NiteWrider,
I have tried the Channel Master Titan for UHF only (forgot the number but I think it is the UHF version of yours), and the Winegard AP4800.
The Channel Master looks like it has better specs, but the Winegard worked better for me. No idea why.
But you can't expect a big improvement when you start with an already good preamp and some people have tried both and found the Channel Master preamp better. You may have to try something else to improve the signal, like going higher, relocating, better antenna, etc.