AVS Forum banner

41 - 60 of 155 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
351 Posts
I liked it. Will continue to watch. With Geoff Johns lurking about (it his baby) this may be a cut above Flash and the other DC related shows. Think its stupid she's on parallel earth.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,450 Posts
No. The longer one ends the same as the broadcast one.
If you've watched both, do you know what was taken out of the broadcast version?

Also, does anyone know if Stargirl will come to HBO Max when it launches? Maybe I can wait until then to watch it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,099 Posts
Also, does anyone know if Stargirl will come to HBO Max when it launches? Maybe I can wait until then to watch it.
I don't think it will. It airs on DC Universe and then next-day airings on CW. That likely means that CW has Season 1 streaming rights through the entire first season. If it did show up on HBO Max it would be after that streaming window closed, which is normally right before Season 2 would begin to air.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zookster

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,099 Posts
I'll take angst and preachy any day over dull if not terrible on many levels (i.e., Batwoman).
Warner and Berlanti agreed with you. Ruby Rose is out and a recast of the role for Season 2.

Enjoyed the first episode of Stargirl. 15 minutes into the show and you felt like they got the casting right. The exact opposite of the first episode and 15 minutes of Batwoman.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26,500 Posts
Since my DVR refused to record it, I caught the first episode tonight on the CW app, with really crummy picture quality and 2.0 audio. The episode was better than I expected. The main girl is well cast and very appealing. I like the staff.

The only thing I didn't understand, that I assume was the same in the longer version, is how Pat didn't know Courtney was Starman's daughter. The mom did say Starman visited his daughter only once a year, so maybe that was just a part of his life he kept secret from his sidekick. It didn't seem like Pat was lying to cover up the fact he knew all along and didn't say anything. He genuinely seemed surprised.
Pat was very insistent that Starman was not her father. Maybe he's wrong, maybe Starman kept it a secret, or maybe he's right and her father will turn out to be someone else either in the JSA or perhaps a villain. Having her be Starman's daughter seems a little too convenient and formulaic.

I don't think it will. It airs on DC Universe and then next-day airings on CW. That likely means that CW has Season 1 streaming rights through the entire first season. If it did show up on HBO Max it would be after that streaming window closed, which is normally right before Season 2 would begin to air.
Don't confuse HBO Max with the other existing HBO streaming services. HBO Max is the new consolidated Warner Bros. subscription portal. It's going to have a lot of overlap with both HBO and DC Universe. In fact, the long-term fate of DC Universe is kind of up in the air at the moment. Future DC Comics series such as Green Lantern and Justice League Dark are being planned to go straight to HBO Max.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WilliamR

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,017 Posts
First show (CW) was ok. The initial fight was fairly impossible to follow who was who and why they were fighting. At some point, Pat (what a bad character name) said they died saving the world which must be a lie because it surely looked like the heroes got wiped out.

Courtney is a loser the first day of school? Right. Pretty perky blonde, she would have guys falling over her. Well, she only had to endure one day at the loser's table and immediately there is an Edward Cullen type at the table and then the stereotypical jock a-hole.

Then it just happens that in nowhere's Nebraska, that's where the villain who just seems to be a rich guy hangs out. Maybe he wasn't after the world and just wanted to do insider trading in peace. Who knows.

Anyhow, I'll watch a few more. Frankly this was about every cliche in the book. Luke Wilson is good but I would have preferred Bob Odenkirk.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
8,996 Posts
Pat was very insistent that Starman was not her father. Maybe he's wrong, maybe Starman kept it a secret, or maybe he's right and her father will turn out to be someone else either in the JSA or perhaps a villain. Having her be Starman's daughter seems a little too convenient and formulaic.
Her being Starman's daughter is the reason the staff will work with her. Pat was left in the dark about Starman's family.
 

·
Premium Member
Bedroom: 50-in 1080p LCD, XG1v4 (Ultra HD DVR for Comcast), BD Player; Office: 32-in LCD, etc.
Joined
·
2,387 Posts
I set the first episode to record from The CW tonight, but my DVR apparently decided not to bother. Probably not a good sign.

Yes. I tried to do a "record series" on the Comcast X1 DVR but it didn't select the premiere episode, so I went back and told it to record the episode, and it did that.


I thought the premiere episode looked promising, so I am keeping the "record series" request in place for at least another week.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,099 Posts
Don't confuse HBO Max with the other existing HBO streaming services. HBO Max is the new consolidated Warner Bros. subscription portal. It's going to have a lot of overlap with both HBO and DC Universe. In fact, the long-term fate of DC Universe is kind of up in the air at the moment. Future DC Comics series such as Green Lantern and Justice League Dark are being planned to go straight to HBO Max.
I don't thing anyone was confusing the difference between HBO, HBO Max and DC Universe. The question being answered was whether or not Stargirl episodes would be available on HBO Max at launch. Since the CW has next-day streaming rights after it airs on DC Universe it will likely be available on those two platforms through the season.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26,500 Posts
I don't thing anyone was confusing the difference between HBO, HBO Max and DC Universe. The question being answered was whether or not Stargirl episodes would be available on HBO Max at launch. Since the CW has next-day streaming rights after it airs on DC Universe it will likely be available on those two platforms through the season.
I'm not sure it's so clear. HBO Max will stream other DC Universe originals. Since all three platforms are owned by Warner Bros (or at least half-owned in the case of The CW), I think there's a fairly good chance the company will put Stargirl on all of them to boost exposure (both of the show and of HBO Max) as much as possible.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26,500 Posts
First show (CW) was ok. The initial fight was fairly impossible to follow who was who and why they were fighting. At some point, Pat (what a bad character name) said they died saving the world which must be a lie because it surely looked like the heroes got wiped out.

Courtney is a loser the first day of school? Right. Pretty perky blonde, she would have guys falling over her. Well, she only had to endure one day at the loser's table and immediately there is an Edward Cullen type at the table and then the stereotypical jock a-hole.

Then it just happens that in nowhere's Nebraska, that's where the villain who just seems to be a rich guy hangs out. Maybe he wasn't after the world and just wanted to do insider trading in peace. Who knows.

Anyhow, I'll watch a few more. Frankly this was about every cliche in the book. Luke Wilson is good but I would have preferred Bob Odenkirk.
All legit criticisms. I also found it ridiculous that no one saw her flying around through the town. I get that this is supposed to be a small town where everything is dead after 9pm, but surely there must have been somebody around. Nevertheless, I still enjoyed it.

I expect that we'll eventually learn that this small town in nowhere Nebraska is secretly an important location where magic powers converge or something. Pat was evasive when asked what he was doing in Nebraska when he met Courtney's mother. There also has to be a reason he insisted the family move there from Los Angeles. The place will undoubtedly turn out to be special.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
14,371 Posts
Discussion Starter #55
From HOTP thread:

‘The Voice’ Finale Tops Quiet Tuesday; ‘DC’s Stargirl’ Debut Ratings Solid
By Dino-Ray Ramos, Deadline.com - May 20, 2020

The Voice ended its season Tuesday with a virtual finale that delivered a 0.9 in the adults 18-49 demographic and 7.43 million viewers who tuned in as Kelly Clarkson, John Legend, Blake Shelton and Nick Jonas crowned the winner (no spoilers here) virtually for the reality singing competition’s 18th cycle.

The finale, which aired from 9-11 PM, dipped a tenth from Monday’s part one to match a season low. It also was down two tenths from last spring’s finale. Still, NBC swept the night in the demo and viewers.

The CW meanwhile introduced a new hero into its comic book universe with DC’s Stargirl (0.3, 1.21M), down and tenth from The Flash finale a week ago in the time slot but beating it in viewers. The freshman series was followed by DC’s Legends of Tomorrow (0.2, 803,000), which held steady.

ABC aired the special After the Dance (0.4, 2.63M) with ESPN host and NBA commentator Stephen A. Smith. The one-hour primetime special featured NBA legends as they discussed ESPN’s hit Michael Jordan docuseries The Last Dance. The network followed it with another special, the two-hour The Story of Soaps (0.3, 2.03M), which put the spotlight on the impact of soap operas.

Elsewhere it was fairly quiet, with CBS airing reruns of NCIS, FBI and FBI: Most Wanted and Fox a recap of The Masked Singer (0.9, 4.17M) and a repeat of 24 Hours to Hell and Back.

https://deadline.com/2020/05/the-voi...ut-1202939430/
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,099 Posts
I'm not sure it's so clear. HBO Max will stream other DC Universe originals. Since all three platforms are owned by Warner Bros (or at least half-owned in the case of The CW), I think there's a fairly good chance the company will put Stargirl on all of them to boost exposure (both of the show and of HBO Max) as much as possible.
Fair enough. But the question was AT LAUNCH of HBO Max would Stargirl episodes be immediately available. I can see them being available on HBO Max after their initial streaming runs on DC Universe and the CW. I would assume CW paid for next-day streaming rights to boost their viewership. Putting them the next-day on HBO Max as well would be counter productive.

I guess we will all know in about 6 days time!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,450 Posts
Pat was evasive when asked what he was doing in Nebraska when he met Courtney's mother. There also has to be a reason he insisted the family move there from Los Angeles. The place will undoubtedly turn out to be special.
Early on Pat says they are moving there because Courtney's mom was offered a job at The American Dream, which is somehow behind the reason Courtney's new high school no longer has gymnastics (all the school's programs were recalibrated for optimal participation). I'm sure the job offer will turn out to be a ruse either by Pat or other forces at play to bring the Starman family back to Blue Valley.

I didn't have a problem with how Courtney was treated during her first lunch at the new school. It's almost a trope how teenagers are cliquish and wary of newcomers (no matter how attractive), and the "mean girls" at the school would be jealous of her. I'm sure Courtney will get a lot of crap while trying out to be a cheerleader, and one of the more popular jocks will go behind his girlfriend's back to hit on her as soon as the opportunity arises (more tropes).
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
8,996 Posts
I'm sure Courtney will get a lot of crap while trying out to be a cheerleader.
She said that cheerleading was not her thing. Now that she has the staff, cheerleading is not on her list.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26,500 Posts
Fair enough. But the question was AT LAUNCH of HBO Max would Stargirl episodes be immediately available. I can see them being available on HBO Max after their initial streaming runs on DC Universe and the CW. I would assume CW paid for next-day streaming rights to boost their viewership. Putting them the next-day on HBO Max as well would be counter productive.

I guess we will all know in about 6 days time!
I don't think it's clear yet what will be available or when. For example, it is known that Doom Patrol season 2 will premiere on both DC Universe and HBO Max on the same day. Although Warner Bros. is being very selective in the wording of its official statements, it seems like the plan is to eventually phase out DC Universe and fold it entirely into HBO Max.

HBO Max will also stream the CW's Batwoman. Not sure about the other CW shows yet.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,099 Posts
I don't think it's clear yet what will be available or when. For example, it is known that Doom Patrol season 2 will premiere on both DC Universe and HBO Max on the same day. Although Warner Bros. is being very selective in the wording of its official statements, it seems like the plan is to eventually phase out DC Universe and fold it entirely into HBO Max.

HBO Max will also stream the CW's Batwoman. Not sure about the other CW shows yet.
The CW and Netflix streaming deal expired in the Spring of 2019. Past shows (The Flash, Supergirl, Legends, Arrow, The 100, etc.) remain under the previous agreement and full seasons are available on Netflix 8 days after the final episode of a season airs.

Looks like new Fall 2019-2020 CW shows KATY KEENE and BATWOMAN will go to HBO Max and will be available 30 days before the start of the next season. NANCY DREW is going to CBS ALL ACCESS.

The CW Secures Full In-Season Streaming Rights To New Series
https://deadline.com/2019/08/the-cw-full-in-season-streaming-rights-new-series-tca-batwoman-katy-keene-nancy-drew-1202660754/
 
  • Like
Reactions: Josh Z
41 - 60 of 155 Posts
Top