AVS Forum banner
  • Our native mobile app has a new name: Fora Communities. Learn more.

Will a Harmony (or any brand) benfit me?

308 Views 2 Replies 2 Participants Last post by  Dustin Windsor
I'm learning i should think about keeping my HDMI CEC to off which means i need a universal remote? Not sure i read that correct to be honest.


I have never had a universal remote and wondering if it would benefit me - i see the Harmony 665 on sale right now.
I only have 3 remotes (smart TV which i like), receiver and my minix box which is a tiny remote).


Knowing nothing about remotes would i get any benefit of only have 3 of them now which sit beside me? I don't have cable, or a bluray player.
I'm interested and curious, thanks!
1 - 3 of 3 Posts
Why are you considering turning CEC off? Leaving it on should enable you to control your AVR volume with your TV remote and Minix remote as well as automatically switch to/from the Minix input. Plus you pretty much have to leave CEC on in order to use ARC to get audio from your smart TV to your AVR.

Obviously a single universal will control all your devices and automate the task of powering up/down everything at once and switching inputs (something CEC is probably doing now). CEC interferes with the commands that Harmony is sending, so it has to be turned off. You also have to find an alternate solution to ARC which usually involves running an optical cable and managing another input.

I'm a huge universal remote proponent. But, I find that my TV remote and CEC does 99.9% of what I need to do these days. On the rare occasion I watch a disc, I grab my universal. Otherwise, I just use the TV remote for everything.

I do question what purpose the Minix serves if you have a Sony smart TV which can presumably do just about everything the Minix does, especially if you put your audio/video library on a sever and access via Plex or similar.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Why are you considering turning CEC off? Leaving it on should enable you to control your AVR volume with your TV remote and Minix remote as well as automatically switch to/from the Minix input. Plus you pretty much have to leave CEC on in order to use ARC to get audio from your smart TV to your AVR.

Obviously a single universal will control all your devices and automate the task of powering up/down everything at once and switching inputs (something CEC is probably doing now). CEC interferes with the commands that Harmony is sending, so it has to be turned off. You also have to find an alternate solution to ARC which usually involves running an optical cable and managing another input.

I'm a huge universal remote proponent. But, I find that my TV remote and CEC does 99.9% of what I need to do these days. On the rare occasion I watch a disc, I grab my universal. Otherwise, I just use the TV remote for everything.

I do question what purpose the Minix serves if you have a Sony smart TV which can presumably do just about everything the Minix does, especially if you put your audio/video library on a sever and access via Plex or similar.

I appreciate this, i honestly never noticed i can use my A1E remote to control my receiver and Minix. Do i need to configure it or program it to work with them?
I actually use my Minix for my external Hard Drives only - i never use it for any apps/functions. Out of Habit i have 5 (now going on 6), 4 TB hard drives filled with stuff i access.


Are you saying i can take my "WD My Book HD's" and plug them into the A1E and get HDR etc instead of using Minix?


Edit - very cool, my A1E plays Kodi and my HD's lol i had no idea. The downside is ARC doesn't play the good audio formats -i guess i will continue to use my Minix. It was a fantastic suggestion!
  • Like
Reactions: 1
1 - 3 of 3 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top