I Think Cinemar is the nicest theater I've seen on this forum lately.. based on aesthetics... its beautiful. the workmanship is awesome. and the documentation of the build is superb. Now to answer which one I'd trade for that is tougher. I'd want to demo a few as audio/visualally its hard to tell which one provides the best presentation based on reading about them.... especially considering I have only been in 1 real home theater in my life and it wasnt in a home but in a best buy magnolia demo room..