselor into her service. But when she emerges into full-blown comprehension, Falco makes her into a force to be reckoned with. Who can forget the dressing down of Father Phil in season one, when Carmela took him to task for using spiritually needy women for food and company? Or her insistence that Tony donate $50,000 to Columbia, not long after a confrontational therapist tells her about Tony's business, "One thing you can never say -- that you haven't been told."
Falco's achievement is more impressive when you realize that she's working among a cast of powerful actresses. The memorable women on "The Sopranos" have included Nancy Marchand's murderous Livia, Annabella Sciorra's self-annihilating Gloria, Aida Turturro's twisted Janice, and Drea de Matteo's Adriana, so breakable and so lost. Even the secondary women on the show are vivid -- Katherine Narducci's Charmaine Bucco, for instance, and Sharon Angela's Rosalie Aprile, who brings irresistible inflections to lines such as "At least Judas didn't go into any Apostle Protection Program." This season, guest star Polly Bergen delivered a standout turn as Fran Felstein, Tony's father's onetime mistress. She was a pathetic, self-absorbed creature.
But Falco has topped all of them with her consistency and her shadings. She has been the perfect acting partner for James Gandolfini, as they push each other into ever-darker areas. Truly, it's hard to imagine "The Sopranos," and TV in general, being quite as compelling without her.