AVS Forum banner
  • Get an exclusive sneak peek into our new project. >>> Click Here

Surround Sound for Headphones?

532 Views 5 Replies 4 Participants Last post by  ATB
Greetings! I'm interested in getting a little more out of my DVDs and my Xbox 360, but the wife isn't thrilled about any sort of surround sound speakers, so I'm going for headphones. I don't currently have any sort of audio receiver, so what I was thinking of doing is getting a receiver that supports Dolby Headphone, then getting a good pair of headphones and using those; if at a later point the wife changes her mind then I can add on a set of speakers, but right now I'm just going to be using the headphones with this.


I took a look at receivers and the Harmon-Kardon AV240 seems like a good choice within my budget for Dolby Headphone. Based on a friend's recommendation I'm thinking of going with the Sennheiser HD595s for headphones. Have you guys used either of these pieces of equipment? What do you think of them?


I really appreciate any advice you guys have to offer. Thanks!
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nijhazer
Greetings! I'm interested in getting a little more out of my DVDs and my Xbox 360, but the wife isn't thrilled about any sort of surround sound speakers, so I'm going for headphones. I don't currently have any sort of audio receiver, so what I was thinking of doing is getting a receiver that supports Dolby Headphone, then getting a good pair of headphones and using those; if at a later point the wife changes her mind then I can add on a set of speakers, but right now I'm just going to be using the headphones with this.


I took a look at receivers and the Harmon-Kardon AV240 seems like a good choice within my budget for Dolby Headphone. Based on a friend's recommendation I'm thinking of going with the Sennheiser HD595s for headphones. Have you guys used either of these pieces of equipment? What do you think of them?


I really appreciate any advice you guys have to offer. Thanks!
For headphone your better off doing research here www.headfi.com


I have the Sennheiser HD600 and love them. I also have the AKG 701's but they are a lot more money. I highly recommend the HD 600's. You'll be amazed by them.

Sry I don't know anything about the receiver. I have a Denon with Dolby Headphone, and it's a nice feature.


I just looked that receiver up. I don't know what your paying for it, but it shows a price of $599. You need to do some research on the forum I gave you. I think you'd be better purchasing a headphone amp, and connecting it to your DVD player. An amp with crossfeed maybe.


For headphones check www.headphone.com
See less See more
This new JVC SU-DH1 unit lists for $130, and does Dolby Headphone:

http://gizmodo.com/gadgets/gadgets/j...ter-147018.php
Thanks very much for the suggestions. On getting a headphone amp, I'm planning to get the receiver because that will allow me to add a full-blown speaker system later if I'm able to and also because I can route all my equipment into that; the aforementioned Xbox 360, for example. I found the HK receiver for $320 from a reputable dealer, which is within my budget. I guess I was looking primarily for some feedback from folks who use Dolby Headphone with their home theater, and also any feedback on this particular receiver.
By the way, Roger, thanks so much for the heads-up on that JVC unit-- now I can have Dolby Headphone with any receiver I want! It's out of stock everywhere at the moment but I can wait.
I just had one of these come in and had a chance to try them out. My key criteria in using this is for gaming on an Xbox.


Taking it out of the box, it was readily apparent that this was well-built and gave me confidence that if I drop it, it won't break on me. It's about the size of my blackberry, perhaps a little more square and seems to weigh roughly the same with batteries installed.


The most difficult part for me was in finding the optical-mini cable required for the digital input on this unit. I thought this would be easy to find, but for some reason just about all of the places convenient (Compusa, Best Buy, Circuit City, etc) to me did not carry such a cable. I ended up finding one at the Apple store (used to connect the Airport Express to a receiver).


Set up was easy...popped the included AA batteries into the unit, plugged in the cable from the Xbox's optical output, plugged in headphones (Sony MDR-V7506) and off I went.


I did do an A/B test with the sound out of this unit vs the headphone output from my TV (which uses the analog L/R output from the Xbox). What a difference the Dolby Headphone makes!


- Without this unit: I play Halo 2 quite a bit and recently started using headphones in order to try to better localize where the action was coming from etc. The basic analog output coming from the Xbox was ok at distinguishing between right and left, but that's about it. I think the best way to describe it is that everything was in the plane between my ears...not in 'front' of me at all. A grenade exploding 15 feet in forward of me at a 45 degree angle to the right (1 - 2 o'clock), sounded the same as one exploding directly to my right (3 o'clock). Any advantage I had in terms of being able to distinguish where noises came was lost by the lack of this front/back dimension. I noticed that playing this was tiring and somewhat frustrating as I was listening for something that wasn't there.


- With this unit: I fired up Halo 2 on the Xbox and just ran around on the Ivory Tower map to see how it sounded. I went to the base of the elevator and turned the master chief around, and I was blown away by how the headphones rendered surround sound. The elevator was behind me, making the same whooshing, mechanical noise. Physically I know there are no additional speakers than the two on my headphones, but holy cow this was nice. I toss a grenade, and turn as the grenade explodes...sure enough the sound of that explosion is to a T exactly where I think it should be based on the direction I'm facing. Very cool.


I played H2 for several hours using this unit. After about 2-3 hours, the batteries that came with the unit died. The product sheet says that alkaline batteries should last 10 hours, manganese 2-3 hours. I'm guessing the ones that came with the unit were manganese. Unfortunately it happened mid-game, without warning. The way this manifested itself is that the sound went away completely (no dimming, no beeps of warning) - then it went into a weird cycle of powering off and on. For say 10 seconds at a time I had sound, at full volume, and then it would die for 10-15 seconds, repeating this for 5-10 minutes while I finished the game I was in. The next day I bought a set of rechargeable AA (2500 mAh) batteries and a charger to plug into the wall next to the Xbox. I used the setup again last night with freshly charged batteries, played for 4-5 hours with no problems.


So far I am very pleased with this unit - I've already caught a couple of people sneaking up on me in H2 that I know would have taken me down with a melee to the back of the head without me hearing a thing before.
See less See more
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top