AVS Forum banner
1 - 20 of 54 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
27,347 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Watched this last night.


Great story told in a compelling manner.


Great picture for the most part with some stylized camera work (blown out whites, long black outs). Big scope picture (CIH folks will live this).


Fabulous DTS MA 5.1 soundtrack!! Incredibly dynamic, big bass extension and great surround cues. Reference worthy.


Great account of the incredibly devastating tsunami on an ordinary family.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
488 Posts
Watched this last nite on my (140") scope screen as well. The tsunami and subsequent destruction sequences are brilliantly realized, with minimal implementation of CGI. Altho LFE activity is mostly confined to the tsunami sequence, it's a consistently highly-immersive soundtrack. The 2.35 frame is exploited to maximum effect, and is essential in conveying the scope (pun intended) of the story and events. Excellent disc, and its content infinitely more memorable than the vast majority of Hollywood fare these days...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
17,029 Posts
Great movie and amazing story.


Solid PQ.


AQ was very good, but nothing demo worthy. Solid LFE extension and good surround work, but not reference IMO.


Great rental. Not a movie that has repeat value for me, but it was an excellent watch.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
6,500 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by ambientcafe  /t/1470066/the-impossible#post_23254046


The tsunami and subsequent destruction sequences are brilliantly realized, with minimal implementation of CGI. Although LFE activity is mostly confined to the tsunami sequence, it's a consistently highly-immersive soundtrack.

I agree, as was the flash-back sequence later in the film. Perhaps I listened louder than most but my HT room was shaking. As close as one can come to imagining the horrific nature of this catastrophe.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
24,365 Posts
Watched this last night, fantastic film. Its amazing what that family had to go through. The tsunami was unreal best one I've seen in a film and the LFE that carried it was powerful. This one will be added to my collection.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
560 Posts
i usually like these kinds of films but with the exception of the tsunami scene which was extremely well done, i was distracted by the video which seemed too soft and disappointed in the rest of the audio. It's an amazing story but overall disappointed in the rest of it. I bought it d/t reviews but doubt I'll watch it again.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,280 Posts
I wish I could say I liked this movie a lot, but I just didn't. I didn't like the racism in the casting of the family or the way that they made the story seem far too Hollywoodish and many things seemed obviously over dramatized. Some things I liked a lot, such as the tsunami scene. But overall, I couldn't tell anyone to watch this for any reason beyond that. It's a bit like how I only recommend that anyone ever watch Knowing to look at Rose Byrne and the absolutely amazing crash scene,
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
27,347 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by lordcloud  /t/1470066/the-impossible#post_23681918


I wish I could say I liked this movie a lot, but I just didn't. I didn't like the racism in the casting of the family or the way that they made the story seem far too Hollywoodish and many things seemed obviously over dramatized. Some things I liked a lot, such as the tsunami scene. But overall, I couldn't tell anyone to watch this for any reason beyond that. It's a bit like how I only recommend that anyone ever watch Knowing to look at Rose Byrne and the absolutely amazing crash scene,

Racism in the casting of the family? What?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
572 Posts
Likely referring to the family the story was based on being Spanish and not how they are cast for the move. Rather silly thing to complain about, but some people like to see racism everywhere, just read any movie's imdb forum.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,771 Posts
I am so completely SICK of the accusations of racism over every aspect of life. This film was made by English speaking Westerners. It needed to make money in English language territories and therefore it needed an English language speaking cast that would appeal to the widest possible audience.


The two leads are big stars! Both have won more awards than you can shake a stick at!


No distributor would be interested in this film were it to star unknown actors who speak Spanish.


Of course people on IMDB would accuse me of being racist for pointing all of this out.



I'll say it again. This was an incredible film. The only film I have seen this year that comes close is THE INTOUCHABLES (a film that was in French and therefore could not get a wide release in the United States, proving the people who made The Impossible were looking out for their investors).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Morpheo

·
Registered
Joined
·
27,347 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kevin M. Dean  /t/1470066/the-impossible#post_23684752


Likely referring to the family the story was based on being Spanish and not how they are cast for the move. Rather silly thing to complain about, but some people like to see racism everywhere, just read any movie's imdb forum.


You're right. I found an article on this accusation on Slate.com.... about the only one on the internet - so, it's of course, a very minority, hard core opinion. Slate is a liberal rag and ironically, they are the biggest racists as they are the first to invoke such in any harmless scenario. Hmm.. I guess they should've cast Javier Bardham and Penelope Cruz... then the film would've shed its 'racist' look
.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
241 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt_Stevens  /t/1470066/the-impossible#post_23684784


This film was made by English speaking Westerners. It needed to make money in English language territories and therefore it needed an English language speaking cast that would appeal to the widest possible audience.


No distributor would be interested in this film were it to star unknown actors who speak Spanish.


...The only film I have seen this year that comes close is THE INTOUCHABLES (a film that was in French and therefore could not get a wide release in the United States, proving the people who made The Impossible were looking out for their investors).

This movie tanked in the US, even with English speaking white people filling in the for the Spanish family. If they wanted it to appeal to the widest possible audience they should have put some robots in it or something.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
24,365 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt_Stevens  /t/1470066/the-impossible#post_23684784


I am so completely SICK of the accusations of racism over every aspect of life. This film was made by English speaking Westerners. It needed to make money in English language territories and therefore it needed an English language speaking cast that would appeal to the widest possible audience.


The two leads are big stars! Both have won more awards than you can shake a stick at!


No distributor would be interested in this film were it to star unknown actors who speak Spanish.


Of course people on IMDB would accuse me of being racist for pointing all of this out.



I'll say it again. This was an incredible film. The only film I have seen this year that comes close is THE INTOUCHABLES (a film that was in French and therefore could not get a wide release in the United States, proving the people who made The Impossible were looking out for their investors).

+1
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,828 Posts
Did anyone accuse Stephen Frears of racism when he made Dangerous Liaisons?
Or that other hack Milos Forman when he made austrians speak english in Amadeus?



I agree with Matt, it's preposterous to see racism in The Impossible.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,573 Posts
^^^Wasn't really looking for it within the movie itself, per se. I will say it did not stand out to me if it was there, but the observation had been made by others, and Matt_Stevens made clear with his post that he believes there was a racist motivation for converting the original victims to white ethnicity and English speaking. So we have seen racism in play in the making of the movie, versus within the movie itself. This can hardly be denied, unless you might think it was a total random accident that two white folk got paired to represent a fairly typical cultural model of same. I personally don't think that, and agree completely with Matt_Stevens that the filmmakers made and executed a racist judgment, probably on the basis of the assumed economics of their project.


There would be a far better argument for presupposing the absence of racism were the two main protagonists, husband and wife, of two distinct racial types, or possibly even the same race as the original victims -- in the latter case, I can't really imagine it would have arisen as a question -- would be assumed the filmmakers were just adhering to accuracy, and in the former case, two distinct racial types, it really might tend to look as though race were a non-consideration for casting. Trouble is, that if the couple were two different races, then it starts to introduce extraneous considerations into the story to bring the audience along.... so racism won the day, and we get two Anglo protagonists.


BTW, the casting of all the children was racist as well. Nothing wrong with that of course -- we pretty much expect to see recognizably white kids as the progeny of white parents, but they were chosen to exclusion of other actors, because they did look white, and inasmuch as a very clear racial bias was brought to bear in their casting, it reflects racism. Of course. As I say, fairly benign racism, but clearly at work here, at least to me and Matt_Stevens, unless I misinterpret what he wrote.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,507 Posts
Racists? In Hollywood!? You have got to be joking.


But seriously, you guys are reaching with this whole racism thing. Big names such as Naomi Watts and Ewan McGregor speak volumes when it comes to getting a relatively low budget movie made. Obviously, some liberties have to be taken, and obviously the film still needs to make money, so a small, non-pivotal part of the script was changed. It still changes nothing of the overall story and has any effect on the impact of the situation.


But hey, never mind the fact that nearly the entire crew behind this movie were from Spain.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,573 Posts

Quote:
Originally Posted by Big Brad  /t/1470066/the-impossible#post_23689167


Racists? In Hollywood!? You have got to be joking.


But seriously, you guys are reaching with this whole racism thing. Big names such as Naomi Watts and Ewan McGregor speak volumes when it comes to getting a relatively low budget movie made. Obviously, some liberties have to be taken, and obviously the film still needs to make money, so a small, non-pivotal part of the script was changed. It still changes nothing of the overall story and has any effect on the impact of the situation.


But hey, never mind the fact that nearly the entire crew behind this movie were from Spain.
Well, on the one hand you say it is reaching, on the other hand you say this: "Obviously, some liberties have to be taken, and obviously the film still needs to make money, so a small, non-pivotal part of the script was changed." So, exactly what is so obvious here? You very much seem to be suggesting that it is obvious to one and all that the race of the original victims had to be altered. You seem to link this "self-evident verity" to the making of money. This suggests that the filmmakers thought the widest appreciation for their project would be diminished if the race of the actors matched that of the original victims of this tragedy, does it not? They anticipated a widespread racially biased disinterest would result directly in underdeveloped revenues, so executed a preemptive racist casting alteration to avert it.


They might have been quite right in this assessment, we'll never know I'm sure, because they chose for us. It might be pointed out here that there are well-known Spanish actors who have done quite well in America: Antonio Banderas, Penélope Cruz, and Javier Bardem among them, but it can also very well be noted that casting the whole native population was entirely racist in nature as well. Of course the race of the native population was critical to maintaining verisimilitude -- that race of people generally comprise the population of those regions of the world, so it would be foolish and confusing in that case NOT to exercise racist bias -- you must be a certain race to play our native population.


Of course I don't use the term "racist" to connote anything necessarily pejorative -- although it frequently gets used that way -- it is not the same as "bigoted", at least in my use -- just implies that race is/was the determinant in some consideration -- such as identifying yourself as Anglo, or what have you, is a racist comment.
 
1 - 20 of 54 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top