[MichaelHDDVD]

Please vote only for The Matrix Reloaded only after you have watched the entire movie.

 

[MichaelHDDVD]

Watch the part of the movie when Neo and Trinity get it on during the zion dance scene... You'll see what I'm talking about, that imo knocks it down from tier 0 to high tier 1

 

[karlw2000]

Watch the part of the movie when Monica walks around in that yellow dress. You should notice she isn't wearing any underwear

.

 

[cleaver]

I can't believe tier 0 is winning. It's not even high tier 1; it pretty good but not as good as The Matrix. I can only assume some voters watched The Matrix and assumed they were all that good.

 

[Mustang1]

who's the idiot who voted tier 4??

 

[NoThru22]



Quote:
Originally Posted by cleaver /forum/post/0


but not as good as The Matrix.

Are you serious? There was only one scene in this movie where I saw digital compression but there were tons in the Matrix.

 

[MichaelHDDVD]

Besides the aforementioned scene with Trinity and Neo the rest is very good

 

[MidnightWatcher]

Who the heck is this carlosg character? Maybe eXgo under a new name?

 

[DrCrawn]



Quote:
Originally Posted by MidnightWatcher /forum/post/0


Who the heck is this carlosg character? Maybe eXgo under a new name?

He owns a Tosh player...apparently...

 

[Django]



Quote:
Originally Posted by MichaelHDDVD /forum/post/0

Please vote only for The Matrix Reloaded only after you have watched the entire movie.

I think you should have clarified, for the less informed, what each tier represents. Looking at some people vote tier 4 is appalling to me.

 

[MichaelHDDVD]

Someone also voted Tier 4 in The Matrix poll. That is why I made it so people can see who votes. imo we have more worry about overvotes for Tier 0 from people who are basing the PQ from online reviews instead of personal viewing experience.

 

[smfchris]

I got my trilogy set early last week (thank you WHV!) and got to watch all 3 at least 2 times from start to finish. All 3 are really great transfers and have awesome PQ & AQ, but to my eyes Reloaded seemed to look the best of the 3 by a fraction. Tier 0

 

[flyersfan]

I'll have to check out the rave/love scene again (even if it makes me cringe) for compression artifacts. But my gut reaction was Tier 0 for all 3.

 

[cnickersonjr]



Quote:
Originally Posted by Mustang1 /forum/post/0


who's the idiot who voted tier 4??

someone with nothing else to do!

 

[cnickersonjr]

Voted Tier 0, wanted to say -1. It is the best looking HD-DVD I've seen to date. By by HULK, hello MATRIX.

 

[nyg]

I'm voting Tier 1 for the entire Matrix series. Each movie looks and sounds phenomenal. That said, IMO Tier 0 should be reserved for 100% perfect discs which I have yet to see any of on either format.

 

[thehun]

I always skip the love/rave scene, since I saw it in the theaters, so I have no idea what's the problem there, so my vote was based on what I actually saw[ the rest].

 

[Milt99]

Definitely a step up from The Matrix, both PQ and AQ.

I don't like the tier thing but I'm voting tier 0.

FWIW, some people really like to trash Reloaded but upon re-viewing,

I liked it and thought it was a very worthy continuation of the first.

Certainly better than many sequels in a trilogy format, miles ahead of the pointless\\mindless DMC.

BTW, why isn't this a public poll?

Reason should be obvious.

 

[Slim GoodBooty]

It's Tier -1.

 

[dad1153]

Tier 0 all the way. Maybe its my Olevia 747i 1080p LCD's Realta HQV but damn if "Reloaded" didn't look as flawless and near-perfect as "Revolutions" and the original "Matrix."