Joined
·
4,693 Posts
I remember that carnival scene quite well in It Chapter Two. Agreed it's one spectacular showcase for HDR material.
The New PQ Tier thread for Blu-Ray - Discussion
26561 - 26580 of 26587 Posts
Joined
·
499 Posts
Child’s Play (1988)
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
Joined
·
499 Posts
The Mummy’s Hand
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
The Mummy’s Tomb
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
The Mummy’s Ghost
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
The Mummy’s Curse
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
American Werewolf in London, An (Arrow)
recommendation: Tier 1.25*
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
The Mummy’s Tomb
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
The Mummy’s Ghost
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
The Mummy’s Curse
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
American Werewolf in London, An (Arrow)
recommendation: Tier 1.25*
Joined
·
499 Posts
^^
I do what I can 😁
Them!
recommendation: Tier 3.5*
Abbott and Costello Meet the Mummy
recommendation: Tier 3.25*
Jaws 2
recommendation: Tier 3.5*
Jaws 3
recommendation: Tier 4.5*
Poor clarity throughout and chunky grain really hinder this film. Most of the underwater 3D effects like a severed arm and diver submersible are barely watchable.
Jaws: The Revenge
recommendation: Tier 3.5*
I do what I can 😁
Them!
recommendation: Tier 3.5*
Abbott and Costello Meet the Mummy
recommendation: Tier 3.25*
Jaws 2
recommendation: Tier 3.5*
Jaws 3
recommendation: Tier 4.5*
Poor clarity throughout and chunky grain really hinder this film. Most of the underwater 3D effects like a severed arm and diver submersible are barely watchable.
Jaws: The Revenge
recommendation: Tier 3.5*
Joined
·
499 Posts
Tarantula (Shout Factory)
recommendation: Tier 4.0*
Le Petit Soldat (Criterion)
recommendation: Tier 4.0*
Beetlejuice (UHD)
recommendation: Tier 1.25*
Goonies, The (UHD)
recommendation: Tier 1.25*
recommendation: Tier 4.0*
Le Petit Soldat (Criterion)
recommendation: Tier 4.0*
Beetlejuice (UHD)
recommendation: Tier 1.25*
Goonies, The (UHD)
recommendation: Tier 1.25*
Joined
·
6,901 Posts
I am "patiently" waiting for its release. There is NO WAY I'm going to buy the "Columbia Classics Set" when I could care less about 3 or 4 of the movies included in that set.
Tomorrow I will be receiving my 4K/UHD "Back to the Future Ultimate Trilogy" set and needless to say, I'm very excited! I don't even own a copy of any of the previous releases so it's about time I get these and this will be the "Ultimate Set."
Joined
·
6,901 Posts
Back to the Future (UHD)
I went into this expecting the PQ to land this release in Tier Gold and that's exactly where it belongs! It did show its age at times, with SOFTNESS resulting in a LACK OF DETAILS and DEPTH, but overall I was thoroughly impressed with the CLARITY, DETAILS, COLORS and BLACK LEVELS. If you're a fan of this Franchise it may never look better and you WILL be satisfied. Though it does merit this coveted tier, its less-than-stellar moments must, of necessity, bring it down to the bottom.
AQ-wise, the Dolby Atmos mix was impressive in a few scenes, but the majority of the film was focused on the front stage.
Tier Recommendation: 1.75*
I went into this expecting the PQ to land this release in Tier Gold and that's exactly where it belongs! It did show its age at times, with SOFTNESS resulting in a LACK OF DETAILS and DEPTH, but overall I was thoroughly impressed with the CLARITY, DETAILS, COLORS and BLACK LEVELS. If you're a fan of this Franchise it may never look better and you WILL be satisfied. Though it does merit this coveted tier, its less-than-stellar moments must, of necessity, bring it down to the bottom.
AQ-wise, the Dolby Atmos mix was impressive in a few scenes, but the majority of the film was focused on the front stage.
Tier Recommendation: 1.75*
Joined
·
687 Posts
I was waiting for your review. I'll put the set on my wishlist. Thanks Denny!
Joined
·
6,901 Posts
Hey Tim,
I should mention that at least one "highly respected reviewer" (from Do.Blu.com....not Phantom
) was quite critical of the PQ and gave it a low "3 Star rating." Every other review echoes my sentiments and some go beyond what I wrote and feel it is "Reference Quality." I will stand by my review though for the reasons stated. I will look forward to hearing your take on it so be sure to "chime in" after viewing it.Denny
Joined
·
4,693 Posts
My copy is actually in the mail somewhere, looking lost! Whenever it does show up, I'll try giving my thoughts.
Joined
·
6,901 Posts
Maybe it was sent "back to the future!"
Joined
·
6,901 Posts
Back to the Future 2 (UHD)
A definite improvement over the first installment. No softness or lack of details and depth...and better clarity, details, colors and black levels. The AQ was also better. The only downside...the movie sucks in comparison. I had never seen this before and I may never see it again. Having said that, I have seen Back to the Future 3 and it is very good, but I'm pumped to see the UHD version which I'm expecting to have an even greater uptick in resolution.
Tier Recommendation: 1.0*
PS I almost went with Tier 0 (.9). There were many "Reference Quality" shots!
A definite improvement over the first installment. No softness or lack of details and depth...and better clarity, details, colors and black levels. The AQ was also better. The only downside...the movie sucks in comparison. I had never seen this before and I may never see it again. Having said that, I have seen Back to the Future 3 and it is very good, but I'm pumped to see the UHD version which I'm expecting to have an even greater uptick in resolution.
Tier Recommendation: 1.0*
PS I almost went with Tier 0 (.9). There were many "Reference Quality" shots!
Joined
·
499 Posts
Set-Up, The (Warner Archive)
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
Gun Crazy (Warner Archive)
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
Day the Earth Caught Fire, The (Kino Lorber)
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
Gun Crazy (Warner Archive)
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
Day the Earth Caught Fire, The (Kino Lorber)
recommendation: Tier 3.0*
Joined
·
4,693 Posts
Daughters of Darkness 4K UHD
recommendation: Tier 1.25*
Blue Underground's new limited edition may be expensive but the beautiful film transfer they've struck is well worth the price of admission. This is an incredible 4K scan of the original, long-lost camera negative with a full Dolby Vision HDR pass! Having owned the older Blu-ray, I've never seen such an improvement in picture quality going from 1080P to 2160P resolution. Marvelous fine detail in the largely unprocessed film scan and a truly faithful presentation that duly captures every pixel possible with maximum color fidelity.
The 1971 vampire thriller has never looked this good. If not for a few minor inconsistencies in the original cinematography, I would have felt no guilt placing this UHD in Tier Zero.
recommendation: Tier 1.25*
Blue Underground's new limited edition may be expensive but the beautiful film transfer they've struck is well worth the price of admission. This is an incredible 4K scan of the original, long-lost camera negative with a full Dolby Vision HDR pass! Having owned the older Blu-ray, I've never seen such an improvement in picture quality going from 1080P to 2160P resolution. Marvelous fine detail in the largely unprocessed film scan and a truly faithful presentation that duly captures every pixel possible with maximum color fidelity.
The 1971 vampire thriller has never looked this good. If not for a few minor inconsistencies in the original cinematography, I would have felt no guilt placing this UHD in Tier Zero.
Joined
·
4,693 Posts
Back To The Future 4K UHD
recommendation: Tier 1.75*
I'm in full agreement with Denny on this fine transfer and 4K presentation from Universal. There's nothing visibly untoward in the film scan's processing, producing a fine image harvest with excellent detail. Back To The Future looks very good on UHD. It's a film-like transfer with proper saturation and accurate color tonality.
Without knowing insider details on this particular release, I suspect some very sophisticated grain management tools have been applied. Which doesn't matter all that much at the end of the day, as the superb PQ results speak for themselves. This is a satisfying UHD purchase, though it's not quite up there with the best of the best on the format.
Don't take this relatively low score as a condemnation, it's merely a reflection of the movie's inherent limitations. The presentation consistently delivers a wonderfully pleasing contrast with rich, warm colors.
Back To The Future happens to be one of my most memorable theater-going experiences and I vividly remember seeing it for the first time all those years ago. This is the first time watching the movie on home video that I feel the presentation nearly matches those visual memories.
Joined
·
6,901 Posts
Back to the Future 3 (UHD)
PQ-wise, they "saved the best for last." Having said that, it started out a "mixed bag" with sporadic "soft shots" resulting in poor resolution and a lack of details and depth. I also detected some "noise" in a couple of those scenes. Other scenes were very good, though not "reference quality." Then at about one-third way into the film the PQ really "came alive" with unbelievable SHARPNESS, exemplary DETAILS, inky BLACKS, and incredible DEPTH. It was "Reference Quality" all the way to the end! Colors were pretty good, though there was a fair amount of "color-grading" (orange hues).
This is a hard one to call. If the whole film was like the second half, I'd easily nominate this for the middle of Tier 0, but when putting everything on the scales, I figure it was about the same as BttF2. So my vote goes for....
Tier Recommendation: Tier 0* (.9)
PS I simply couldn't resist going a tad higher due to the EYE CANDY in the last half to two-thirds!
PQ-wise, they "saved the best for last." Having said that, it started out a "mixed bag" with sporadic "soft shots" resulting in poor resolution and a lack of details and depth. I also detected some "noise" in a couple of those scenes. Other scenes were very good, though not "reference quality." Then at about one-third way into the film the PQ really "came alive" with unbelievable SHARPNESS, exemplary DETAILS, inky BLACKS, and incredible DEPTH. It was "Reference Quality" all the way to the end! Colors were pretty good, though there was a fair amount of "color-grading" (orange hues).
This is a hard one to call. If the whole film was like the second half, I'd easily nominate this for the middle of Tier 0, but when putting everything on the scales, I figure it was about the same as BttF2. So my vote goes for....
Tier Recommendation: Tier 0* (.9)
PS I simply couldn't resist going a tad higher due to the EYE CANDY in the last half to two-thirds!
Joined
·
4,693 Posts
I've been thinking about your question the past day. I probably should have done this earlier but I sincerely thought I'd get more free time at some point.
As of now, there is no separate 4K UHD list. Maybe that needs to change. That seems to be where all the energy is these days reviewing discs.
Most UHDs from newer productions land in Tier 0 with older movies usually ending up in Tier 1. Tier 0 is updated through early January 2019. There have obviously been many UHD placements made in the thread over the past two years that aren't reflected in the current list.
If someone else would like to take over my duties running the PQ Tiers and regularly updating the list, I'm open to passing the baton. I'd do this myself but other priorities currently take precedence, unfortunately. I'm not leaving the thread by any means but updates may have to be made by others.
I think all of us here want a smoothly functioning PQ Tiers that remains in operation.
As of now, there is no separate 4K UHD list. Maybe that needs to change. That seems to be where all the energy is these days reviewing discs.
Most UHDs from newer productions land in Tier 0 with older movies usually ending up in Tier 1. Tier 0 is updated through early January 2019. There have obviously been many UHD placements made in the thread over the past two years that aren't reflected in the current list.
If someone else would like to take over my duties running the PQ Tiers and regularly updating the list, I'm open to passing the baton. I'd do this myself but other priorities currently take precedence, unfortunately. I'm not leaving the thread by any means but updates may have to be made by others.
I think all of us here want a smoothly functioning PQ Tiers that remains in operation.
26561 - 26580 of 26587 Posts
Join the discussion
Join now to ask and comment!