AVS Forum banner
  • Get an exclusive sneak peek into our new project. >>> Click Here

Why DONT manufacturers have Greyscale dialed in pre-sale?

1112 Views 8 Replies 6 Participants Last post by  Michael TLV
So. As I have now seen probably 2 dozen BEFORE shots of peoples Greyscale RGB graphs, I see that pretty much all TV's ship with the Greyscale basically out of whack. At least in terms of a good D65 Greyscale calibration goes with fully balanced RGB.


Why do they do that? In the digital realm, these sets can be made within a percent or two of a reference. I know this from working with LCD displays on computers. There's sometimes a dud in the batch but they are pretty close in a quality brand/model release.


And what TV out there is already 99% dialed in out of the box? Is there such a TV? Plain old accurate and 99% calibrated already? In the Plasma world would be nice.


C.
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
because side by side next to a wall of really blue white (12000K) super bright(400cd/m) display a nicely calibrated (6500K) normal (120cd/m) display just looks dull.


TV's are designed to sell, not for the best picture.


I hear some pioneer displays can are closer than others and have great service menu controls to repair the factory settings.
if manufacturers dialed in accurate grayscales at 6500k color temperature they would get a lot of customers returning tv's complaining they're too dim or not buying in the first place.

Quote:
Originally Posted by sotti /forum/post/15408158


because side by side next to a wall of really blue white (12000K) super bright(400cd/m) display a nicely calibrated (6500K) normal (120cd/m) display just looks dull.


TV's are designed to sell, not for the best picture.


I hear some pioneer displays can are closer than others and have great service menu controls to repair the factory settings.

pioneer kuro's even has a setting to set the tv for home or retail when coming out of service menu.
Displays are also generally set up by eye on the line, at least grayscale is. They get an upload of preset values, then the final white balance (grayscale) is done by eye, for "best white" in the case of my older Mitsubishi.
Greetings


There is a little thing called ... "The marketing of a TV set has nothing to do with producing accurate images. It has everything to do with selling TVs."


If manufacturers figure out that they will sell more TVs if they make pictures GREEN ... guess what ... they make pictures GREEN.


If you want close ... you pick the pure mode on the pioneers ... the movie mode on the Samsung ... the Cinema mode on the Panasonic.


the TV's already come with those modes.


Try selling a TV on a showroom floor with only a movie mode. You won't be in business very long.


And while we are at this ... why can't someone sell a piano that is properly tuned from the factory?



Regards
See less See more
Very good points, and here's just another twist...


Imagine a production line with hundreds (and thousands) of TV's getting assembled, tested, packed and shipped out the door. If the major manufacturers attempted to calibrate all those TV's, (or even tried to get close) it would take forever to get all those TV's out the door. Which would mean decreased production, higher costs, etc (you get the idea).


Unfortunately MichaelTLV is right, the majority of customers out there aren't looking for a calibrated TV, they just want something big, flat, bright, colorful and sharp to hang on their walls. The minority of us who actually want a calibrated and correct (or as close to as possible) picture unfortunately have to deal with tolerances differences in the panel, and circuity behind the TV that only put us in the ballpark of being calibrated.
While I understand my Cinema mode on my PZ85 is pretty close, I still believe that the digital world allows for more sameness in a production line. It's not that impossible in the end. But I understand there is a bit of variance in the screen from unit to unit.


I guess the Pure/Cinema/Movie/Pro modes on these displays get "closer" to "accurate" with more money spent. I know the Kuro's were close to double the price of my TV at the time of purchase for the same size.


Thanks for the feedback.


C.
Greetings


So it comes down to what you want to pay? Double the price gets you closer ...


The idea would be that they sent a person to each and every home 30 days after purchase ... now factor another $150 into that. Travel time for the tech and hey wait ... you have to train them too ... and time on the job ...


Most people ... 99% of them ... would rather save the money.


BTW ... you are getting more sameness now in the Digital world. In the CRT days ... the variation between TVs was way way more. A CRT RP TV could arrive at a persons home at 60% operation capability (while capable of 100%) ... but the move to the flat panels pushed that number to 75% ... so most people would now get a better operating product in their homes.


Regards
See less See more
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top