AVS Forum banner

1 - 11 of 11 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
56 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·

So I have a W1070, very satisfied with it. Just wondering if there is anything universally "better" out there where you aren't necessarily making a tradeoff. For example, even the new BenQ W7500 seems to have a much worse input lag, which seems very disappointing. Going to LCD you get the worse lag, and apparently crosstalk in 3D (but no RBE).

 

Just seems like everything is a tradeoff. Wondering if there is a way to just "step up" without needing to give anything up. For the record I think the W1070 is pretty brilliant aside from minor RBE, and perhaps less than perfect black levels. 
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,375 Posts
Since the W1070's release, there hasn't really been anything of note (that would be in place on this section of the forums) to represent a significant step up.

That's changed recently with Sony's HW40ES, which is considerably pricier than the W1070 but certainly represents the 'step up' you're referring to.

You'll get some of LCD's disadvantages (being an LCOS unit) - motion blur tends to be more noticeable, 3D has a bit more cross-talk. Panel alignment (even once corrected to the nearest pixel) may reduce comparative sharpness. Low lag requires switching picture modes.

But of course you'll also get some serious advantages: much quieter fans, no RBE (assuming it gets noticed to begin with), better lens shifting (therefore much more placement flexibility), and over double the contrast.

The contrast improvement is something of note: I suspect the W1070's relatively low measured contrast is more due to its poor black levels (contrast ratio is a function of black level), since few would describe the picture it puts out as obviously lacking in contrast (without measuring it). But black level is a metric that matters to most (I'd say black level is the one real improvement that'd compel me to consider the W1070's successor when/if it arrives.)

The question, then, is really regarding the law of diminishing returns: at over triple the price, I might rather stick a W1070 in place of (or in addition to) every TV in my house :)

If anyone finds themselves in a position to compare these two projectors side-by-side, I'd be very interested in those findings.

But in answering the original question: it's the Sony for sure.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
56 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
Which is funny, because I am now looking at the 40es. But I am not so sure about the trade offs for 3x the price. But in fact, my biggest complaint with the BenQ is unquestionably the noise.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,375 Posts
Which is funny, because I am now looking at the 40es. But I am not so sure about the trade offs for 3x the price. But in fact, my biggest complaint with the BenQ is unquestionably the noise.

Bright bulb, small chassis, lots of heat... It has (at least) 3 separate fans. My air con in the room is louder (and on all the time) so the projector doesn't bother me - but there's no denying it's a bit noisy, even in its price class.

Side-note: my old W1070 had a rattling fan (very common issue at a point) that made it much, much noisier than my current one... Yours isn't rattling (ie grinding/cricket-noise), is it? Because if it is, it's a valid reason for an RMA.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
56 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Which is funny, because I am now looking at the 40es. But I am not so sure about the trade offs for 3x the price. But in fact, my biggest complaint with the BenQ is unquestionably the noise.

Bright bulb, small chassis, lots of heat... It has (at least) 3 separate fans. My air con in the room is louder (and on all the time) so the projector doesn't bother me - but there's no denying it's a bit noisy, even in its price class.

Side-note: my old W1070 had a rattling fan (very common issue at a point) that made it much, much noisier than my current one... Yours isn't rattling (ie grinding/cricket-noise), is it? Because if it is, it's a valid reason for an RMA.
Yup, mine has started to develop the rattle when using smarteco mode. Doesn't really do it in eco mode, but I prefer the picture in smarteco...

Looking to see how they might fix it, they seemed to have a live chat before when my remote was broken and now I cannot find it. I did send their support an email however.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,375 Posts
Which is funny, because I am now looking at the 40es. But I am not so sure about the trade offs for 3x the price. But in fact, my biggest complaint with the BenQ is unquestionably the noise.




Bright bulb, small chassis, lots of heat... It has (at least) 3 separate fans. My air con in the room is louder (and on all the time) so the projector doesn't bother me - but there's no denying it's a bit noisy, even in its price class.



Side-note: my old W1070 had a rattling fan (very common issue at a point) that made it much, much noisier than my current one... Yours isn't rattling (ie grinding/cricket-noise), is it? Because if it is, it's a valid reason for an RMA.


Yup, mine has started to develop the rattle when using smarteco mode. Doesn't really do it in eco mode, but I prefer the picture in smarteco...



Looking to see how they might fix it, they seemed to have a live chat before when my remote was broken and now I cannot find it. I did send their support an email however.

Which I guess brings us to our next advantage of much-more-expensive units: Quality Control :)
Older W1070 builds had poor brightness uniformity, seemed more prone to dust, had the rattling fans and had that shoddy non-backlit remote. When comparing my new one, all of these issues seem (I hope!) sorted in the newer build, so maybe QC has improved. (Again: I hope!)

But yeah, SmartECO has the fans running higher so it's going to be more noticeable in that mode. See what you can do about an RMA: if you're still in warranty, you're definitely covered (people around these forums have done the same successfully).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
56 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
Which is funny, because I am now looking at the 40es. But I am not so sure about the trade offs for 3x the price. But in fact, my biggest complaint with the BenQ is unquestionably the noise.




Bright bulb, small chassis, lots of heat... It has (at least) 3 separate fans. My air con in the room is louder (and on all the time) so the projector doesn't bother me - but there's no denying it's a bit noisy, even in its price class.



Side-note: my old W1070 had a rattling fan (very common issue at a point) that made it much, much noisier than my current one... Yours isn't rattling (ie grinding/cricket-noise), is it? Because if it is, it's a valid reason for an RMA.


Yup, mine has started to develop the rattle when using smarteco mode. Doesn't really do it in eco mode, but I prefer the picture in smarteco...



Looking to see how they might fix it, they seemed to have a live chat before when my remote was broken and now I cannot find it. I did send their support an email however.

Which I guess brings us to our next advantage of much-more-expensive units: Quality Control :)
Older W1070 builds had poor brightness uniformity, seemed more prone to dust, had the rattling fans and had that shoddy non-backlit remote. When comparing my new one, all of these issues seem (I hope!) sorted in the newer build, so maybe QC has improved. (Again: I hope!)

But yeah, SmartECO has the fans running higher so it's going to be more noticeable in that mode. See what you can do about an RMA: if you're still in warranty, you're definitely covered (people around these forums have done the same successfully).
Yup, bought it new only a few months ago. Should still be under warranty.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12,279 Posts
I think the panasonic PT-AE8000U is a significant step up from the BenQ 1070. Since the BenQ and Epson 8350 are about on the same plane. I had an 8350 for a couple years and my cousin has a 1070. I like my new AE8000U quite a bit. $1900 after rebate.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
300 Posts
I have a friend that has a 8350 and I have the 1070 and the pic is night and day (BenQ wins). And the BenQ is much sharper and has better colors....at least to me. How does the BenQ compare to the ae8000? I almost bought the panny.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
120 Posts
Having never seen the Benq, I can't be 100% sure it's a candidate, but I recently purchased the Optoma HD30b. It's not in the Sony class, but is between the Benq and Sony in price. It has good blacks, is quiet, and projects a very good image. One of the reasons I got the HD30b, is because it also is not as bright as a lot of the other under $2000.00 units, and my room and screen are relatively small, (the screen is 92"). There's also no light to worry about. So, if you don't need a light canon, it may fit quite nicely.
Larry
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12,279 Posts
Just be aware JoeBoy73 that the room, darkness, screen, distance, screen size etc will all play into your impression on a projector. My understanding is there is no way there is a night and day difference between the BenQ 1070 and the Epson 8350 -- just from reading reviews. I've never compared them side by side in the same room. Nor have I compared the 8350 to the 8000 side by side in the same room. My AE8000U arrived after I sold my 8350. However - the AE8000U is a clear step up from my 8350 on every front.
 
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
Top